Mode
Process
Comment
Blood gas related
Blood gas analysis
Requires collection of blood specimens, and is thus invasive, and may be associated with increased need for blood transfusion
Generally used commonly, but role may be decreasing with increasing availability of noninvasive monitors of pO2 and pCO2
Transcutaneous monitor
Provides constant data on pO2 and pCO2 without blood collection or vascular access
More expensive equipment and consumables and requires extra nursing attention to move probes and monitor sites
Saturation monitors
Provides continuous data on oxygen saturation. Simple to use and reliable technology. Not good for identification of high pO2
Increasingly recognized as essential equipment when treating any patient with potential hypoxemia
End-tidal CO2 monitors and capnography
Provides continuous data but may be technically challenging to get accurate data, particularly if large leaks around ETT
Recommended as essential equipment to confirm endotracheal intubation. Useful in monitoring of patients on conventional ventilators when other parameters are stable
Tissue oxygen monitors (including NIRS)
Have generally been used for monitoring of cardiac output rather than ventilation
Expensive equipment and consumables. Has not been widely used for monitoring of ventilation but possibly has important potential
Respiratory mechanics measurement
Airway pressures
Part of basic ventilator monitoring. Particular important if on volume modes of ventilation
May be significant inaccuracies on some ventilators
Flow and tidal volume
Part of basic ventilator monitoring. Particular important if on pressure modes of ventilation. Tidal volume is the one parameter that has been shown to correspond with outcomes
Some ventilators are significantly inaccurate in measurement of tidal volumes. Relatively inexpensive monitors can be purchased to measure flow and tidal volume at the ETT
Pressure-volume curves
Available on many ventilators. Provide useful physiological data, but have not shown to improve patient outcomes
Not part of essential monitoring, although may help with
Electrical impedance tomography
Newly developing technology that may provide information on regional ventilation
Expensive, not generally available commercially, and complex to use
16.4 Respiratory Mechanics Measurement
Most ventilators provide data on the ventilator regarding airway pressures, and increasingly modern ventilators have displays of both flow and tidal volume. However, there is considerable data that measurements may be significantly inaccurate. For monitoring purposes it is important to measure dependant variables. Thus during pressure control ventilation, it is most important to monitor flows and tidal volumes, while during volume control ventilation, it is important to monitor pressures.
16.4.1 Pressures
Measurement of airway pressure in a ventilator is fundamental to the management of ventilation (using both pressure and volume modes). Display of the pressure trace, as opposed to a digital display or an analog display, enables much clearer analysis of the pattern of ventilation that is actually being administered.
There is some data that airway pressures measured at the endotracheal tube are similar to those measured in the ventilator circuit (Cannon et al. 2000). However, Nasiroglu et al. (2006) compared the pressure measured in the ventilator circuit proximal to the endotracheal tube with the pressure in the trachea on a group of 30 children (aged 29 days to 5 years) and showed that there were significant differences. Peak inspiratory pressures measured in the ventilator circuit overestimated tracheal pressure during positive-pressure ventilation and underestimated tracheal pressures during spontaneous ventilation. Similar findings have been reported by other authors (Dela Cruz et al. 2005). Nikischin et al. (2007; Nikischin and Lange 2003) have examined the impact of leaks on the relationship between airway and tracheal pressures and have suggested methods for correction of data.
16.4.2 Flow and Volume
Airflow during ventilation can be measured using a range of pneumotachographs placed at a variety of places within the ventilation circuit. Care must be taken to ensure that the pneumotachographs are appropriately calibrated and that the geometry of the ventilatory circuits does not interfere with effective function (Kreit and Sciurba 1996). Respiratory impedance plethysmography can also be used to measure gas flows (Brooks et al. 1997) with the advantage that there is no insertion to the respiratory circuit with additional resistance and dead space; however, respiratory impedance plethysmography does require calibration and may require more sophisticated resources.
There is substantial evidence that flows and tidal volumes measured at the endotracheal tube may be substantially different to those measured within ventilator circuits (Cannon et al. 2000; Al-Majed et al. 2004; Castle et al. 2002; Chow et al. 2002; Heulitt et al. 2005, 2009), and these differences may be affected by issues such as lung compliance and leaks around the endotracheal tube (Main et al. 2001; Herber-Jonat et al. 2008) or the use of heat moisture exchangers for humidification (Fujita et al. 2006).
This is of particular concern, as there is substantial evidence that tidal volumes are clearly related to inflammatory responses both systemically and within the lungs (Wolthuis et al. 2008) and many studies have highlighted the potential benefits of ventilation with lower tidal volumes in adults and children with ARDS and other lung conditions (Wolthuis et al. 2008; Amato et al. 1995, 1998; The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network 2000; Meade et al. 2008; Schultz 2008; Choi et al. 2006; Ferguson et al. 2005; Rimensberger et al. 1999; Brochard et al. 1998). And ventilation at lower tidal volumes has been associated with improved outcomes in pediatric patients with lung disease (Khemani et al. 2009; Randolph 2009; Hanson and Flori 2006; Mehta and Arnold 2004; Albuali et al. 2007).
Ideally flow and volume data should be graphically displayed (in conjunction with pressure data), as this enables optimization of inspiratory and expiratory times. Utilization of this data can prevent overdistension of the lung from “stacking” (Pohlman et al. 2008).
Particular attention needs to be paid to leaks around endotracheal tubes, which are almost the norm in smaller children where uncuffed endotracheal tubes have been used routinely for many years. With modern cuffed endotracheal tubes, it may be possible (and appropriate) to use cuffed tubes on younger infants, particularly those who are unstable at the time of intubation (Newth et al. 2004). Elimination of the leak makes it substantially easier to evaluate respiratory function in ventilated children.
16.4.3 Pressure-Volume Curves
A wide variety of curves and graphics can be generated using the interactions of pressure, flow, volume, and time. However, although they may provide promising and interesting data regarding lung and respiratory physiology, there is not data showing that their use changes patient outcomes (Terragni et al. 2003).
Much physiological data has been derived from static compliance curves, and much of the theory on optimal ventilation has derived from study of static compliance curves. However, as shown by Adams et al. (2001), the dynamic compliance curves that are displayed on many ventilators are very different to static curves and should not be used to define ventilatory strategies. In particular inflection points on compliance curves are often difficult to identify and may not be present on tidal pressure-volume curves (Albaiceta et al. 2008).
16.5 New Technology
Electrical impedance tomography (Frerichs et al. 2001; Heinrich et al. 2006; Wolf et al. 2007) has been used in a variety of settings to assess regional ventilation of the lung. It is however technically challenging and remains essentially a research tool in sophisticated settings, although more commercial systems may soon be available.
16.6 Conclusions
Clinical assessment of patients and their interface with ventilators remains a fundamental requirement for safe ventilation. However, clinical assessment does require the development of acute clinical skills, and this is difficult in the absence of additional monitoring and in the context of limited resources and substantial caseload.
Although a wide variety of techniques are available for the monitoring of ventilation in children, the only proven techniques are arterial blood gas analysis; capnography for rapid identification of endotracheal tube placement; pulse oximetry for identification of poor oxygenation (not reliable for identification of hyperoxia); and measurement of pressure, flows, and tidal volume at the ETT.
Points to Remember
Basic clinical monitoring is essential, with a particular emphasis on ensuring patient comfort.
Blood gas analysis is the baseline for assessment of ventilation. It is however invasive and may have complications. Noninvasive monitoring of oxygenation and pCO2 will be used increasingly.
Oxygen saturation monitoring is essential in any child who may be hypoxemic, and equipment is relatively cheap and reliable.
Monitoring of end-tidal pCO2 is recommended for confirmation of endotracheal placement during intubation.
Monitoring of tidal volumes is the only ventilation monitoring parameter that has been shown to affect outcomes. However, equipment must be shown to be accurate.
References
Adams AB, Cakar N, Marini JJ (2001) Static and dynamic pressure-volume curves reflect different aspects of respiratory system mechanics in experimental acute respiratory distress syndrome. Respir Care 46:686–693PubMed
Al-Majed SI, Thompson JE, Watson KF, Randolph AG (2004) Effect of lung compliance and endotracheal tube leakage on measurement of tidal volume. Crit Care 8:R398–R402PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRef
Bhat YR, Abhishek N (2008) Mainstream end-tidal carbon dioxide monitoring in ventilated neonates. Singapore Med J 49:199–203PubMed
Bhende MS (2001) End-tidal carbon dioxide monitoring in pediatrics – clinical applications. J Postgrad Med 47:215–218PubMed
Brochard L, Roudot-Thoraval F, Roupie E et al (1998) Tidal volume reduction for prevention of ventilator-induced lung injury in acute respiratory distress syndrome. The Multicenter Trail Group on Tidal Volume reduction in ARDS. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 158:1831–1838PubMedCrossRef