Key points
VULVAR PREMALIGNANT AND MALIGNANT DISEASE
- •
Squamous cell carcinomas constitute 90% of primary vulvar malignancies. More than 80% of patients are older than 50 years at the time of diagnosis.
- •
Cancer of the vulva accounts for approximately 4% of malignancies of the lower female genital tract and occurs less often than uterine, ovarian, and cervical cancers.
- •
Paget disease generally occurs in postmenopausal women and is usually treated by wide excision. Invasive carcinomas at other sites should be ruled out.
- •
Prolonged use of fluorinated corticosteroids to treat itching accompanying vulvar dystrophy can lead to vulvar contraction.
- •
Topical testosterone is sometimes beneficial to treat lichen sclerosus but is absorbed systemically and occasionally can produce masculinizing symptoms.
- •
Studies have indicated that symptomatic lichen sclerosus is a premalignant condition preceding carcinoma by a mean of 4 years. The tumors that develop tend to be clitoral in location and identified in patients older than age 40 years.
- •
Human papillomavirus (HPV) vulvar infection is common. Intraepithelial neoplasia occurs much less often.
- •
HPV-positive tumors tend to occur in younger patients, and these tumors tend to have a better prognosis than HPV-negative tumors.
- •
A clear progression of dysplasia–carcinoma in situ (vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia [VIN] I, II, and III) to invasive carcinoma in the vulva has not been clearly established. VIN may spontaneously regress. VIN III has an approximately 3.4% risk of progression to invasive carcinoma.
- •
Intraepithelial neoplasia of the vulva is usually treated by local excision. Laser therapy of the atypical area may be used for younger patients who do not have raised lesions.
- •
Vulvar carcinomas less than 2 cm in diameter and depth of invasion less than 1 mm rarely metastasize to regional nodes.
- •
Unilateral vulvar tumors (>2 cm from midline) usually metastasize to ipsilateral inguinofemoral nodes only.
- •
Prognosis in vulvar cancer is primarily related to lesion size, lymph node status, and stage.
- •
The risk of lymph node groin metastases is related to tumor differentiation, lesion thickness, lymphovascular space involvement, patient age, and tumor size.
- •
The deep pelvic nodes do not become involved with metastatic vulvar cancer unless the inguinofemoral nodes are affected.
- •
The 5-year survival rate of vulvar carcinoma with negative nodes is more than 95%. With one positive node, the 5-year survival is approximately the same, 94%; with two nodes, it decreases to 80% and with three or more to 12%.
- •
Advanced vulvar tumors encroaching on the urethra or anus may be treated by radiation followed by wide radical excision rather than exenteration. Enhanced results have also been reported with the combined use of chemotherapy and radiation.
- •
Verrucous carcinomas are a variant of squamous cancer that do not metastasize to regional nodes. Radiation therapy is contraindicated, and local surgical excision is the treatment of choice.
- •
Melanomas constitute 5% of vulvar cancers and are the most common non–squamous cell malignancies.
- •
The overall 5-year survival of patients with vulvar melanoma is approximately 50%.
- •
Superficial spreading melanomas tend to occur in younger patients and have a better prognosis than nodular melanomas.
- •
Prognosis of vulvar melanoma is related to tumor invasion (Clark level) and to tumor thickness.
- •
Basal cell carcinoma of the vulva is treated by wide local excision.
VAGINAL PREMALIGNANT AND MALIGNANT DISEASE
- •
Predisposing factors associated with the development of vaginal intraepithelial neoplasia include infection with HPV, previous radiation therapy to the vagina, immunosuppressive therapy, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection.
- •
The tendency of intraepithelial squamous neoplasia to develop anywhere in the lower female genital tract is termed a field defect and describes the increased risk of premalignant changes occurring in the cervix, vagina, or vulva.
- •
Most cases of vaginal intraepithelial neoplasia (VAIN) occur in the upper third of the vagina.
- •
VAIN can be treated by excision, laser, 5-fluoroucacil (5-FU), or imiquimod. Excision is often used for VAIN-3. Laser treatment is generally used for discrete lesions once invasion has been ruled out, and 5-FU and imiquimod cream are used to treat diffuse, multicentric, low-grade disease.
- •
The most common primary vaginal malignancy is squamous cell carcinoma (90%).
- •
Most cancers occurring in the vagina are metastatic.
- •
Vaginal cancers constitute less than 2% of gynecologic malignancies.
- •
Tumors of the upper vagina have a lymphatic drainage to the pelvis similar to cervical tumors. Tumors of the lower third of the vagina drain to the pelvic nodes and also to the inguinal nodes, similar to vulvar tumors.
- •
Radical surgery may be used to treat low-stage tumors, primarily of the upper vagina, in younger patients.
- •
Radiation therapy is the most commonly used modality for the treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the vagina. Ideally at least 7000 to 7500 cGy is administered in less than 9 weeks. Concurrent chemoradiation should strongly be considered.
- •
The overall 5-year survival rate of patients treated for squamous cell carcinoma of the vagina is approximately 45%.
- •
Clear cell adenocarcinoma is often associated with prenatal diethylstilbestrol (DES) exposure. Prognosis is improved if the patient is older than 19 years, the tumor has a predominant tubulocystic tumor pattern, and the disease is low stage. Those with a maternal history of DES exposure have a better prognosis.
- •
Local therapy for small, stage I clear cell adenocarcinoma of the vagina is best considered if the tumor is smaller than 2 cm in diameter, invades less than 3 mm, and is predominantly of the tubulocystic histologic type. Pelvic nodes should be sampled and be free of tumor.
- •
The overall 5-year survival rate of patients treated for clear cell adenocarcinoma is approximately 80%, partially because of the high proportion of low-stage cases.
- •
Vaginal melanomas are usually fatal. They occur primarily in patients older than 50 years.
- •
Endometrioid adenocarcinomas of the vagina may occur through the malignant transformation of endometriosis, often associated with the use of unopposed estrogen or tamoxifen.
- •
Endodermal sinus tumors occur in children younger than 2 years. They secrete alpha-fetoprotein and are usually treated by multiagent chemotherapy, followed by surgical excision.
- •
Sarcoma botryoides occurs primarily in children younger than 8 years. It is treated by a multimodality approach using multiagent chemotherapy with surgical removal and occasionally irradiation.
This chapter reviews the clinical and pathologic aspects of premalignant vulvar lesions and vulvar atypias ( Box 30.1 ). This is followed by consideration of the diagnosis, natural history, and management of invasive cancers of the vulva, which includes not only the squamous cell carcinomas but also the rarer melanomas and sarcomas. The second part of the chapter reviews the diagnosis and treatment of premalignant and malignant diseases of the vagina.
Squamous cell hyperplasia (formerly hyperplastic dystrophy)
Lichen sclerosus
Intraepithelial neoplasia
VIN I: Mild dysplasia
VIN II: Moderate dysplasia
VIN III: Severe dysplasia–carcinoma in situ
Others
Paget disease
Melanoma in situ (level 1)
Premalignant and malignant lesions of the vulva
Cancer of the vulva accounts for approximately 5% of malignancies of the lower female genital tract, ranking it fourth in frequency after cancers of the endometrium, ovary, and cervix. Well-defined predisposing factors for the development of vulvar carcinoma have not been identified. In general, premalignant and malignant changes often arise at multifocal points on the vulva. Human papillomavirus (HPV) has been noted in almost 70% of patients with carcinoma of the vulva ( ), and invasive carcinoma may arise from areas of carcinoma in situ, similar to the mechanism in cervical squamous cell carcinoma (see Chapter 29 ); however, some cases of squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva appear to develop in the absence of HPV or premalignant changes in the vulvar epithelium. Other factors, such as granulomatous disease of the vulva, diabetes, hypertension, smoking, and obesity, have been suggested as causative factors, but data do not provide consistent evidence regarding their association with vulvar carcinoma. Carcinoma of the vulva occurs with increasing frequency in those who have been treated for squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix or vagina, presumably as a result of the increased risk of carcinogenesis in the squamous epithelium of the lower genital tract in these patients. It appears that HPV DNA is involved in the development of a subset of vulvar carcinomas that tend to occur in younger patients, as noted by Crum ( ). Monk and colleagues demonstrated that not only were the HPV DNA–associated carcinomas found in younger patients but also that patients who are HPV negative appear to have had a poorer prognosis with tumors that were more likely to recur and lead to patient death ( ). As demonstrated by Hording and coworkers, HPV-positive tumors tend to have a warty or basaloid appearance, whereas HPV-negative tumors tend to be keratinized ( ). The former tend to be associated with premalignant vulvar changes (vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia [VIN]). The incidence of vulvar carcinoma in situ has increased by more than 400% since the 1980s, with most of the increase in new cases occurring in women younger than 50 years ( ).
Most vulvar malignancies are squamous cell carcinomas and most occur in women older than 50 years. In fact, although more than 80% of patients with vulvar carcinoma in situ are younger than 50, less than 20% of women with invasive carcinoma are younger than 50. The age-specific incidence of vulvar cancer increases with each decade of life but overall has remained relatively stable since the 1980s ( Fig. 30.1 ). Although most patients with carcinoma of the vulva are older than 60, those with carcinoma in situ of the vulva are usually 10 to 15 years younger—that is, aged 40 to 55. Premalignant changes of the vulva have been seen with increasing frequency among younger patients, often in their 20s and 30s, possibly as a result of an increasing rate of multiple sexual contacts and increased exposure to venereal infections, particularly HPV, in this population. Carter and colleagues reported a link between immunosuppression and invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva in women younger than 40 years ( ). Similar to cervical cancer, HPV-related infections would presumably progress through dysplasia to invasive cancer in these immunocompromised women.
Vulvar atypias
Specific conditions
Vulvar atypias: Intraepithelial neoplasia
Lichen sclerosus ( Fig. 30.2 ) is a change in the vulvar skin that often appears whitish; microscopically the epithelium becomes markedly thinned, with a loss or blunting of the rete ridges. In some cases there is also a thickening or hyperkeratosis of the surface layers ( Fig. 30.3 ), and inflammation is usually present. In a study of 3038 women in the Netherlands, Bleeker and associates found that the cumulative incidence of squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva for women with a prior diagnosis of lichen sclerosis was 6.7% ( ). The latency period between diagnosis of lichen sclerosis and subsequent vulvar cancer in those who developed the malignancy was 3.3 years. Concurrent VIN and age 70 or older at the time of the diagnosis of lichen sclerosis were independent risk factor for subsequent development of vulvar cancer. For women with lichen sclerosis, the standard incidence ratio (SIR) for developing vulvar cancer is 33.6 and 3.69 for developing vaginal cancer ( ). For women who are compliant with topical corticosteroid therapy, the risk of developing vulvar dysplasia or carcinoma approaches 0% compared with noncompliant women, whose risk is 4.7% ( ). Squamous hyperplasia (formerly called hyperplastic dystrophy) involves the elongation and widening of the rete ridges, which may be confluent ( Fig. 30.4 ). There may also be hyperkeratotic surface layers, and the tissue grossly is often whitish or reddish.
Atypical changes may appear in the vulvar epithelium. These are often marked by a loss of the maturation process usually seen in squamous epithelium, as well as an increase in mitotic activity and nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio ( Fig. 30.5 ). Mild dysplasia (atypia) is diagnosed if these changes involve the lower third of the epithelium, moderate dysplasia (atypia) if half to two-thirds of the epithelium is involved, and severe dysplasia (atypia) if more than two-thirds of the epithelium is affected. Carcinoma in situ involves the full thickness of the epithelium. The term VIN I is used for mild atypia, VIN II for moderate atypia, and VIN III for severe atypia and carcinoma in situ. It is sometimes difficult to distinguish between squamous hyperplasia and intraepithelial neoplasia. Crum has suggested that VIN usually contains nuclei that are fourfold or greater different in size, whereas differences in the size of nuclei in condyloma or nonneoplastic epithelia are threefold or less ( ). Furthermore, abnormal mitoses are usually observed in VIN.
Carcinoma in situ (vin III)
Carcinoma in situ is diagnosed if the full thickness of the epithelium is abnormal ( Fig. 30.6 ). Occasionally the process may histologically resemble carcinoma in situ of the cervix, and in many lesions there are multinucleated cells, abnormal mitoses, an increased density in cells, and an increase in the nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio.
Paget disease
Paget disease is a rare intraepithelial disorder that occurs in the vulvar skin and histologically resembles Paget disease in the breast. Paget cells are large pale cells ( Fig. 30.7 ). The cells often occur in nests and infiltrate upward through the epithelium. Histologic abnormalities of the apocrine glands of the skin often may be noted in these lesions. There has been an increased association of Paget disease of the vulva with underlying invasive adenocarcinoma of the vulva, vagina, and anus, as well as distant sites, including the bladder, cervix, colon, stomach, and breast. Paget disease of the vulva tends to spread, often in an occult fashion, and recurrences are common after treatment.
Diagnosis
Clinical presentation
Atypias of the vulva present with a variety of symptoms and signs. Irritation or itching is common, although some patients do not report these symptoms. The vulva often has a whitish change because of a thickened keratin layer. In the past, the term leukoplakia was used. This term has been discarded, in part because abnormal lesions of the vulva require biopsy to establish a correct diagnosis. When lichen sclerosus is present, there is usually a diffuse whitish change to the vulvar skin ( Fig. 30.8 ). The vulvar skin often appears thin and there may be scarring and contracture. In addition, fissuring of the skin is often present, accompanied by excoriation secondary to itching. Areas of squamous hyperplasias (formerly called hyperplastic dystrophy without atypia ) also appear as whitish lesions in general, but the tissues of the vulva usually appear thickened and the process tends to be more focal or multifocal than diffuse ( Fig. 30.9 ).
Abnormal areas of vulvar atypia or VIN may also appear as white, red, or pigmented areas on the vulva, although the clinical appearance of VIN is variable. Friedrich and colleagues estimated that approximately one-third of patients with carcinoma in situ present with pigmented lesions, emphasizing the importance of a biopsy to establish the diagnosis ( ). The lesions tend to be discrete and multifocal and occur more commonly in those who have had squamous cell neoplasia of the cervix. In addition, reddish nodules may be foci of Paget disease as well as of carcinoma in situ, and Paget disease often has a reddish eczematoid appearance. However, it should be reemphasized that these conditions cannot be accurately diagnosed from their clinical appearance, and biopsies are needed.
Diagnostic methods
In general, cytologic evaluation (Papanicolaou [Pap] smear) of the vulva has not proved helpful, in part because the vulvar skin is thick and keratinized and does not shed cells as readily as the epithelium of the vagina and cervix; however, in some cases, particularly if there is ulceration of the vulva, a cytologic smear can be helpful diagnostically (see Fig. 32.6 , B ). A tongue depressor moistened with normal saline or tap water is scraped over the surface portion of the vulva to be sampled, and the specimen is placed on a glass slide and then fixed.
The toluidine blue test (1% toluidine blue applied for 1 minute, followed by 1% acetic acid) with biopsy of the retained blue-staining areas has generally been discarded because it appears to be very nonspecific.
Colposcopy of the vulva is difficult because the characteristic changes in vascular appearance and tissue patterns that are seen in the cervix are not present (see Chapter 28 ). Nevertheless, the magnification of the colposcope may be used to help follow patients with VIN and to identify the discrete whitish or pigmented areas that warrant biopsy. The colposcope is not used for routine vulvar examination but is primarily used for those who are being evaluated or followed for vulvar atypia or VIN. The addition of 3% acetic acid highlights whitish areas for biopsy.
Biopsy of the vulva can be conveniently accomplished with a Keyes dermal punch biopsy ( Fig. 30.10 ). Usually, a 3- to 5-mm diameter punch is used. Each area in which a biopsy sample is to be obtained is usually infiltrated with local anesthesia using a fine 25-gauge needle. The punch is then rotated and downward pressure applied so that a disk of tissue is circumscribed. When the entire thickness of the skin has been incised, the specimen is elevated with forceps and removed with a sharp scissors. Occasionally, a larger biopsy is needed, in which case a larger field is anesthetized and a small scalpel or cervical punch biopsy (see Fig. 30.14 later in the chapter) is used to obtain the specimen. Little bleeding typically is encountered, and generally can be controlled by applying silver nitrate or ferrous subsulfate (Monsel solution). Depending on the size of the atypical area and the variety of atypical-appearing areas, one or multiple biopsy specimens may be needed.
Treatment
Vulvar atypias
Most vulvar atypias have pruritus as the major symptom, so the relief of itching is often the woman’s main concern. Once the correct diagnosis has been established by biopsy, appropriate therapy can be undertaken. Most whitish lesions will be benign because lichen sclerosus is the most common condition encountered.
Topical steroids can be used for atrophic conditions of the vulva, particularly lichen sclerosus. The most commonly used option for the treatment of lichen sclerosus is 0.05% clobetasol propionate ointment. This can be used anywhere from nightly to twice weekly for up to 12 weeks and then used to retreat as necessary. Although lichen sclerosus can be associated with the development of squamous cell carcinoma as described previously, use of a potent steroid cream may offer protection from malignant evolution.
A newer class of drug, topical calcineurin inhibitors (TCIs), has been evaluated as a nonsteroidal treatment of lichen sclerosis. Both the TCIs, pimecrolimus and tacrolimus, have been compared with clobetasol. In one study, twice daily usage of pimecrolimus 1% cream was compared with once daily application of clobetasol 0.05% cream in 38 women with biopsy-proven vulvar lichen sclerosis ( ). Although clobetasol was superior in improving inflammation, patients who used pimecrolimus did have some reduction in inflammation and showed equivalent improvement in pruritus and burning/pain. Another study compared nightly tacrolimus 0.1% ointment with nightly clobetasol 0.05% cream in 55 women with lichen sclerosis ( ). Both groups had significant improvement in disease-related symptoms, although the clobetasol group had a larger improvement. Most would agree that clobetasol should still be used as first-line therapy in the treatment of lichen sclerosis, with consideration of TCIs in women who fail clobetasol or have other contraindications to topical steroid therapy.
When clobetasol and TCIs are ineffective, some advocate the use of hormonal creams, although results from small clinical trials using testosterone and progesterone creams have been mixed. A preparation of 2% testosterone propionate in petrolatum can be used twice daily, with once-daily maintenance after the first week. Often, reducing the dosage of testosterone cream to twice weekly is a sufficient maintenance dose. Side effects, such as clitoral hypertrophy and increased hair growth, can occur. If there are undesirable side effects with testosterone, local progesterone cream is sometimes tried, with variable success. Those who have a beneficial response to testosterone should be continued on the medication indefinitely.
The control of local irritation of the vulva is discussed in Chapter 18 (Benign Gynecologic Lesions). In addition to local measures to diminish irritation (e.g., cotton underclothes, avoidance of strong soaps and detergents, avoidance of synthetic undergarments), topical fluorinated corticosteroids are helpful to control itching. Commonly used preparations are 0.025% or 0.1% triamcinolone acetonide (Aristocort, Kenalog), fluocinolone acetonide (Synalar), and 0.01% or 0.1% betamethasone valerate. These are usually applied twice daily to control the itching, which is often relieved in 1 to 2 weeks. Unfortunately, the prolonged use of fluorinated topical steroids can lead to vulvar atrophy and contraction, and thus once the symptoms of itching are controlled, the dose of topical corticosteroids is tapered off or, if long-term therapy is needed, a nonfluorinated compound such as 1.0% hydrocortisone is used to avoid vulvar contraction. Occasionally, 1% hydrocortisone is sufficient for initial therapy. In some cases the corticosteroids are not successful, and numerous types of topical therapy must be tried to control symptoms. Gentle soaps are helpful. Burow’s solution (5% solution of aluminum acetate) is often used as a wet dressing to help control irritation and itching. Doak tar, 3%, in petrolatum (USP) or in 1% hydrocortisone ointment is useful for severe cases.
In some patients with lichen sclerosus, severe contracture of the vulva, particularly in the area of the posterior fourchette, occurs with concomitant scarring and tenderness. Intercourse may then become painful for these patients. Woodruff and coworkers described a useful surgical technique to treat these vaginal outlet disorders by repair of the perineum ( ). The contractured and fissured area in the posterior fourchette is excised, which results in an elliptic defect. This is then closed by undermining the distal 3 to 4 cm of the posterior vaginal mucosa and suturing the freed mucosa to the perineal skin ( Fig. 30.11 ).
Vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia
Once the diagnosis of VIN has been established by biopsy, therapy is performed to eradicate the area containing the neoplasia. The clinician must be aware that the progress of vulvar atypia (mild dysplasia [VIN I]) to moderate dysplasia (VIN II) to severe dysplasia and carcinoma in situ (VIN III) and then to invasive carcinoma is not as well documented for vulvar neoplasia as it is for squamous cell neoplasia of the cervix. Moreover, vulvar neoplasia is often multifocal, requiring treatment of several areas. An additional complication is that some cases originally diagnosed as intraepithelial neoplasia have been reported to regress spontaneously.
In 1972, Friedrich reported bowenoid atypia (histologically similar to carcinoma in situ) in a pregnant woman that regressed spontaneously postpartum ( ). Others also reported spontaneous regression of this lesion. These spontaneously regressing lesions tend to be discrete elevations in young women. Some may be explained by studies of the nuclear DNA content of vulvar atypias that suggest that not all lesions with this designation are premalignant. Fu and colleagues noted that only four of eight cases of vulvar atypia had an aneuploid (neoplastic) distribution. A polyploid distribution was noted in four of the cases, which is consistent with a benign process, whereas aneuploidy is consistent with intraepithelial neoplasia ( ).
Although VIN has been diagnosed more commonly in younger women, the risk of progression to invasive cancer is higher for those who are older and for those who are immunosuppressed, such as women with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) or transplant recipients. Chafe and associates studied 69 patients with a diagnosis of VIN treated by surgical excision ( ). Unsuspected invasion was found in 13 patients. The median age was 36 years for those without invasive carcinoma, whereas the median age was 58 years ( P = .003) for those with invasion found in the excision specimen, emphasizing the increased risk of invasion in the older patients. Furthermore, the risk of invasion was higher in those who had raised lesions with irregular surface patterns. Thus patients who were older and those with irregular raised lesions had the greatest risk of unrecognized invasive carcinoma. A study by Modesitt and colleagues of 73 women, with a mean age of 45 years, found an invasive carcinoma in 22% of VIN III excision specimens ( ). Not surprisingly, the risk of recurrence was almost 50% if the margins were positive and only 17% if they were negative. The risk of progression from intraepithelial disease to invasive carcinoma appears to be less for vulvar cases than for cervical disease (see Chapter 28 ).
Women with HIV and AIDS are also more likely to develop vulvar carcinoma in situ and invasive cancer than the general population. In a large population-based study, Chaturvedi and colleagues found a relative risk (RR) of 1.59 for developing VIN III in the 28 to 60 months after the onset of AIDS and an RR of 4.91 for developing invasive carcinoma in this group ( ).
Studies have suggested that the potential of VIN to develop into invasive cancer is low. Buscema and coworkers followed 102 patients with vulvar carcinoma in situ for 1 to 15 years without treatment; 4 patients developed invasive disease, 2 of whom were immunosuppressed ( ). Unfortunately, current techniques do not allow precise prediction of which lesions of VIN are at the greatest risk of progression to invasive disease. A population-based study from Norway has confirmed an increasing frequency of VIN III that nearly tripled from the mid-1970s to 1988 to 1991 but, during the same period, the age-adjusted frequency of invasive vulvar carcinomas remained almost constant ( ). Iversen and Tretli further noted an estimated conversion rate of VIN III to invasive carcinoma of approximately 3.4% for these in situ lesions ( ). For women with a known diagnosis of VIN, risk factors for progression to invasive disease include immunosuppression (odds ratio [OR], 4.0), multifocal lesions (OR, 3.1), and smoking (OR, 3.0) ( ).
HPV types 6 and 11 have generally been recognized as being found most often in benign vulvar warts, whereas primarily HPV types 16, 18, 31, 33, and 35 are more often associated with intraepithelial neoplasia or invasive carcinoma (see Chapter 28 ). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has estimated that 80% of women aged 50 will have acquired a genital HPV infection at some point in their lives. Beutner and associates predicted that as many as 1 million new cases of perineal warts will occur annually in the United States ( ). An additional complication is that HPV type 16 infection is not always accompanied by histologic evidence of VIN. Moreover, HPV types 6, 11, and 16 can be recovered from a single site, including those that show only condyloma as well as those that show carcinoma. Thus a unique role for HPV types in VIN has not been elucidated. With current data, therapy should be based on histologic findings and not on the presence or absence of HPV infection or specific HPV types. Studies by Buscema and associates have suggested that HPV type 16 is often found in vulvar neoplasia and, as noted, HPV 16 has been commonly associated with some vulvar carcinomas ( ).
HPV therapy
The problem of the management of vulvar HPV infection is particularly complicated because it is extremely prevalent and the risk of progression from HPV infection to VIN is small. Planner and Hobbs evaluated 148 women with cytologic evidence of vulvar HPV infection and found that two-thirds of them had pruritus and dyspareunia ( ). Results of the biopsy revealed that 11 of the 148 women had VIN. Follow-up identified spontaneous regression of HPV infection in 56 patients, whereas VIN III developed in 2 and invasive cancer eventually developed in 1. It appears that the best approach is to restrict therapy to those with clinically bothersome symptoms such as warts or to eradicate lesions with VIN, particularly VIN II and III. Cytologic or histologic evidence of an asymptomatic HPV infection, such as koilocytosis, is not an indication for therapy. Riva and colleagues treated lower genital tract HPV infection with laser to include the cervix, vagina, and vulva; 25 patients had proven subclinical HPV infection, and their male partners were also evaluated and treated ( ). All 25 patients suffered severe pain, and many required hospitalization. At 3 months after therapy, 24 of 25 again had evidence of subclinical HPV infection and 22 had persistent histologic evidence of koilocytosis, indicating the futility of trying to eradicate HPV infection by this method.
Many VIN lesions tend to be posterior, predominantly in the perineal area. Surgical removal has been effectively used, but the type of operation has been changing. In the past, simple vulvectomy was widely performed to treat carcinoma in situ of the vulva, but this disfiguring operation is now uncommon, particularly because the disease is occurring in younger women. To improve the cosmetic result and sexual function, Rutledge and Sinclair introduced the method of skinning vulvectomy ( ). This removes the superficial vulvar skin, preserving the clitoris, and replaces the removed skin with a split-thickness vulvar graft. In many cases, however, such extensive surgery is not needed. Often the abnormal area of the vulva can be removed only with wide local excision. Of the patients in the series reported by Buscema and coworkers, 62 were treated with local excision; 68% showed no recurrence ( ). For comparison, in 28 patients treated by vulvectomy, 70% showed no recurrence. The risk of recurrence is higher if neoplastic epithelium is found at the resection margin. Friedrich has noted a 10% risk of recurrence if the surgical margins are free of disease compared with a 50% risk if the surgical margins are involved with neoplasia ( ). In addition to positive margins, other risk factors for recurrence of VIN include smoking and larger tumor size. ( ). Because recurrence may develop even if the resection margins are negative, long-term follow-up is mandatory.
The carbon dioxide laser has been used to treat VIN, usually to a depth of 2 to 3 mm, with a deeper depth being used for areas that contain hair. This results in eradication of the abnormal vulvar tissue and healing without scarring. Most patients require a single treatment but some require more, particularly those with large or multiple lesions. Usually, patients can be treated on an outpatient basis with local, regional, or general anesthesia. The laser is particularly useful for younger patients. It is essential to be certain that the woman does not have invasive disease before using the laser, so a biopsy of any suspicious lesions should be performed before laser ablation. The surgeon should be experienced in the diagnosis and treatment of vulvar disease before using laser ablation. Older patients and those with raised lesions should be treated by surgical excision.
Laser ablation treatment is usually carried out to a depth of 2 to 3 mm, and healing is usually complete within 2 to 3 weeks. Leuchter and associates treated 142 patients with carcinoma in situ of the vulva ( ). Of the 42 treated by laser, 17% had recurrence; 4 of the 16 treated with vulvectomy (25%) and 15 of 45 treated by local excision (33%) also had recurrence. In view of the risk of unsuspected carcinoma in older patients, as noted by the studies of , those older than 45 years and those with raised or irregular lesions should have an excision performed and the entire tissue submitted for histologic evaluation. Posterior lesions near the anus require particular attention because the anal canal is often involved and this abnormal tissue also should be removed.
Treatment with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) cream has been attempted for carcinoma in situ of the vulva, but it causes severe burning and is generally not used. Investigators have had promising results with 5% imiquimod cream as a primary treatment for VIN III. Van Seters and coworkers performed a randomized control study of 5% imiquimod topical cream versus placebo in 52 women with VIN II and III ( ). Most women included in the study (96%) were positive for HPV before initiation of therapy. In the treatment group, 81% had at least a reduction in the size of the primary lesion by more than 25% at 20 weeks and 35% had a complete response. In the placebo group there were no patients with partial or complete responses. At 12 months after enrollment, however, 3 patients (6%) had progressed to microinvasive vulvar carcinoma (1 in the treatment group, 2 in the placebo group).
Therapeutic vaccines using HPV peptides have also been explored for the treatment of VIN III. Kenter and colleagues combined long peptides from the E6 and E7 oncoproteins of HPV-16 into a vaccine and immunized 20 women with HPV-16–positive VIN III ( ). At 12 months after last vaccination, 79% had a clinical response, with 47% achieving complete response. Of note, all the women who had a complete response by 12 months also remained disease free at 24 months.
Paget disease of the vulva
Paget disease generally occurs in postmenopausal women with an average age of approximately 65 years and is more common in white women. The disease typically appears grossly as a diffuse erythematous eczematoid lesion that has usually been present for a prolonged time. Itching is a common problem. The major importance of Paget disease of the vulva is the common association with other invasive carcinomas. Squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva or cervix, adenocarcinoma of the sweat glands of the vulva, or Bartholin gland carcinoma may be present. Cases of adenocarcinoma of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract and breast accompanying Paget disease have also been reported. Once a diagnosis of Paget disease of the vulva is made, it is important for the gynecologist to rule out the presence of breast and GI malignancies. In a review by Fanning and associates, 20% of patients with vulvar Paget had nonvulvar malignancies, including cancers of the breast, uterus, pancreas, lung, stomach, thyroid, and skin. In addition, 12% had invasive Paget disease of the vulva and 4% had invasive adenocarcinoma of the vulva ( ).
If no local or distant primary malignancy is uncovered, a wide excision of the affected area can be performed. It is important to remove the full thickness of the skin to the subcutaneous fat to ensure that all the skin adnexal structures are excised because they may have a subclinical malignancy. Bergen and coworkers evaluated 14 patients with Paget disease of the vulva treated by surgery, usually vulvectomy, skinning vulvectomy with graft, or hemivulvectomy ( ). With a median follow-up of 50 months, all patients were free of disease, although 2 with positive margins and 1 with negative margins required treatment for recurrence. Fishman and colleagues studied 14 patients with Paget disease treated by various surgical procedures ( ). Frozen-section or gross visual inspection was used to judge the operative margins. In this series, visual estimation was as useful as frozen section insofar as the error rate for judging margins by the final pathology report was approximately 35%. In addition, 2 of 5 patients with positive margins had a recurrence after the initial operation compared with 3 of 9 with negative margins. This small series therefore suggests that gross visual inspection may be as useful as frozen section when judging the extent of surgical operation. Other small series evaluating Mohs micrographic surgery for treating vulvar extramammary disease have failed to reduce recurrence significantly. A conservative approach involving removal of gross Paget disease with approximately a 1-cm margin appears to be the most appropriate, with the understanding that reexcision may be required for recurrence in the future. The full thickness of the vulvar skin to the adipose layer should be removed.
Even if resection margins are free of Paget disease at the time of surgical excision, local recurrence remains a risk. Women who have been treated for Paget disease of the vulva should have as part of their routine follow-up an annual examination of the breast, cytologic evaluation of the cervix and vulva, and screening for GI disease, at least by testing for occult blood in the stool. Progression of Paget disease of the vulva to invasive adenocarcinoma has been rarely reported.
Investigators have also explored using topical imiquimod cream as a nonsurgical therapy for extramammary Paget disease of the vulva. In one retrospective study, 21 women with Paget disease were treated with imiquimod cream and 11 (52%) had a complete response to therapy, whereas an additional 6 (29%) had a partial response with no cases of progressive disease ( ). In another small study, 6 of 8 patients with vulvar Paget disease (75%) treated with imiquimod cream had a complete pathologic response at 12 weeks; however, 4 of the 6 patients who had a complete response (67%) eventually did have recurrent disease ( ). Because treatment of Paget disease not associated with underlying malignancies is largely for symptom control, a trial of imiquimod may be a reasonable approach for patients who do not desire surgery or are not surgical candidates. In addition, because achieving negative margins with surgical resection is rare, some may consider using a course of imiquimod adjuvantly after surgical resection in an effort to reduce recurrence.
Malignant conditions
Squamous cell carcinoma
Squamous cell carcinomas comprise approximately 90% of primary vulvar malignancies, but a variety of other vulvar cancers are encountered; the major types are listed in Box 30.2 . Melanomas account for approximately 4% to 5%, and the other types make up the remainder.
Squamous cell carcinoma
Adenocarcinoma (including Bartholin gland)
Verrucous carcinoma
Basal cell carcinoma
Melanoma
Sarcoma
Morphology and staging
Grossly, vulvar carcinomas usually appear as raised, flat, ulcerated, plaquelike, or polypoid masses on the vulva ( Fig. 30.12 ). A biopsy sample of the lesion reveals the characteristic histologic appearance of squamous cell carcinoma (see Fig. 30.6 , C ).
Four clinical stages are defined for carcinoma of the vulva according to the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO), similar to the system used for other gynecologic malignancies. In addition, many centers use the TNM system (tumor, nodes, metastases) for classification; T denotes the size and extent of the tumor, N the clinical status of the nodes, and M the presence or absence of metastatic disease.
In the clinical staging system, lymph node status was assessed clinically and incorporated into the stage. Enlarged or clinically suspicious lymph nodes were assigned a higher stage, regardless of disease status documented at surgery. Clinically negative nodes were assigned an earlier stage, which was upheld even if they were found to harbor metastasis after surgical removal and pathologic examination. Therefore in 1988 the FIGO staging was modified to a surgical staging system for vulvar cancer to reflect lymph node status more accurately. In addition, a location on the perineum is no longer assigned to stage III. This system, with the modifications introduced in 2009 by FIGO and in 2017 by the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) for new definitions of stages I to IV, is shown in Box 30.3 .
TNM
T: Primary tumor
Tis: Preinvasive carcinoma (carcinoma in situ)
T1: Tumor confined to the vulva and/or perineum
T1a: Tumor confined to the vulva or perineum, ≤2 cm in diameter and with stromal invasion <1 mm
T1b: Tumor confined to the vulva or perineum, >2 cm in diameter or tumor any size with stromal invasion >1 mm
T2: Tumor of any size with adjacent spread to the urethra, vagina, anus, or all of these
T3: Tumor of any size infiltrating the bladder mucosa, rectal mucosa, or both, including the upper part of the urethral mucosa or fixed to the anus
N: Regional lymph nodes
NX: Regional lymph nodes cannot be assessed
N0: No regional lymph node metastasis
N1: Regional lymph node metastasis with one or two lymph node metastases each less than 5 mm, or one lymph node metastasis greater than or equal to 5 mm
N1a: One or two lymph node metastases each less than 5 mm
N1b: One lymph node metastasis greater than or equal to 5 mm
N2: Regional lymph node metastasis with three or more lymph node metastases each less than 5 mm, or two or more lymph node metastases greater than or equal to 5 mm, or lymph node(s) with extranodal extension
N2a: Three or more lymph node metastases each less than 5 mm
N2b: Two or more lymph node metastases greater than or equal to 5 mm
N2c: Lymph node(s) with extranodal extension
N3: Fixed or ulcerated regional lymph node metastasis
M: Distant metastases
M0: No clinical metastases
M1: Distant metastases (including pelvic lymph node metastases)
Staging (FIGO), modified 2009
Stage I—T1, N0, M0: Tumor confined to vulva or perineum
IA: Lesions ≤2 cm in size, confined to the vulva or perineum and with stromal invasion ≤1 mm; no nodal metastasis
IB: Lesions >2 cm in size or with stromal invasion >1.0 mm, confined to the vulva or perineum, with negative nodes
Stage II—T2, N0, M0: Tumor of any size with extension to adjacent perineal structures (one-third lower urethra, one-third lower vagina, anus) with negative nodes
Stage III—T1-2, N1/2, M0: Tumor of any size with or without extension to adjacent perineal structures (one-third lower urethra, one-third lower vagina, anus), with positive inguinofemoral lymph nodes
IIIA: (i) With one lymph node metastasis (≥5 mm) or (ii) one or two lymph node metastasis(es) (<5 mm)
IIIB: (i) With two or more lymph node metastases (≥5 mm) or (ii) three or more lymph node metastases (<5 mm)
IIIC: With positive nodes with extracapsular spread
Stage IV—T3 or any T, any N, M1: Tumor invades other regional (two-thirds upper urethra, two-thirds upper vagina) or distant structures
IVA: Tumor invades any of the following: (i) upper urethral or vaginal mucosa, bladder mucosa, rectal mucosa, or fixed to pelvic bone; or (ii) fixed or ulcerated inguinofemoral lymph nodes
IVB: Any distant metastasis including pelvic lymph nodes.
FIGO, International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics; TNM, tumor-node-metastasis.
Natural history, spread, and prognostic factors
The vulvar area is rich in lymphatics, with numerous cross connections. The main lymphatic pathways are illustrated in Fig. 30.13 . Tumors located in the middle of either labium tend to drain initially to the ipsilateral inguinofemoral nodes, whereas perineal tumors can spread to the left or right side. Tumors in the clitoral or urethral areas can also spread to either side. From the inguinofemoral nodes, the lymphatic spread of tumor is cephalad to the deep pelvic iliac and obturator nodes. Although there has been concern in the past that tumors in the clitoral-urethral area would spread directly to the deep pelvic nodes, this rarely, if ever, occurs. The characteristics of lymph drainage of the vulva have been evaluated by Iversen and Aas, who injected technetium-99m colloid subcutaneously into the anterior and posterior labia majora, anterior and posterior labia minora, clitoral area, and perineum ( ). They then measured the radioactivity in the pelvic lymph nodes, which were surgically removed 5 hours later. More than 98% of the radioactivity was found in the ipsilateral node and less than 2% on the contralateral side. The anterior labial injections resulted in a 92% concentration of radioactivity in the ipsilateral side, with 8% on the contralateral side. The clitoral and perineal injections developed a bilateral nodal distribution of radioactivity in all the patients. It is of interest that two-thirds of the patients with labial injections had a small amount of detectable radioactivity in the contralateral nodes. Thus anastomoses of the lymphatics do exist, but a direct connection from the clitoris to the deep nodes was not demonstrated.