Regenerative medicine has recently been established as an emerging field focussing on repair, replacement or regeneration of cells, tissues and whole organs. The significant recent advances in the field have intensified the search for novel sources of stem cells with potential for therapy. Recently, researchers have identified the amniotic fluid as an untapped source of stem cells that are multipotent, possess immunomodulatory properties and do not have the ethical and legal limitations of embryonic stem cells. Stem cells from the amniotic fluid have been shown to differentiate into cell lineages representing all three embryonic germ layers without generating tumours, which make them an ideal candidate for tissue engineering applications. In addition, their ability to engraft in injured organs and modulate immune and repair responses of host tissues suggest that transplantation of such cells may be useful for the treatment of various degenerative and inflammatory diseases affecting major tissues/organs. This review summarises the evidence on amniotic fluid cells over the past 15 years and explores the potential therapeutic applications of amniotic fluid stem cells and amniotic fluid mesenchymal stem cells.
Highlights
- •
Regenerative medicine focusses on replacement, repair and regeneration of cells, tissues and organs.
- •
Amniotic fluid stem cells (AFSCs) are broadly multipotent , that is, they can differentiate into all embryonic germ lineages, but they do not form tumours.
- •
Amniotic fluid mesenchymal stem cells (AFMSCs) are multipotent cells with mesodermal potential, that is, they can only differentiate towards fat, cartilage and bone.
- •
AFSCs and AFMSCs can be expanded, differentiated and used together with scaffolds for engineering of tissues and organs.
- •
AFSCs and AFMSCs home to sites of tissue injury and have paracrine effects that stimulate host repair/regeneration processes.
Introduction
Regenerative medicine: therapeutic potential and the quest for novel stem cell sources
Regenerative medicine has recently been established as an emerging field focussing on repair, replacement or regeneration of cells, tissues and whole organs. It involves multiple disciplines devoted to different aspects of the regeneration process, including stem cell biology, gene therapy, bioengineering, material science and pharmacology. After years of basic science research and proof-of-principle experiments on animal models of disease, the first clinical applications of regenerative medicine have recently become a reality . The rapid development of regenerative medicine is driven by the unmet clinical needs of patients requiring healthy tissues and organs, but for whom transplantation is not an option mainly due to the limited availability of appropriate grafts of human origin. So far, scientists around the world have been successful in tissue-engineering structurally simple organs with the main functions of allowing passage (e.g., trachea) or storage (e.g., urinary bladder) in the body. However, in the coming few years, more complex structures will likely be prepared in bioreactors before being transplanted into patients. Alternatively, it is possible that regeneration may occur directly in patients by either using their own body as a bioreactor (e.g. cell therapy involving transplantation of stem cells that proliferate, differentiate and replace damaged host cells, or transplantation of a scaffold which is then repopulated/remodelled by host cells) or activating/enhancing innate regenerative processes (e.g., transplantation of stem cells that home to sites of injury and act via a paracrine mechanism to stimulate repair/regeneration of host tissues) . Ultimately, regenerative medicine may offer a long-term solution to the problem of shortage of tissue/organs available for therapy.
The significant advances in the field of regenerative medicine have intensified the search for novel sources of stem cells with potential for therapy. Although embryonic and adult tissues can be used for the isolation of pluripotent stem cells, significant limitations, including ethical concerns, complexity of isolation/culture and tumorigenicity, have hindered translation of laboratory findings into clinical practice. In recent years, the amniotic fluid (AF) has been recognised as an alternative underutilised source of stem cells for tissue regeneration. AF cells could be banked and used for either allogeneic or autologous transplantation, the latter being particularly attractive for perinatal applications. Researchers have developed efficient protocols for the isolation of stem cells from the AF, which may be used for regenerative medicine-based treatments against both congenital and adult disorders .
Amniotic fluid: novel source of stem cells with therapeutic applications in regenerative medicine
The amnion is a sac that contains the developing embryo, surrounded by the chorion and yolk sac in humans and mice, respectively. Along with the enveloping AF, it has protective functions for the foetus, in particular, against trauma, infectious and toxic agents . AF composition and volume fluctuates with gestation, in part due to foetal development. During the first half of gestation, it is dependent on the osmotic gradient developed by sodium and chloride transport across the amniotic membrane and foetal skin. In the second half of gestation, it also contains foetal respiratory secretions, urine and excrement .
The AF is composed mainly of water and electrolytes, chemical substances (e.g., lipids, proteins and hormones), suspended materials (e.g., vernix caseosa, lanugo hair and meconium) and cells . The cells present within the AF represent a heterogeneous cell population with varying morphologies, in vitro characteristics and in vivo potential. They are mostly derived from the embryo, in particular the amniotic membrane, respiratory, intestinal and urinary tracts. AF-derived cells steadily increase with gestational age unless a pathological condition alters cellular turnover. For example, cell counts are abnormally low in the presence of intrauterine death and urogenital atresia, whereas they are increased in situations such as anencephaly and spina bifida .
Added to the changing cell counts, the AF contains a number of subpopulations that vary in proportion according to gestational age. These subpopulations were initially classified according to their morphology into amniocytes (60.8%), epithelioid (33.7%) and fibroblastic (5.5%) cells . Recently, cells with therapeutic potential have been isolated from the AF: amniotic fluid stem cells (AFSCs) and amniotic fluid mesenchymal stem cells (AFMSCs). These are selectively cultured from the entirety of AF-derived cells using different selection processes and specific growth conditions. Epithelial cells derived from the amnion and other cells derived from amniotic membranes have not been considered in this review.
Amniotic fluid stem cells
Characteristics, isolation and culture
The first suggestion that the AF may contain undifferentiated cells originated from a group that demonstrated the expression of skeletal muscle proteins when cells were cultured in the supernatant of rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines . Subsequently, amniotic fluid-derived cells were reported to differentiate into osteocytes, adipocytes and fibroblasts, whilst having a cell marker profile comparable to mesenchymal stem cells . Brivanlou et al. reported the expression of octamer-binding transcription factor-4 (Oct-4) at transcriptional and protein levels, thereby confirming the stem cell potential of a subpopulation of cells (0.5–1%) have stem cell potential . Oct-4 is a POU-domain transcription factor that maintains pluripotency and self-renewal in populations such as embryonic stem cells (ESCs), induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) and carcinoma cell lines.
De Coppi et al. used CD117 (a type III tyrosine kinase receptor for stem cell factor) as a means to select out the undifferentiated population from the AF, via either magnetic or fluorescent-activated cell sorting (MACS and FACS respectively) . Following selection, the cells are cultured in feeder layer-free, serum-rich conditions consisting of Chang medium B and C, α-minimum essential medium (α-MEM) and foetal bovine serum (FBS). The medium is changed every 2–3 days and the cells are passaged to maintain confluence below 60% in order to ensure multipotency.
The CD117-expressing (CD117 + ) subpopulation (AF stem cells; AFSCs) comprises 1% of cells and proliferates rapidly with clonal lines having a doubling time of 36 h . In addition, AFSCs maintain a normal karyotype following 250 population doublings with stable telomeres. In vitro experiments have demonstrated a potential for these cells to differentiate into all three germ layers. The endodermal potential of AFSCs was determined by differentiation into hepatocytes expressing albumin, α-fetoprotein and c-met receptor following growth in a hepatocytic medium. Differentiation towards ectoderm was demonstrated using culture conditions promoting the development of neural stem cells (nestin expression) and dopaminergic neurons (G-protein-gated, inwardly rectifying potassium channel-2 gene expression). The mesodermal potential was shown by differentiation into myotubes, adipocytes, endothelial cells and chondrocytes . AFSCs expressed a number of ESC markers such as Oct-4 and stage-specific embryonic antigen-4 (SSEA-4), but not the entire range of proteins associated with pluripotency. When cultured in adherence, AFSCs were negative for markers of haematopoietic lineage (CD45) and haematopoietic stem cells (CD133, CD34), confirming the lack of contamination with other cells from the umbilical cord and foetal blood .
Some researchers have suggested that AFSCs may have a pluripotent potential similar to ESCs or iPS . However, this is still unclear and possibly one of the reasons why AFSCs represent a cell population with enhanced regenerative applicability. Strictly speaking, pluripotent cells are defined by the ability to (i) be cultured indefinitely in an undifferentiated state, whilst remaining diploid with a normal karyotype; (ii) form clonal lines; (iii) differentiate towards all three germ layers in vitro; (iv) form teratomas in vivo; and (v) differentiate into all three germ layers when injected into a blastocyst. AFSCs can be reprogrammed to pluripotency without any genetic manipulation; however, to the authors’ opinion, prior to full reprogramming, they do not fulfil the last two criteria suggesting a broadly multipotent potential .
ESCs derived from humans have been considered to have great potential for therapy due to their high self-renewal capacity, pluripotency and ease of reproducibility, evident by the derivation of human ESCs by many laboratories using well-established protocols . However, major issues have hindered their clinical translation including allogeneic immunogenicity, tumorigenic potential and ethical concerns. The first two are particularly important if whole-organ generation is considered. Two major limitations associated with practical application of human ESCs (immunogenicity and ethical issues) were overcome following the generation of human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) . As human iPSCs could be developed from an autologous biopsy, allogeneic immunogenicity was not a problem, except for storage-associated modifications similar to those occurring in red blood cells stored prior to autotransfusion . Current issues limiting the clinical translation of human iPSCs include the low efficiency of iPSC generation methods, and the risks associated with the use of viral vectors that integrate into the genetic material of cells (risk of insertional mutagenesis and tumorigenesis).
Therefore, there is great potential to use AFSCs for clinical translation, mainly due to their differentiation capabilities, in vitro culture characteristics and the lack of tumorigenic potential and ethical concerns. In addition, if pluripotency were needed, AFSCs could be efficiently reprogrammed to generate iPSCs using a single chemical substance (i.e., valproic acid, a Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drug for the treatment of epilepsy), thus eliminating any risks of insertional mutagenesis . Finally, as AFSCs originate from the foetus, they could be used as an autologous stem cell source for pre- and postnatal regenerative medicine applications.
Regenerative medicine applications
Cardiovascular system
We have previously looked at the cardiomyogenic potential of AFSCs in vitro and in vivo. AFSCs cultured in cardiomyocyte induction media or in co-culture with cardiomyocytes demonstrated expression of proteins specific for cardiomyocytes (atrial natriuretic peptide and α-myosin heavy chain), endothelial (CD31, CD144) and smooth muscle cells (α-smooth muscle actin). In our first experience with xenogeneic transplantation, human AFSCs were transplanted in a rat model of myocardial infarction (MI). Cells of the immune system were recruited including T cells, B cells, natural killer (NK) cells and macrophages resulting in cell rejection. We speculated that this may be due to AFSC expression of the B7 co-stimulatory molecules CD80 and CD86, as well as macrophage marker CD68 . Next, we attempted allogeneic rat AFSC cardiac therapy by intracardiac transplantation in rats with ischaemia–reperfusion injury (IR). A portion of the cells acquired an endothelial or smooth muscle phenotype, and a smaller number had cardiomyocyte characteristics, 3 weeks following transplantation. The left ventricular ejection fraction was improved in animals that received the AFSC injection, as quantified using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), suggesting a paracrine therapeutic effect . The aim was to further investigate this paracrine effect using a rat model of MI and xenogeneic transplantation of human AFSCs administered intravascularly immediately following reperfusion. This was dissimilar to our previous attempt with xenogeneic cellular cardiomyoplasty, which involved intramuscular injection of human AFSCs within 20 min of coronary artery occlusion without reperfusion. Intravascular injection of human AFSCs and their conditioned medium showed a cardioprotective effect, improved cell survival and decreased the infarct size from 54% to around 40% in both cases. We have also shown that AFSCs secrete the actin monomer-binding protein thymosin beta-4 (Tβ-4), a paracrine factor with cardioprotective properties . Tβ-4 had also previously been implicated in cardioprotection in MI models that involved bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell (BMMSC) injection .
In addition to models of myocardial IR injury, we have investigated the salutary effects of AFSCs in a rat model of right heart failure secondary to pulmonary hypertension. Following intravascular injection, AFSCs engrafted in the lungs, heart and skeletal muscle, reducing the levels of brain natriuretic peptide (BNP), a surrogate marker for heart failure, and pro-inflammatory cytokines. In addition, AFSCs differentiated into endothelial and vascular cells forming micro-vessels, capillaries and small arteries. A 35% decrease in pulmonary arteriole thickness accompanied the injection .
Gastrointestinal system
We have recently looked at the effect of AFSCs in a rat model of necrotising enterocolitis (NEC) that involved hypoxia, hypothermia, gavage feeding with a hyperosmolar formula, hypoxia and administration of lipopolysaccharide. After 24 h of life, NEC rats were randomised to treatments of either AFSCs, BMMSCs, myoblasts (as a committed negative control) or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) via intraperitoneal injection. NEC rats treated with AFSCs showed significantly higher survival at 7 days in comparison to all the other groups, and had an improved NEC clinical status at 96 h. The MRI scans displayed significantly decreased peritoneal fluid accumulation (a surrogate marker for NEC grade) in the AFSC-treated rats. The improved clinical picture of the pups injected with AFSCs was also evident by measurement of intestinal permeability, contraction and motility.
The observational data were confirmed by histological analysis, demonstrating a decreased amount of villus sloughing, core separation and venous congestion. The relationship between these therapeutic effects and the presence of AFSCs in the intestine was confirmed by tracking AFSCs expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP). The cells were adherent to the mesentery at 48 h, found in the serosa and muscularis at 72 h and located in the villi at 96 h. The low cell numbers in these locations alongside the great clinical differences between treated groups suggested a paracrine effect. Accordingly, when we performed microarray analysis, we observed differences in a number of genes involved in inflammation and tissue repair, cell-cycle regulation and enterocyte differentiation. These results were corroborated by immunofluorescence analysis examining cell proliferation and apoptosis.
We then sought to investigate the paracrine mechanism by which AFSCs mediate their therapeutic effect, establishing that the number of cryptal cells expressing cyclo-oxygenase-2 (COX-2 + ) inversely correlated with the degree of intestinal damage. COX-2 + cells were diminished in rats treated with PBS, whereas they were maintained in rats treated with AFSCs. Interestingly, even though the total number of COX-2 + cells in villi was similar in AFSC-treated and control animals, cryptal COX-2 + cells were significantly increased in the AFSC rats in comparison to both control and pups treated with PBS. This dependence on COX-2 was confirmed when the effect of AFSCs was abolished by both selective COX-2 and non-selective COX inhibition (COX-1 and COX-2), but remained unaffected by a selective COX-1 inhibitor.
Haematopoietic system
Ditadi and colleagues were the first to demonstrate the haematopoietic potential of murine and human CD117 positive/lineage negative AFSCs . In vitro, the AFSC population in both species displayed multi-lineage haematopoietic potential, as demonstrated by the generation of erythroid, myeloid and lymphoid cells (haematopoietic lineages). In vivo, cells belonging to all haematopoietic lineages were found after primary and secondary transplantation of murine AFSCs into immunocompromised hosts, thus demonstrating the long-term haematopoietic repopulating capacity of these cells. The latter results support the idea that the AF may be a source of stem cells with potential for therapy of haematological disorders.
One of the most exciting applications of AFSCs in this setting is in the field of in utero transplantation (IUT). IUT has been proposed as a novel approach for the treatment of inherited haematological disorders (including thalassaemia and sickle cell disease) before birth . Clinical translation to date has been limited by competitive and immunological barriers associated with IUT of adult bone-marrow-derived haematopoietic stem cells (BMHSCs) . The use of AFSCs for IUT could address many of these limitations. AFSCs are of foetal origin and, as a result, should be able to compete better against host cells in comparison to adult stem cells (potentially overcoming competitive barriers to engraftment). Due to the tolerogenic properties of the placenta, AFSCs are non-immunogenic to the foetus at any gestational age and are also unlikely to result in maternal immunisation. The IUT of AFSCs would involve harvesting the cells from the AF, in vitro gene therapy to correct the genetic defect and transplantation back to the donor foetus. Such a combined autologous stem cell–gene transfer approach would also address some of the risks associated with administering gene therapy directly to the foetus (in utero gene therapy; IUGT) . The possibility of performing in vitro gene transfer to harvested ASFCs would allow cells to be checked for insertional mutagenesis prior to transplantation, and it would obviate the risk of germ-line transmission of transgenes. In recent proof-of-principle studies, Shaw and colleagues showed that in utero transplantation of autologous (isolated using ultrasound-guided amniocentesis), expanded and transduced AFSCs resulted in widespread tissue engraftment (including the haematopoietic system) in the ovine foetus . At present, we are investigating the haematopoietic potential of freshly isolated and expanded AFSCs following intravenous transplantation in immunocompetent foetal mice, and we have obtained stable, multi-lineage engraftment at near-therapeutic levels using relatively small donor cell numbers (Loukogeorgakis et al.; unpublished data). However, despite encouraging preliminary data, whether in utero stem cell–gene therapy with AFSCs would be therapeutic in models of haematological and other congenital disorders remains to be determined.
Musculoskeletal system
We have investigated the osteogenic potential of AFSCs after they were cultured in a medium containing dexamethasone, β-glycerophosphate and ascorbic acid-2-phosphate. Following seeding in a collagen/alginate scaffold, they were implanted subcutaneously in immunodeficient mice. At 18 weeks, micro-computed tomography (CT) revealed highly mineralised tissues and blocks of bone-like material . In a study by Sun et al. osteogenic differentiation of human amniotic fluid stem cells (hAFSCs) was achieved using bone morphogenetic protein-7 (rhBMP-7) and seeding on nanofibrous scaffolds, as evident by alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, calcium content, von Kossa staining and the expression of osteogenic genes. Implantation into the subcutaneous space led to bone formation in 8 weeks with positive von Kossa staining and a radioopaque profile on X-ray .
A series of experiments by the Goldberg laboratory investigated osteogenesis of AFSCs following seeding on a poly-(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) biodegradable polymer. Cells that were differentiated in a three-dimensional (3-D) PCL scaffold deposited mineralised matrix and were viable after 15 weeks of culture. It was also shown that pre-differentiated cells in vitro produced seven times more mineralised matrix when implanted subcutaneously in vivo. The authors obtained some remarkable results when comparing AFSCs and BMMSCs for osteogenesis following seeding on scaffolds and long-term in vitro culture. Although BMMSCs differentiated more rapidly than AFSCs, their growth and production of mineralised matrix halted at 5 weeks. In sharp contrast, AFSCs continued producing matrix for up to 15 weeks, thus leading to an overall production that was five times larger in comparison to BMMSC-seeded scaffolds. In another comparison, PCL scaffolds coated with adeno-associated viral vector encoding bone morphogenetic protein 2 (scAAV2.5-BMP-2) were seeded with AFSCs and BMMSCs. Whereas BMP-2 was shown to have increased production in both populations after 2 weeks in vitro, it was only the BMMSCs that had significantly increased mineral formation. It was interesting how both acellular-coated and BMMSC-seeded scaffolds led to increased mineral formation and mechanical properties when used to cover large femoral defects.
More recently, we demonstrated for the first time the functional and stable long-term integration of AFS cells into the skeletal muscle of HSA-Cre SmnF7/F7 mutant mice, which closely replicate the clinical features of human muscular dystrophy . AFSCs were obtained from E11.5–13.5 GFP + mice through immediate CD117 selection after AF collection. Approximately, 25,000 freshly isolated AFSCs were directly injected into the tail vein of each animal without previous expansion in culture. Transplanted mice displayed enhanced muscle strength, improved survival rate by 75% and restored muscle phenotype in comparison to untreated animals. Not only was the dystrophin distribution in GFP + myofibres similar to that of wild-type animals but GFP+ cells were also found engrafted into the muscle stem cell niche as demonstrated by their sub-laminal position and Pax7 and alpha7integrin expression. Functional integration of AFSCs in the stem cell niche was confirmed by successful secondary transplants of GFP + satellite cells derived from AFSC-treated mice into untreated SmnF7/F7 mutant mice. In order to progress towards their application for therapy, the therapeutic potential of cultivated AFSCs was also investigated, and 25,000 AFSCs previously expanded in the culture were intravenously injected into SmnF7/F7 mice. Despite maintaining their therapeutic potential, cultivated AFSCs regenerated approximately 20% of the recipient muscle fibres versus 50% when using freshly isolated AFSCs, thus, highlighting the importance of optimising cell expansion conditions . In summary, the available data support the potential of AFSCs (1) to differentiate towards the myogenic lineage; (2) to participate in muscle regeneration concerning animal models with muscle injury; and (3) to engraft and participate in the muscle stem cell niche. Therefore, AFSCs constitute a promising therapeutic option for musculoskeletal and muscle degenerative diseases. Understanding the process of AFSCs’ myogenesis in vivo and improving cell expansion in vitro will be essential requisites before this could happen.
Nervous system
We have previously investigated human AFSC injection in the brain of twitcher mice (model of Krabbe globoid leucodystrophy, associated with progressive oligodendrocyte and neuronal loss). Human AFSCs engrafted into the lateral cerebral ventricles, differentiated to cells similar with the surrounding environment and survived for up to 2 months. It was also demonstrated that engraftment was variable, with 70% of AFSCs surviving in the brain of twitcher mice, in contrast to only 30% of AFSCs shown to survive in the brain of normal mice . A study by Prasongchean et al. indicated that treatment with small molecules that normally lead to neuronal differentiation and grafting of AFSCs into environments such as organotypic rat hippocampal cultures and the embryonic chick nervous system led to no expression of neural cell markers. However, AFSCs reduced haemorrhage and increased survival in a chick embryo model of extensive thoracic crush injury. Survival rates did not improve through mesenchymal cells, neural cells or desmopressin. The authors explained this effect in association with the secretion of paracrine factors as evidenced by a trans-well co-culture model .
Respiratory system
AFSCs have been shown to have plastic regenerative properties in the lungs, by differentiating into different lineages according to the type of lung injury taking place in animal models of disease. AFSCs injected intravascularly into nude mice subjected to hyperoxia-induced pulmonary injury, migrated to the lung and expressed the human pulmonary epithelial differentiation marker thyroid transcription factor 1 (TTF1) and type-II pneumocyte marker surfactant protein C (SPC). Following naphthalene injury to Clara cells, AFSCs expressed the Clara cell-specific 10-kDa protein .
Beneficial effects of cell therapy with AFSCs have also been reported in the setting of lung hypoplasia, with potential applications in patients with congenital diaphragmatic hernia or prematurity. A study by Pederiva and colleagues showed, in the rat nitrofen model of pulmonary hypoplasia, that early prenatal administration of expanded AFSCs improved lung growth, bronchial motility and innervation, both in vitro and in vivo . The salutary effects of AFSC transplantation were related to release and paracrine activity of growth factors including fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10) and vascular endothelial growth factor alpha (VEGF-α).
Urinary system
The first evidence in terms of a nephrogenic potential of AFSCs arose from a series of experiments involving the ex vivo growth of murine embryonic kidneys that were injected with labelled AFSCs. Whilst AFSCs were viable for up to 10 days of growth, they were also shown to contribute to a number of components of the developing kidneys, such as the renal vesicle, S- and C-shape bodies. In addition, the extracellular matrix (ECM) and surrounding cells induced renal differentiation, with the AFSCs expressing kidney markers (zona occludens-1, glial-derived neurotrophic factor and claudin) .
In a mouse model of acute tubular necrosis (ATN) that involved glycerol injection, luciferase-labelled AFSCs that were injected intra-renally homed to the kidney. This decreased creatinine and blood urea nitrogen (BUN) levels and reduced the number of damaged tubules, whilst increasing proliferation of tubular epithelial cells. Interestingly, AFSCs injected during the acute phase of ATN (between 48 and 72 h) had no effect on creatinine and BUN levels, whereas AFSCs injected into the kidneys on the same day of glycerol injection resulted in no observed peaks in creatinine or BUN. The authors speculated that this may be due to AFSCs accelerating the proliferation of partially damaged epithelial tubular cells, whilst, in addition, preventing apoptosis . Another laboratory confirmed the protective effect of AFSCs in the same mouse model of ATN, whilst comparing their effect with MSCs. In addition to results in terms of amelioration concerning the effect of glycerol, MSCs were reported to be more efficient in inducing proliferation, and AFSCs were more anti-apoptotic. To assess the effect of AFSCs in renal fibrosis, Sedrakyan et al. used Col4a5(-/-) mice as a murine model of Alport syndrome . Early intracardiac administration of AFSCs delayed interstitial fibrosis and progression of glomerular sclerosis, and prolonged animal survival. However, AFSCs did not exhibit differentiation into podocytes, suggesting a paracrine mechanism that mediated the positive effects on the basement membrane .
Amniotic fluid stem cells
Characteristics, isolation and culture
The first suggestion that the AF may contain undifferentiated cells originated from a group that demonstrated the expression of skeletal muscle proteins when cells were cultured in the supernatant of rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines . Subsequently, amniotic fluid-derived cells were reported to differentiate into osteocytes, adipocytes and fibroblasts, whilst having a cell marker profile comparable to mesenchymal stem cells . Brivanlou et al. reported the expression of octamer-binding transcription factor-4 (Oct-4) at transcriptional and protein levels, thereby confirming the stem cell potential of a subpopulation of cells (0.5–1%) have stem cell potential . Oct-4 is a POU-domain transcription factor that maintains pluripotency and self-renewal in populations such as embryonic stem cells (ESCs), induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) and carcinoma cell lines.
De Coppi et al. used CD117 (a type III tyrosine kinase receptor for stem cell factor) as a means to select out the undifferentiated population from the AF, via either magnetic or fluorescent-activated cell sorting (MACS and FACS respectively) . Following selection, the cells are cultured in feeder layer-free, serum-rich conditions consisting of Chang medium B and C, α-minimum essential medium (α-MEM) and foetal bovine serum (FBS). The medium is changed every 2–3 days and the cells are passaged to maintain confluence below 60% in order to ensure multipotency.
The CD117-expressing (CD117 + ) subpopulation (AF stem cells; AFSCs) comprises 1% of cells and proliferates rapidly with clonal lines having a doubling time of 36 h . In addition, AFSCs maintain a normal karyotype following 250 population doublings with stable telomeres. In vitro experiments have demonstrated a potential for these cells to differentiate into all three germ layers. The endodermal potential of AFSCs was determined by differentiation into hepatocytes expressing albumin, α-fetoprotein and c-met receptor following growth in a hepatocytic medium. Differentiation towards ectoderm was demonstrated using culture conditions promoting the development of neural stem cells (nestin expression) and dopaminergic neurons (G-protein-gated, inwardly rectifying potassium channel-2 gene expression). The mesodermal potential was shown by differentiation into myotubes, adipocytes, endothelial cells and chondrocytes . AFSCs expressed a number of ESC markers such as Oct-4 and stage-specific embryonic antigen-4 (SSEA-4), but not the entire range of proteins associated with pluripotency. When cultured in adherence, AFSCs were negative for markers of haematopoietic lineage (CD45) and haematopoietic stem cells (CD133, CD34), confirming the lack of contamination with other cells from the umbilical cord and foetal blood .
Some researchers have suggested that AFSCs may have a pluripotent potential similar to ESCs or iPS . However, this is still unclear and possibly one of the reasons why AFSCs represent a cell population with enhanced regenerative applicability. Strictly speaking, pluripotent cells are defined by the ability to (i) be cultured indefinitely in an undifferentiated state, whilst remaining diploid with a normal karyotype; (ii) form clonal lines; (iii) differentiate towards all three germ layers in vitro; (iv) form teratomas in vivo; and (v) differentiate into all three germ layers when injected into a blastocyst. AFSCs can be reprogrammed to pluripotency without any genetic manipulation; however, to the authors’ opinion, prior to full reprogramming, they do not fulfil the last two criteria suggesting a broadly multipotent potential .
ESCs derived from humans have been considered to have great potential for therapy due to their high self-renewal capacity, pluripotency and ease of reproducibility, evident by the derivation of human ESCs by many laboratories using well-established protocols . However, major issues have hindered their clinical translation including allogeneic immunogenicity, tumorigenic potential and ethical concerns. The first two are particularly important if whole-organ generation is considered. Two major limitations associated with practical application of human ESCs (immunogenicity and ethical issues) were overcome following the generation of human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) . As human iPSCs could be developed from an autologous biopsy, allogeneic immunogenicity was not a problem, except for storage-associated modifications similar to those occurring in red blood cells stored prior to autotransfusion . Current issues limiting the clinical translation of human iPSCs include the low efficiency of iPSC generation methods, and the risks associated with the use of viral vectors that integrate into the genetic material of cells (risk of insertional mutagenesis and tumorigenesis).
Therefore, there is great potential to use AFSCs for clinical translation, mainly due to their differentiation capabilities, in vitro culture characteristics and the lack of tumorigenic potential and ethical concerns. In addition, if pluripotency were needed, AFSCs could be efficiently reprogrammed to generate iPSCs using a single chemical substance (i.e., valproic acid, a Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drug for the treatment of epilepsy), thus eliminating any risks of insertional mutagenesis . Finally, as AFSCs originate from the foetus, they could be used as an autologous stem cell source for pre- and postnatal regenerative medicine applications.
Regenerative medicine applications
Cardiovascular system
We have previously looked at the cardiomyogenic potential of AFSCs in vitro and in vivo. AFSCs cultured in cardiomyocyte induction media or in co-culture with cardiomyocytes demonstrated expression of proteins specific for cardiomyocytes (atrial natriuretic peptide and α-myosin heavy chain), endothelial (CD31, CD144) and smooth muscle cells (α-smooth muscle actin). In our first experience with xenogeneic transplantation, human AFSCs were transplanted in a rat model of myocardial infarction (MI). Cells of the immune system were recruited including T cells, B cells, natural killer (NK) cells and macrophages resulting in cell rejection. We speculated that this may be due to AFSC expression of the B7 co-stimulatory molecules CD80 and CD86, as well as macrophage marker CD68 . Next, we attempted allogeneic rat AFSC cardiac therapy by intracardiac transplantation in rats with ischaemia–reperfusion injury (IR). A portion of the cells acquired an endothelial or smooth muscle phenotype, and a smaller number had cardiomyocyte characteristics, 3 weeks following transplantation. The left ventricular ejection fraction was improved in animals that received the AFSC injection, as quantified using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), suggesting a paracrine therapeutic effect . The aim was to further investigate this paracrine effect using a rat model of MI and xenogeneic transplantation of human AFSCs administered intravascularly immediately following reperfusion. This was dissimilar to our previous attempt with xenogeneic cellular cardiomyoplasty, which involved intramuscular injection of human AFSCs within 20 min of coronary artery occlusion without reperfusion. Intravascular injection of human AFSCs and their conditioned medium showed a cardioprotective effect, improved cell survival and decreased the infarct size from 54% to around 40% in both cases. We have also shown that AFSCs secrete the actin monomer-binding protein thymosin beta-4 (Tβ-4), a paracrine factor with cardioprotective properties . Tβ-4 had also previously been implicated in cardioprotection in MI models that involved bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell (BMMSC) injection .
In addition to models of myocardial IR injury, we have investigated the salutary effects of AFSCs in a rat model of right heart failure secondary to pulmonary hypertension. Following intravascular injection, AFSCs engrafted in the lungs, heart and skeletal muscle, reducing the levels of brain natriuretic peptide (BNP), a surrogate marker for heart failure, and pro-inflammatory cytokines. In addition, AFSCs differentiated into endothelial and vascular cells forming micro-vessels, capillaries and small arteries. A 35% decrease in pulmonary arteriole thickness accompanied the injection .
Gastrointestinal system
We have recently looked at the effect of AFSCs in a rat model of necrotising enterocolitis (NEC) that involved hypoxia, hypothermia, gavage feeding with a hyperosmolar formula, hypoxia and administration of lipopolysaccharide. After 24 h of life, NEC rats were randomised to treatments of either AFSCs, BMMSCs, myoblasts (as a committed negative control) or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) via intraperitoneal injection. NEC rats treated with AFSCs showed significantly higher survival at 7 days in comparison to all the other groups, and had an improved NEC clinical status at 96 h. The MRI scans displayed significantly decreased peritoneal fluid accumulation (a surrogate marker for NEC grade) in the AFSC-treated rats. The improved clinical picture of the pups injected with AFSCs was also evident by measurement of intestinal permeability, contraction and motility.
The observational data were confirmed by histological analysis, demonstrating a decreased amount of villus sloughing, core separation and venous congestion. The relationship between these therapeutic effects and the presence of AFSCs in the intestine was confirmed by tracking AFSCs expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP). The cells were adherent to the mesentery at 48 h, found in the serosa and muscularis at 72 h and located in the villi at 96 h. The low cell numbers in these locations alongside the great clinical differences between treated groups suggested a paracrine effect. Accordingly, when we performed microarray analysis, we observed differences in a number of genes involved in inflammation and tissue repair, cell-cycle regulation and enterocyte differentiation. These results were corroborated by immunofluorescence analysis examining cell proliferation and apoptosis.
We then sought to investigate the paracrine mechanism by which AFSCs mediate their therapeutic effect, establishing that the number of cryptal cells expressing cyclo-oxygenase-2 (COX-2 + ) inversely correlated with the degree of intestinal damage. COX-2 + cells were diminished in rats treated with PBS, whereas they were maintained in rats treated with AFSCs. Interestingly, even though the total number of COX-2 + cells in villi was similar in AFSC-treated and control animals, cryptal COX-2 + cells were significantly increased in the AFSC rats in comparison to both control and pups treated with PBS. This dependence on COX-2 was confirmed when the effect of AFSCs was abolished by both selective COX-2 and non-selective COX inhibition (COX-1 and COX-2), but remained unaffected by a selective COX-1 inhibitor.
Haematopoietic system
Ditadi and colleagues were the first to demonstrate the haematopoietic potential of murine and human CD117 positive/lineage negative AFSCs . In vitro, the AFSC population in both species displayed multi-lineage haematopoietic potential, as demonstrated by the generation of erythroid, myeloid and lymphoid cells (haematopoietic lineages). In vivo, cells belonging to all haematopoietic lineages were found after primary and secondary transplantation of murine AFSCs into immunocompromised hosts, thus demonstrating the long-term haematopoietic repopulating capacity of these cells. The latter results support the idea that the AF may be a source of stem cells with potential for therapy of haematological disorders.
One of the most exciting applications of AFSCs in this setting is in the field of in utero transplantation (IUT). IUT has been proposed as a novel approach for the treatment of inherited haematological disorders (including thalassaemia and sickle cell disease) before birth . Clinical translation to date has been limited by competitive and immunological barriers associated with IUT of adult bone-marrow-derived haematopoietic stem cells (BMHSCs) . The use of AFSCs for IUT could address many of these limitations. AFSCs are of foetal origin and, as a result, should be able to compete better against host cells in comparison to adult stem cells (potentially overcoming competitive barriers to engraftment). Due to the tolerogenic properties of the placenta, AFSCs are non-immunogenic to the foetus at any gestational age and are also unlikely to result in maternal immunisation. The IUT of AFSCs would involve harvesting the cells from the AF, in vitro gene therapy to correct the genetic defect and transplantation back to the donor foetus. Such a combined autologous stem cell–gene transfer approach would also address some of the risks associated with administering gene therapy directly to the foetus (in utero gene therapy; IUGT) . The possibility of performing in vitro gene transfer to harvested ASFCs would allow cells to be checked for insertional mutagenesis prior to transplantation, and it would obviate the risk of germ-line transmission of transgenes. In recent proof-of-principle studies, Shaw and colleagues showed that in utero transplantation of autologous (isolated using ultrasound-guided amniocentesis), expanded and transduced AFSCs resulted in widespread tissue engraftment (including the haematopoietic system) in the ovine foetus . At present, we are investigating the haematopoietic potential of freshly isolated and expanded AFSCs following intravenous transplantation in immunocompetent foetal mice, and we have obtained stable, multi-lineage engraftment at near-therapeutic levels using relatively small donor cell numbers (Loukogeorgakis et al.; unpublished data). However, despite encouraging preliminary data, whether in utero stem cell–gene therapy with AFSCs would be therapeutic in models of haematological and other congenital disorders remains to be determined.
Musculoskeletal system
We have investigated the osteogenic potential of AFSCs after they were cultured in a medium containing dexamethasone, β-glycerophosphate and ascorbic acid-2-phosphate. Following seeding in a collagen/alginate scaffold, they were implanted subcutaneously in immunodeficient mice. At 18 weeks, micro-computed tomography (CT) revealed highly mineralised tissues and blocks of bone-like material . In a study by Sun et al. osteogenic differentiation of human amniotic fluid stem cells (hAFSCs) was achieved using bone morphogenetic protein-7 (rhBMP-7) and seeding on nanofibrous scaffolds, as evident by alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, calcium content, von Kossa staining and the expression of osteogenic genes. Implantation into the subcutaneous space led to bone formation in 8 weeks with positive von Kossa staining and a radioopaque profile on X-ray .
A series of experiments by the Goldberg laboratory investigated osteogenesis of AFSCs following seeding on a poly-(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) biodegradable polymer. Cells that were differentiated in a three-dimensional (3-D) PCL scaffold deposited mineralised matrix and were viable after 15 weeks of culture. It was also shown that pre-differentiated cells in vitro produced seven times more mineralised matrix when implanted subcutaneously in vivo. The authors obtained some remarkable results when comparing AFSCs and BMMSCs for osteogenesis following seeding on scaffolds and long-term in vitro culture. Although BMMSCs differentiated more rapidly than AFSCs, their growth and production of mineralised matrix halted at 5 weeks. In sharp contrast, AFSCs continued producing matrix for up to 15 weeks, thus leading to an overall production that was five times larger in comparison to BMMSC-seeded scaffolds. In another comparison, PCL scaffolds coated with adeno-associated viral vector encoding bone morphogenetic protein 2 (scAAV2.5-BMP-2) were seeded with AFSCs and BMMSCs. Whereas BMP-2 was shown to have increased production in both populations after 2 weeks in vitro, it was only the BMMSCs that had significantly increased mineral formation. It was interesting how both acellular-coated and BMMSC-seeded scaffolds led to increased mineral formation and mechanical properties when used to cover large femoral defects.
More recently, we demonstrated for the first time the functional and stable long-term integration of AFS cells into the skeletal muscle of HSA-Cre SmnF7/F7 mutant mice, which closely replicate the clinical features of human muscular dystrophy . AFSCs were obtained from E11.5–13.5 GFP + mice through immediate CD117 selection after AF collection. Approximately, 25,000 freshly isolated AFSCs were directly injected into the tail vein of each animal without previous expansion in culture. Transplanted mice displayed enhanced muscle strength, improved survival rate by 75% and restored muscle phenotype in comparison to untreated animals. Not only was the dystrophin distribution in GFP + myofibres similar to that of wild-type animals but GFP+ cells were also found engrafted into the muscle stem cell niche as demonstrated by their sub-laminal position and Pax7 and alpha7integrin expression. Functional integration of AFSCs in the stem cell niche was confirmed by successful secondary transplants of GFP + satellite cells derived from AFSC-treated mice into untreated SmnF7/F7 mutant mice. In order to progress towards their application for therapy, the therapeutic potential of cultivated AFSCs was also investigated, and 25,000 AFSCs previously expanded in the culture were intravenously injected into SmnF7/F7 mice. Despite maintaining their therapeutic potential, cultivated AFSCs regenerated approximately 20% of the recipient muscle fibres versus 50% when using freshly isolated AFSCs, thus, highlighting the importance of optimising cell expansion conditions . In summary, the available data support the potential of AFSCs (1) to differentiate towards the myogenic lineage; (2) to participate in muscle regeneration concerning animal models with muscle injury; and (3) to engraft and participate in the muscle stem cell niche. Therefore, AFSCs constitute a promising therapeutic option for musculoskeletal and muscle degenerative diseases. Understanding the process of AFSCs’ myogenesis in vivo and improving cell expansion in vitro will be essential requisites before this could happen.
Nervous system
We have previously investigated human AFSC injection in the brain of twitcher mice (model of Krabbe globoid leucodystrophy, associated with progressive oligodendrocyte and neuronal loss). Human AFSCs engrafted into the lateral cerebral ventricles, differentiated to cells similar with the surrounding environment and survived for up to 2 months. It was also demonstrated that engraftment was variable, with 70% of AFSCs surviving in the brain of twitcher mice, in contrast to only 30% of AFSCs shown to survive in the brain of normal mice . A study by Prasongchean et al. indicated that treatment with small molecules that normally lead to neuronal differentiation and grafting of AFSCs into environments such as organotypic rat hippocampal cultures and the embryonic chick nervous system led to no expression of neural cell markers. However, AFSCs reduced haemorrhage and increased survival in a chick embryo model of extensive thoracic crush injury. Survival rates did not improve through mesenchymal cells, neural cells or desmopressin. The authors explained this effect in association with the secretion of paracrine factors as evidenced by a trans-well co-culture model .
Respiratory system
AFSCs have been shown to have plastic regenerative properties in the lungs, by differentiating into different lineages according to the type of lung injury taking place in animal models of disease. AFSCs injected intravascularly into nude mice subjected to hyperoxia-induced pulmonary injury, migrated to the lung and expressed the human pulmonary epithelial differentiation marker thyroid transcription factor 1 (TTF1) and type-II pneumocyte marker surfactant protein C (SPC). Following naphthalene injury to Clara cells, AFSCs expressed the Clara cell-specific 10-kDa protein .
Beneficial effects of cell therapy with AFSCs have also been reported in the setting of lung hypoplasia, with potential applications in patients with congenital diaphragmatic hernia or prematurity. A study by Pederiva and colleagues showed, in the rat nitrofen model of pulmonary hypoplasia, that early prenatal administration of expanded AFSCs improved lung growth, bronchial motility and innervation, both in vitro and in vivo . The salutary effects of AFSC transplantation were related to release and paracrine activity of growth factors including fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10) and vascular endothelial growth factor alpha (VEGF-α).
Urinary system
The first evidence in terms of a nephrogenic potential of AFSCs arose from a series of experiments involving the ex vivo growth of murine embryonic kidneys that were injected with labelled AFSCs. Whilst AFSCs were viable for up to 10 days of growth, they were also shown to contribute to a number of components of the developing kidneys, such as the renal vesicle, S- and C-shape bodies. In addition, the extracellular matrix (ECM) and surrounding cells induced renal differentiation, with the AFSCs expressing kidney markers (zona occludens-1, glial-derived neurotrophic factor and claudin) .
In a mouse model of acute tubular necrosis (ATN) that involved glycerol injection, luciferase-labelled AFSCs that were injected intra-renally homed to the kidney. This decreased creatinine and blood urea nitrogen (BUN) levels and reduced the number of damaged tubules, whilst increasing proliferation of tubular epithelial cells. Interestingly, AFSCs injected during the acute phase of ATN (between 48 and 72 h) had no effect on creatinine and BUN levels, whereas AFSCs injected into the kidneys on the same day of glycerol injection resulted in no observed peaks in creatinine or BUN. The authors speculated that this may be due to AFSCs accelerating the proliferation of partially damaged epithelial tubular cells, whilst, in addition, preventing apoptosis . Another laboratory confirmed the protective effect of AFSCs in the same mouse model of ATN, whilst comparing their effect with MSCs. In addition to results in terms of amelioration concerning the effect of glycerol, MSCs were reported to be more efficient in inducing proliferation, and AFSCs were more anti-apoptotic. To assess the effect of AFSCs in renal fibrosis, Sedrakyan et al. used Col4a5(-/-) mice as a murine model of Alport syndrome . Early intracardiac administration of AFSCs delayed interstitial fibrosis and progression of glomerular sclerosis, and prolonged animal survival. However, AFSCs did not exhibit differentiation into podocytes, suggesting a paracrine mechanism that mediated the positive effects on the basement membrane .
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel
Full access? Get Clinical Tree