Short Stature
Dorit Koren
Adda Grimberg
INTRODUCTION
Linear growth is an integral part of childhood development. Human growth generally occurs in a predictable pattern:
Rapid growth of intrauterine life—how much the fetus grows is primarily determined by maternal health and nutrition.
Less rapid growth of infancy—genetic factors gradually come into play and eventually outweigh the intrauterine conditions that initially determined fetal size; in practice, this means that infants often cross growth percentiles (channelize) to a percentile more in line with their genetic potential, whether tall or short. Growth gradually slows such that average rates of growth are 25 cm over first year of life and 10 cm over second year of life.
Slow, relatively constant rate of growth of early-to-mid childhood: from ages 2 to beginning of puberty: 4 to 6 cm/year.
Growth acceleration of mid-puberty—also known as the pubertal “growth spurt”—occurs early in puberty in girls (Tanner stages 3 to 4) and later in puberty in boys (Tanner stages 4 to 5). Average peak pubertal growth velocity: 9 cm/year in females and 10.3 cm/year in males. (This difference in growth velocity and, the fact that puberty [and hence, growth plate fusion] occurs later in boys than in girls, underlies the average 13 cm difference between the 50th percentile height for men and women.)
Cessation of growth with epiphyseal (growth plate) fusion.
Deviations from this pattern may represent a number of different possibilities, including the benign variants of normal growth to abnormal patterns with a wide differential diagnosis ranging from an underlying genetic abnormality, psychosocial or nutritional deprivation, endocrine abnormalities, or systemic illness. Early detection of any such deviations, with diagnosis and treatment of underlying illness (if any), is essential to maximizing potential adult height. Thus, interval growth should be accurately assessed at each child care visit, and any deviations from standard growth patterns should be evaluated. It is crucial to differentiate between normal variants of growth and abnormal patterns—that is, between a healthy petite child and a child with an underlying systemic illness and/or other abnormality of growth.
Definition of Important Terms
Short stature: Because height is a continuous variable, the definition of “short” involves a selected cutoff; a height that is more than 2 standard deviations (SD) below the mean for age and sex is the most commonly accepted threshold. It is important to recall that, given the nature of bell curves and SDs, ˜2% of the population (including a number of healthy children) will obligatorily be classified as short by definition. Thus, short stature may or may not be pathological. It is important to take the child’s height and growth velocity in the context of the overall picture, including the variables discussed below.
Height/growth velocity: The annualized rate of linear growth.
Growth failure: A height velocity that is less than expected for a child’s age, sex, genetic potential (as determined by parental heights—see below), and stage of puberty; alternately defined as the crossing downward of two or more major height percentiles (beyond 2 years of age) and/or dropping below the third height percentile.
Chronological age: Age since birth.
Bone/skeletal age: The stage of bone development or maturation as assessed by radiography.
Assessment of Growth
Length/Stature
Measurement of length/stature must be accurate and reproducible in order to correctly assess the degree of interval growth. Children >2 years should be measured supine, children >3 years should be measured standing, and children between ages 2 and 3 years can be measured either way, depending on the child’s ability to stand erect for the time it takes to be measured. Recumbent lengths should be recorded on the length (ages from birth to 36 months) chart and standing heights on the height (ages 2 to 20 years) chart, as they will differ slightly. Recumbent length is best measured with the child’s head against an inflexible board in the Frankfurt plane (wherein the long axis of the trunk is perpendicular to the line formed by connecting the inferior margin of the eyes to the top of the external auditory meatus), legs fully extended, and the feet placed perpendicularly against a movable footboard. To measure height, a stadiometer fixed to the wall is most accurate. The child’s feet are placed together in parallel to each other, and the child’s heels, buttocks, thoracic spine, and back of head should all be up against the stadiometer’s vertical axis. The child should be standing fully erect, heels touching the ground, and the head must be in the Frankfurt plane (see above).
Growth Charts
Evaluation of a child’s current height and overall growth pattern occurs within the context of standards typical for the population. Most general pediatric and pediatric endocrine offices use the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) growth charts—percentile curves that illustrate the distribution, in U.S. children, of length or height, weight, head circumference (for ages from birth to 36 months), and body mass index (BMI + weight (kg)/height (m)2 for ages 2 to 20 years). The data used to construct the 2000 growth curves came from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. The CDC growth curves were derived from cross-sectional population surveys, rather than longitudinal surveys that follow the same children over a course of years to determine their growth rates over time. Therefore, an individual’s growth pattern may differ somewhat from the standardized pattern, especially during periods of rapid growth (infancy and the pubertal growth spurt).
In April 2006, the World Health Organization (WHO) released new international growth charts for children aged 0 to 59 months. Similar to the 2000 CDC growth charts, these charts describe weight for age, length (or stature) for age, weight for length (or stature), and body mass index for age, but the methodology for the infant growth charts differed. The growth of infants aged 0 to 24 months was tracked longitudinally, although the growth data on older children (up to 71 months of age) was obtained cross-sectionally; thus, the WHO charts for infants aged 0 to 24 months are in fact true growth standards, describing the linear growth of healthy children under optimal conditions. In September 2010, the CDC recommended that clinicians in the United States use the 2006 WHO growth charts, rather than the 2000 CDC growth charts, for tracking linear growth of children aged 0 to 24 months.
WHO charts are available online at www.who.int/childgrowth/standards/en.
Parental Heights
Because genetics play a large role in determining both the rate of maturation and the eventual adult height, it is important to consider the heights of the biological mother and father in order to place the child’s current stature and predicted height in proper context. A significant deviation from the familial growth pattern should raise suspicion of possible pathological processes.
Body Proportions
Several conditions underlying growth abnormalities cause disproportionate growth (e.g., extremities more shortened than trunk in SHOX insufficiency, skeletal dysplasias, and chondrodysplasias). Thus, measurement of the following body proportions can aid the diagnosis of the underlying defect:
Occipitofrontal head circumference
Lower body segment: distance from top of pubic symphysis to the floor
Upper body segment: distance from top of head to top of symphysis pubis
Arm span: distance between the tips of the middle digits with both arms fully extended
Published standards exist for each of these measurements relative to the child’s age.
Skeletal Maturation (Skeletal or Bone Age)
The determination of bone age is predicated on the fact that ossification centers appear and progress in a predictable sequence in most children, so that a radiograph may be compared to a standard. The bone age, or skeletal age, is the only quantitative determination of somatic maturation; thus, it mirrors the tempo of growth and maturation and gives an indication of the remaining growth potential. Once the child is beyond infancy, an anteroposterior (AP) radiograph of the left hand and wrist is taken and compared to published standards (Greulich-Pyle or Tanner-Whitehouse method); knee films can be used at ages when hand/wrist films are not yet informative. Factors that impact the rate of skeletal maturation include genetic predisposition, thyroid hormone, growth hormone (GH), insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1, glucocorticoids, and estrogens (in children of both sexes). Once a bone age is assigned, this value, in combination with the child’s present height, is entered into one of several commonly used algorithms (Bayley-Pinneau, Roche-Wainer-Thissen, or Khamis-Roche method) to generate an adult height prediction. However, as demonstrated in a study published in Pediatrics in October 2010, a fair amount of variability exists between the predicted heights generated by these various methods. Thus, such predictions may be less reliable than was previously believed to be the case.
HINT: It is critical to evaluate the child’s present height in the greater context of the parents’ heights, the historical pattern of linear growth and weight gain, the presence or absence of abnormalities on history or physical examination, and the degree of skeletal maturation. These all help assess whether the growth pattern is pathological or a variant of normal.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS LIST
Normal Variants
Familial (genetic) short stature (excluding genetic problems inherited in an autosomal dominant fashion, which can also cause short stature in successive family generations)
Constitutional delay of growth and puberty
Intrauterine Growth Retardation (IUGR)
Metabolic or Genetic Causes
Bone Disorders
Osteochondrodysplasias: Genetic abnormalities of cartilage and/or bone. Examples:
Achondroplasia and hypochondroplasia
Achondrogenesis
Mesomelic dysplasias
Epiphyseal and metaphyseal dysplasias
Osteogenesis imperfecta
Chromosomal Abnormalities:
Trisomy 21
Turner syndrome
Trisomies 8, 13, 18
18q deletion
Other Genetic Conditions
Deletions of SHOX gene region of × (or Y) chromosome
Polymorphism—Chromosome 1q12, 2q36, 6q24, 12q11
Russell-Silver syndrome
Prader-Willi syndrome
Noonan syndrome
Others: Cornelia de Lange syndrome, insulin receptor gene mutations (leprechaunism, or “Donovan” syndrome), Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome, Aarskog syndrome, Bloom syndrome, Cockayne syndrome, progeria, Seckel syndrome)
Inborn Errors of Metabolism
Glycogen storage diseases
Galactosemia
Mucopolysaccharidoses
Glycoproteinoses
Mucolipidoses
Malnutrition
Protein-calorie (kwashiorkor)
Generalized (marasmus)
Anorexia nervosa
Bulimia nervosa
Nutritional dwarfing and failure to thrive
Micronutrient deficiencies (especially iron and zinc)
Psychosocial (Deprivation) Dwarfism Iatrogenic
Chronic glucocorticoid exposure (e.g., in severe asthma, inflammatory conditions)
Stimulant medications for attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder
Chronic Systemic Diseases
Renal Disease
Fanconi syndrome
Renal Tubular acidosis
Uremia/chronic renal failure
Heart Disease
Congenital (especially cyanotic)
Congestive heart failure
Malabsorption
Celiac disease
Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)
Short gut syndrome
Liver Disease
Chronic liver disease and/or liver failure
Lung Disease
Cystic fibrosis
Hematologic
Profound anemia
Thalassemia (especially if transfusion dependent)
Hemosiderosis
Oncologic
Primary malignancy
Secondary to chemotherapy
Secondary to irradiation
Collagen Vascular Diseases
Endocrine Disorders
Diabetes mellitus (DM) (Mauriac syndrome)
Glucocorticoid excess (Cushing syndrome)
Hypothyroidism
Growth hormone deficiency (GHD)
Primary IGF deficiency
GH insensitivity (Laron Dwarfism)
Post-GH receptor defects
Pseudohypoparathyroidism
Rickets
Pituitary and/or hypothalamic dysfunction:
Structural abnormalities:
Associated with other midline defects (e.g., holoprosencephaly, septo-optic dysplasia)
Isolated hypothalamic/pituitary malformation/s (e.g., empty sella syndrome, ectopic neurohypophysis)
Trauma—generalized brain trauma or trauma specific to hypothalamus, pituitary stalk, or anterior pituitary
Surgical resection of pituitary and/or pituitary stalk
Inflammation of pituitary and/or hypothalamus
Brain and/or hypothalamic tumors (e.g., germinomas, gliomas)
Pituitary tumors (e.g., craniopharyngiomas, histiocytosis X)
Irradiation of brain and/or hypothalamus
Genetic causes:
Idiopathic GHD
Growth hormone releasing hormone (GHRH) receptor mutation
Isolated: GH1 and GH2 mutations, CSHP1 mutation, CSH1 and CSH2 mutations, idiopathic
GH secretagogue receptor mutation
Multiple pituitary hormone deficiencies: HESX1 mutation, PROP1 mutation, POU1F1 mutation
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS DISCUSSION
A comprehensive discussion of all the causes of short stature is beyond the scope of this chapter. The following is a focused review of a select number of normal variants and abnormal causes of short stature (see section on “Differential Diagnosis List”).
Familial Short Stature
Familial short stature (FSS) is a height that, while representing the lower end of the population norm, is nonetheless in keeping with the child’s genetic potential. This is usually a normal variant. However, some causes of abnormal short stature such as GH gene deletions can be inherited in a dominant fashion, so even if there is a family history of short stature, taking a careful history, including heights and pubertal timing of parents, siblings and extended family members, and performing a focused physical examination remain important.
Clinical Features
Both parents’ heights are usually in the lower height percentiles, often below the 10th. The child’s pattern of growth is consistent with that of his/her parents (and often siblings, too). The child’s growth velocity is usually normal, so that the growth curve is low, but parallel to the normal lines. The predicted adult height is in keeping with midparental target height. In the absence of a family history of delayed puberty, the timing of puberty is usually average.
Evaluation
The past medical history, review of systems, and physical examination are typically unremarkable, with no abnormalities of body proportions in either the patient or the parents. As skeletal growth is not delayed, the bone age should be within the normal range. Laboratory workup, including growth factors and a chemistry panel, should be within the normal range. Abnormalities of history, physical examination, or laboratory studies should prompt the investigator to look for other causes of short stature.
Treatment
The child and family should be reassured that this is not a disease, that the child will likely enter puberty within the same average time frame as his or her peers, and that the child’s height will likely be in keeping with the family trend. As this is not a disease, treatment is not indicated.
Constitutional Growth Delay
(Also known as constitutional delay of growth and puberty or constitutional delay of growth and maturation)
Delayed puberty is defined as the absence of secondary sexual characteristics by an age that is delayed by more than 2 to 2.5 S.D. beyond the mean for the population: the absence of thelarche in girls over 12 years of age, of signs of puberty in boys over 13 years of age, or of menarche in girls over 16 years of age (primary amenorrhea). Constitutional delay of growth and puberty (CDGP) represents the late end of the spectrum of pubertal development. Children with CDGP enter puberty later than most of their peers. Thus, the pubertal growth spurt is also delayed, and these children continue to grow at the prepubertal rate of 4 to 6 cm/year while their peers’ height velocity increases, resulting in a gap between the heights of children with CDGP and the heights of age-matched peers—a transient relative short stature.