Introduction
Prune belly syndrome (PBS), also named Eagle–Barrett syndrome, is a rare multisystem congenital disorder with a triad presentation of urinary tract dilation, deficient abdominal-wall musculature ( Fig. 59.1 ), and bilateral undescended testes. Frohlich (1839) first described the distinct abdominal wall and then Parker (1895) described the full triad of anomalies. , The term prune belly syndrome was first coined by Osler in 1901. There is a broad spectrum of severity of the condition, with some patients not surviving the neonatal period, to others with minimal abnormalities. PBS affects 3.8 cases per 100,000 live births and the proportion of those of African descent with PBS is significantly greater than that of the general population (31% vs. 15%). Females represent <5% of PBS cases, and fewer than 30 cases have been described in the literature. , Females with PBS have abdominal-wall muscle deficiency and urinary tract dilation, but no gonadal anomalies.
Typical symmetric abdominal-wall laxity and bulging flanks seen in prune belly patients.
PBS can be one the most challenging conditions to manage for pediatric urologists and surgeons. Due to the low number of cases (10–20) seen, even at large institutions, evidence-based data is lacking. , The overall initial mortality rate is approximately 50% (20% stillborn, 30% initial hospital stay), and survival has not improved much in the last 50 years despite advances in perinatal and operative management. Perinatal mortality is usually related to prematurity and pulmonary conditions and surviving patients may suffer from high morbidity due to prematurity, varied degrees of urinary tract pathology, and associated cardiovascular, respiratory, orthopedic, and gastrointestinal anomalies. The condition is associated with low self-esteem due to its physical appearance, constipation, impaired physical mobility, and decreased fertility. Most will need multiple operative interventions for reconstruction. In a recent study, it was found that family members and patients had a lower overall quality of life compared with healthy children, secondary to lifelong medical disability leading to psychological, financial, and social issues.
Genetics
The etiology of PBS is unknown, yet the greater incidence in males, higher proportion of cases in those of African descent, and occurrence among twins (12.2/100,000 live births) suggests that PBS may have a genetic basis. Since most reported cases are in males, it has been suggested that the mode of inheritance may be sex-linked autosomal recessive. However, others feel it is likely purely autosomal recessive. , Sporadic cases of PBS have also been associated with other chromosomal abnormalities, including Turner syndrome and trisomies 13, 18, and 21. However, most cases of PBS occur sporadically in children with a normal karyotype. Only 11 cases of familial PBS have been reported. In addition, while PBS does occur more frequently in twins, most twins are discordant for PBS, favoring a developmental rather than a genetic cause. Thus, in the absence of any large cohort investigations, the general consensus remains that chromosomal abnormalities are not the main cause of PBS.
Embryology
Several theories regarding PBS embryogenesis have been proposed, with some overlap between theories. However, none have universal acceptance as no experimental model exists to test them. The first, and most widely accepted theory, is that of transient urethral obstruction during gestation, which causes massively distended bladder and ureters. , , This transient urethral obstruction may then interfere with the descent of the testicles, explaining the presence of bilateral cryptorchidism. The severe urinary tract dilation then causes abdominal-wall muscle atrophy resulting in the characteristic wrinkled, lax, and thin abdominal wall found in PBS patients. Obstruction is theorized to resolve (in most patients) prior to delivery. Delayed canalization of the urethra during the 11th–16th week of gestation is proposed as the mechanism for cases in which the urethra is patent at birth. Another hypothesis for the urethral obstruction is that it is created by a hypoplastic prostate, which may cause the unsupported urethra to twist or create a flap-like obstruction. This is sustained by the generalized presence of prostatic hypoplasia in PBS patients.
The abdominal mesodermal maldevelopment theory implies that between 6 and 10 weeks of gestation an unknown event to the mesoderm prevents normal development of the abdominal-wall muscles and urinary tract. , , Failure of migration of the lateral mesoderm explains the classic abdominal-wall appearance. In addition, a defect in the intermediate plate mesoderm is suggested because it would affect the development of the ureters, bladder, prostate, urethra, and gubernaculum, explaining the genitourinary abnormalities seen in PBS. A shortage of mesenchymal tissue during the third week of embryogenesis is suggested as the possible source of PBS within twins when the primitive streak is developing. However, an insult to the mesodermal layer should affect other organ systems, but this is not observed in PBS. , , Additional theories suggest an intrinsic defect in the urinary tract leading to ureteral dilation and subsequent PBS, and a yolk sac defect as another proposed etiology. , ,
Clinical Features
Genitourinary Anomalies
Bladder
PBS is characterized by a low-pressure dilated urinary system from the urethra to the renal pelvis. A typical bladder in PBS patients will be massively enlarged and smooth-walled without trabeculations. Histologically, muscle fibers are replaced by collagen and fibrous tissues. This loss of muscle fibers causes the bladder to bulge in multiple directions, giving the appearance of a pseudodiverticulum at the bladder dome ( Fig. 59.2 ). A patent urachus is present in 25%–30% of PBS patients. The bladder neck is poorly defined, and the urethra is dilated, with mucosal folds giving the appearance of obstruction on imaging. , , PBS patients typically demonstrate a normal compliance on urodynamic studies. However, a very large bladder capacity and a delay in the first sensation to void are often seen. , PBS bladders demonstrate poor detrusor contractions and variable emptying, with only 44% of PBS patients voiding spontaneously and 50% of patients having normal flow rates, voiding pressures, and low postvoid residuals. , Regardless of the voiding pattern, all PBS patients should be closely followed because bladder function may deteriorate throughout their life.
Appearance of a pseudodiverticulum at the bladder dome in a child with prune belly syndrome. The pseudodiverticulum develops because of the loss of muscle fibers in the bladder, which are replaced by collagen and fibrous tissue.
Ureters
The trigone is wider and the bilateral ureteral orifices are displaced more lateral than usual, which likely contributes to the presence of vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) in 75%–80% of patients ( Fig. 59.3 ). , , , The ureters are tortuous and severely dilated. , The degree of ureteral pathology can vary and has been shown to be segmental, with the distal ureter being the most affected ( Fig. 59.4 ). , Distally, the ureters have shown a greater decrease in muscle fibers and an increase in collagen and connective tissue fibers, which makes the proximal ureter more useful than the distal ureter for reconstruction. , This change in muscle fibers causes inefficient ureteral peristalsis and the development of upper tract urinary stasis and system dilation. , , , Obstruction at the ureterovesical junction (UVJ) and ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) are not common but have been reported. As the child grows and the ureters elongate, spontaneous improvement may occur in the ureteral appearance and function. ,
Voiding cystourethrogram in a patient with prune belly syndrome shows large, dilated distal ureters. The bladder is marked with an asterisk.
Marked dilation of the distal ureter ( asterisk ), which is often found in a child with prune belly syndrome.
Kidneys
Renal abnormalities range from completely normal to severely dysplastic kidneys. Dysplasia is present in 50% of PBS patients and in some cases, one kidney may be affected, with a normal contralateral kidney. The presence of hydronephrosis is also quite variable, and the degree of hydronephrosis does not correlate with the degree of dysplasia. , Hydronephrosis, when present, is typically nonobstructive. Progressive uropathy is known to occur, and nearly 20%–30% of PBS patients will progress to renal failure. The most accurate predictor of progression to end-stage renal disease (ESRD) is a nadir creatinine >0.7 mg/dL in the first 8 months of life. The degree of urinary system dilation is not a prognostic factor for renal function. Renal infection provides the greatest risk to renal function, and while early progression to ESRD may be attributed to severe renal dysplasia, later progression is attributed to renal damage from repeated infections and obstruction. , , , , Many patients with PBS will ultimately require renal transplantation.
Urethra
Several urethral anomalies have been described, including urethral obstruction and megalourethra. Although rare, obstruction of the urethra has been described in 20% of cases including urethral atresia, posterior urethral valves, and urethral stenosis. , Urethral atresia is usually fatal unless associated with a patent urachus, which allows drainage of urine. PBS is also associated with both types of megalourethra. , Scaphoid megalourethra, the most common and less severe form, is the deficiency of corpus spongiosum with intact bilateral corpora cavernosa ( Fig. 59.5 ). Fusiform megalourethra occurs when there is complete absence of corpus cavernosum and corpus spongiosum. , , With fusiform megalourethra, when the patient voids, the entire penis will enlarge, while with scaphoid megalourethra, only the anterior urethra dilates with voiding. Megalourethra is more commonly seen in PBS than any other syndromes, with 50% of cases occurring in association with PBS. , ,
Scaphoid megalourethra.
Prostate and Accessory Sex Organs
As mentioned, children with PBS have hypoplasia of the prostate and resultant dilation of the posterior urethra ( Fig. 59.6 ). The normal prostatic smooth muscle and epithelium are replaced by connective tissue. The prostatic urethra tapers as it becomes membranous due to redundant folds of mucosa, which may give the impression of obstruction on imaging. , Adult men with PBS usually have infertility that is multifactorial in etiology. Cryptorchidism, prostate secretory disorders, and retrograde ejaculation are contributory.43 Ejaculatory failure may occur due to the lack of normal prostatic tissue and retrograde ejaculation can result from the incompetent bladder neck. , , In addition, the vas deferens and the seminal vesicles are typically atretic, but dilation of these structures has also been described. Finally, there may be poor attachment between the testis and epididymis and between the efferent duct and the rete testis.
Posterior urethral dilation ( asterisk ) is often found in children with prune belly syndrome. This dilation is similar to that seen in boys with posterior urethral valves.
Extragenitourinary Anomalies
Up to 75% of children with PBS will have concomitant nongenitourinary diagnoses, with prematurity and respiratory conditions affecting around half of patients. Cardiovascular, pulmonary, gastrointestinal, and musculoskeletal conditions are also described. , , , , The severity of these comorbidities will dictate the initial postnatal course of these patients. Perinatal mortality (30%) is primarily related to prematurity and the degree of pulmonary hypoplasia. , , ,
Abdominal Wall
Abdominal-wall muscle deficiency is one of the most distinctive features in PBS. The abdomen has a wrinkled “prune like” appearance with bulging flanks ( Fig. 59.1 ). The degree of muscle deficiency varies, but typically the medial and inferior aspects of the abdomen are more severely involved. , In some cases, the musculature of the abdominal wall may be totally absent. As PBS children grow, the deposition of cutaneous abdominal adipose tissue increases reducing wrinkles, and a potbelly appearance ensues. , Due to the lack of abdominal support, they may develop lordosis. Gait usually is not affected, but walking may be delayed, and PBS infants tend to roll on their side in order to sit up. Due to poor lower chest-wall support, PBS patients also have a poor cough and are more prone to respiratory infections. ,
Cardiac and Pulmonary
Cardiopulmonary anomalies are present in 49%–60% of PBS patients. , , , During the neonatal period, stabilization and management of cardiac and pulmonary anomalies may take priority over genitourinary conditions. A significant number of PBS patients have patent ductus arteriosus, atrial septal defect, ventricular septal defect, or tetralogy of Fallot. , Patients can also suffer from pulmonary hypoplasia due to oligohydramnios, caused by bladder outlet obstruction (BOO), and renal dysplasia. Nearly half of PBS patients may need mechanical ventilation during the neonatal period. If severe pulmonary hypoplasia is present, it can result in newborn demise. Other associated lung anomalies include pneumothorax or pneumomediastinum. Reactive airway disease is found in 22% of patients, and as mentioned, due to poor lower chest-wall support, PBS patients have poor cough effectiveness and are more prone to respiratory infections and atelectasis. , It is also very important to note that PBS patients are more prone to respiratory failure from acute respiratory illness or anesthesia. Older patients may also develop restrictive lung disease secondary to musculoskeletal abnormalities. ,
Gastrointestinal
Greater than 30% of PBS patients suffer from gastrointestinal conditions, with one study demonstrating that 63% of living PBS patients have gastrointestinal diagnoses. , , The majority of anomalies are due to incomplete rotation of the midgut and the development of a wide mesentery, which may lead to increased bowel mobility in the capacious abdominal cavity predisposing patients to volvulus. In addition, intestinal atresia and stenosis have been reported. Intestinal atresia is more common than stenosis, with most occurring in the colon. Omphalocele, splenic torsion, gastroschisis, and anorectal malformations have also been described. , , Constipation affects 58% of PBS patients and is a lifelong problem due to the inability to generate adequate intraabdominal pressure, which may lead to acquired megacolon. ,
Musculoskeletal
Musculoskeletal anomalies are present in 21%–65% of PBS children. , , The etiology of such abnormalities is suspected to be in utero compression and the sequelae of oligohydramnios. The most common deformities are clubfoot and scoliosis, which are each seen in about a quarter of patients. Hip dysplasia, pectus excavatum/carinatum, and sacral agenesis have also been described.
Spectrum of Disease
There is a broad spectrum of disease severity, with some PBS patients not surviving the neonatal period, and others with minimal symptoms and near-normal life expectancy. Woodard described a classification system to aid in patient management in which PBS patients are sorted into three groups. , , , These categories, with their characteristics, prognosis, and management, are described in Table 59.1 .
Table 59.1
Classification System for Prune Belly Syndrome
| Category | Characteristics | Cases (%) | Prognosis | Management |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Renal dysplasia
Urethral atresia Oligohydramnios Pulmonary hypoplasia Club feet |
20 | Stillborn or die within a few days |
Interventions will not change course of events
Catheter drainage |
| 2 |
Typical triad physical features
Renal dysplasia minimal or unilateral No pulmonary hypoplasia May progress to renal failure |
40 | Variable |
Significant controversy in management
Early surgical intervention of urinary system to repair urine stasis, reflux or obstruction vs medical surveillance and management |
| 3 |
Incomplete triad features
No renal dysplasia No pulmonary dysplasia Stable renal function |
40 | Near normal life expectancy |
Routine follow-up
Interventions if recurrent urinary tract infection or upper tract deterioration develops |
Testes
Among the classic triad of PBS is bilateral intraabdominal undescended testes. The most common location of the testes is above the iliac vessels and adjacent to the dilated ureters. Data regarding PBS testicular histology is varied, with some reports stating no difference in germ cell count, spermatogonia, and Leydig cells between undescended testes in PBS patients and undescended testes found in non-PBS patients. , Meanwhile, other studies have described diminished spermatogonia and Leydig cell hyperplasia in PBS fetal testes suggesting an intrinsic testicular abnormality. Regardless of histology, azoospermia with little or no germ cell maturation is usually found in adult PBS patients. Currently, no PBS patient has been documented as having fathered a child naturally. As stated previously, this infertility is thought to be multifactorial. However, now with early orchidopexy, sperm retrieval, and microinjection of spermatozoa, PBS patients have better prospects for fertility, and more recently, the birth of two normal male infants was documented from a PBS father after intracytoplasmic sperm injection. , Cryptorchidism is also a well-known risk factor for testicular cancer, most commonly seminoma. , For this reason, PBS children should undergo early orchiopexy and long-term surveillance to improve testicular cancer detection.
Clinical Presentation
Prenatal Evaluation
Prenatal ultrasonography (US) has become the standard modality for prenatal evaluation worldwide and is an excellent tool for the evaluation of the urinary tract. The sonographic appearance of the PBS fetus is similar to those with urethral atresia and PUV. Sonographic findings include bilateral hydroureteronephrosis, a distended bladder, and an irregular abdominal circumference. , The prenatal diagnosis of PBS has been made as early as 11 weeks of gestation. , Prenatal vesicoamniotic shunting in fetuses with PBS has not been proven to improve postnatal renal function, and is only indicated in PBS patients with urethral atresia and severe oligohydramnios in order to improve postnatal pulmonary function. ,
Postnatal Evaluation
The classic triad of hydroureteronephrosis, abdominal-wall laxity, and bilateral nonpalpable testis is highly suggestive of the diagnosis of PBS, but there is a spectrum of presentation in the postnatal period. The evaluation of the patient born with PBS needs to be multidisciplinary. Centers involved in the care of these patients need to have the availability of a neonatologist, pediatric nephrologist, pediatric urologist and/or pediatric surgeon, as well as other pediatric subspecialties including cardiology, pulmonology, and orthopedics. Life-threatening conditions must be identified and treated promptly.
The urologic evaluation should focus on the status of the kidneys, identify BOO, and characterize the degree of urinary tract involvement. Complete evaluation of the urinary tract may include renal and bladder US, voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG), and renal scintigraphy, including dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA), diethylenetriamine (DTPA), mercaptoacetyltriglycine renal scans (MAG), and magnetic resonance urography (MRU). Initial and serial evaluation of a complete metabolic panel is also warranted. Any electrolyte abnormalities or abnormal levels of creatinine could indicate impaired future renal function. , Patients with bladder outlet obstruction need immediate bladder drainage via urethral catheterization, suprapubic tube, or cutaneous vesicostomy.
A renal-bladder US is often the initial radiological study performed and will provide information regarding renal size, parenchymal thickness, and degree of hydroureteronephrosis. The US can also evaluate the degree of bladder dilatation, its capacity to empty, and the presence of a urachal diverticulum. For most patients, VCUG is warranted and will identify VUR in up to 75% of patients. VCUG can also delineate the degree of bladder dilation, the presence of a urachal diverticulum, and rule out urethral obstruction. The possibility of introduction of bacteria into a urinary tract with urinary stasis mandates the use of suppressive antibiotics in patients undergoing urinary tract instrumentation. MAG-3 nuclear medicine scans allow for the evaluation of renal parenchymal function and the presence of obstruction. MRU may also be useful to delineate renal anatomy if unclear on standard imaging, but the need for sedation, high cost, in addition to the rare risk of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis, prohibits MRU as a first-line tool to evaluate the urinary tract. ,
Management Principles
The goals in the management of prune belly patients are to preserve renal function, avoid urinary tract infections (UTIs), and improve the patients’ quality of life. As noted above, due to urinary tract dilation and stasis, patients with PBS may be at increased risk of UTIs. Because of the decreased risk of UTI within the first year of life following circumcision in the general male population, circumcision may be recommended in PBS patients to decrease the risk of UTI. The consideration of antibiotic prophylaxis, judicious urinary tract instrumentation, an aggressive program of timed voiding/bladder emptying, and bowel management are also needed in patients with PBS to limit the number of UTIs in their lifetime.
There are differences in opinion regarding the need for early operative intervention, with much of the difference regarding management of category II patients ( Table 59.1 ). With the idea that UTI and progressive renal deterioration are the greatest threat to the PBS patient, some groups have advocated early aggressive reconstruction of the urinary tract. , , This approach includes ureteral shortening and tapering, ureteral reimplantation, bilateral orchiopexy, abdominoplasty, and reduction cystoplasty ( Fig. 59.7 ). This approach can be performed as early as 3–6 months in patients with good cardiac and pulmonary function. Woodard popularized this approach with excellent results. Others have recently reported similar good results with long-term follow-up.
In this prune belly syndrome patient undergoing reduction cystoplasty and bilateral ureteral reimplantation, note the severe ureteral ( U ) dilation seen prior to ureteral shortening and tailoring. B, bladder.
An alternative approach centers on surgical intervention on an as-needed basis. This approach is based on the belief that UTI and renal deterioration can be prevented with close surveillance and aggressive nonsurgical management in most PBS patients. Surgical intervention is then reserved only for the patients with proven obstruction and recurrent UTIs. , This approach has also been reported to have excellent results. , However, in patients with compromised respiratory status it may be beneficial to combine orchiopexy with other procedures, such as abdominoplasty or urinary system reconstruction, to limit the number of general anesthetics.
Surgical Management
Cutaneous Vesicostomy
In patients with BOO secondary to urethral atresia, PUV, or megalourethra causing urethral obstruction, a temporizing vesicostomy may be needed. To prevent prolapse, the vesicostomy is best performed at the dome of the bladder with resection of the large bladder diverticulum that is often found in PBS patients. Routine use of vesicostomy in all patients is discouraged as it may make future abdominal-wall reconstructions more difficult. Around 10% of PBS children undergo vesicostomy. ,
Bilateral Orchiopexy
The testes in most patients with PBS are found in the abdominal cavity. Preservation of hormonal function and the potential risk of malignancy in these testes are indications for orchiopexy. Although the fertility potential in patients with PBS is known to be poor, new fertility techniques could help with their fertility potential in the future. The timing for orchiopexy follows the same management of undescended testes for non-PBS patients, with repair after 6 months of corrected gestational age providing the best opportunity for a single-stage repair. Depending on the distance from the internal inguinal ring, the procedure can be performed with preservation of the testicular vessels or using the Fowler-Stephens single or staged procedures. The orchiopexies can be performed using a suprainguinal incision, a large midline incision with concomitant urinary tract reconstruction, or via a laparoscopic approach. The abdominal laxity allows for a large laparoscopic working space and easy visualization of the ureters, testes, and testicular vessels, and several groups have reported excellent results with this approach. A unique difficulty with laparoscopy in PBS is loss of insufflation secondary to port leaks that can be overcome with smaller incisions, purse-string sutures around the ports, and the use of higher flow rates. ,
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel
Full access? Get Clinical Tree