Newborn Intensive Care Unit Design: Scientific and Practical Considerations



Newborn Intensive Care Unit Design: Scientific and Practical Considerations


Robert D. White

Gilbert I. Martin

Judith Smith

Stanley N. Graven



DEVELOPING A MISSION STATEMENT

The first step in a successful newborn intensive care unit (NICU) design project is the development of a shared vision among NICU, hospital, and community leaders. The construction of a new unit or redesign of an existing facility should successfully address key problems in the region’s current system of neonatal care. For an existing, stable unit wishing to modernize its facility, these problems may be primarily internal—the need for more space, current technology, and family support. For an entirely new facility, these issues will be predominantly external—who are the existing providers and what niche will this new unit most appropriately fill? A careful appraisal of medical care trends anticipated within the community over the next 20 years, especially with regard to obstetric and intensive care services, should precede any decision on a mission statement intended to guide NICU construction and operation. Whether a hospital is the only provider of NICU services in its area or one of several, it is crucial that it understand its niche and the responsibilities inherent to that role, so that appropriate physical facilities can be constructed to fulfill its mission.

A mission statement that might provide a framework for many NICUs is as follows:

The Newborn Intensive Care Unit will provide a state-of-the-art, integrated, family-centered approach to neonatal care. This interdisciplinary program will strive to give patients, families, and payers high quality and compassionate care through the provision of:



  • Care that honors the racial, ethnic, cultural, religious, and socioeconomic diversity of family and staff


  • Education, information, and emotional support


  • Access to the most current effective therapies


  • Integrated treatment plans emphasizing coordination throughout the continuum of care


  • Encouragement of family support and involvement

When consensus is reached on a mission statement, specific goals and objectives can be defined that apply this mission to the local realities of demographics, care practices, and competition. Defining these goals will be the first step toward decisions on bed capacity, types of equipment needed, and changes in care practices. All of these can then be explored in depth by the teams described below. The goals and objectives should be measurable (e.g., survival and morbidity rates compared to regional and national standards, staff experience and turnover, parental satisfaction ratings, cost per patient day) and realistic, so that the overall value of the project can be ascertained at the time cost projections are available, and on an ongoing basis after construction is complete.


CREATING THE TEAMS

Once a decision has been made to proceed with the development of either a new or a renovated NICU, it is important to form specialized teams with well-defined goals. In many hospitals, several persons will serve on two or more teams. Each team should have access to the several excellent reference materials available to assist in the design of an NICU (1,2,3,4,5,6).


The Strategic Planning Team

The strategic planning team will continue to develop the vision and goals that led to the decision to pursue new
construction. It should include, at a minimum, an administrator, a neonatologist, and a nursing director. This group will be responsible for reviewing utilization and demographic information (available from state and local planning and health agencies, the insurance industry, and the Census Bureau) in order to define the NICU’s service area and appropriate number of beds. Some general guidelines in this area include estimates that 5% to 12% of all newborns will need intensive care at the time of birth, and 1% to 2% will need ventilator care. Total NICU days for a defined region will approximate 1.25 patient-days per live birth—if a region has 10,000 live births per year, it will generate approximately 13,000 NICU patient days, or an average census of 35 babies, with an average length of stay of 20 to 25 days. These numbers will be influenced considerably by the level of care provided by a particular NICU, referral and back transport patterns, admission and discharge criteria, and competing NICUs serving the same region. Because of fluctuations in census, a unit should have sufficient bed positions to care for 40% to 50% more babies than the average census calculations, so a region with 10,000 deliveries per year will need 50 to 55 NICU beds. Many areas currently exceed this number by a sizable proportion because of serving a particularly high-risk population, or because of inefficiencies inherent in multiple NICUs serving a single region.

The strategic planning team also should make some basic calculations regarding staffing patterns, if this is to be a new service for the hospital. Depending on patient mix, overall staffing patterns may require 4 to 6 nurses and 2 support staff (inclusive of nursing administration, respiratory therapy, developmental therapy, social work, ward clerk, and housekeeping staff) for every 10 babies. A unit with an average census of 20 babies, for example, would require 8 to 12 nurses on each shift, or 40 to 65 full-time equivalents (FTEs), with an additional 20 to 25 FTEs for support staff. One neonatologist is needed for each 6 to 8 babies (average census); this is one area, among several, where units with an average census of less than 20 infants encounter certain inefficiencies because of their size. On the other hand, large units (more than 40 beds or so) can be difficult to design and manage efficiently because of the space requirements. Some hospitals have addressed this issue by dividing their NICU into intensive care and continuing care, or step-down areas. Some units will also need to plan staffing for transport team or nurse practitioner coverage. Six to 7 full-time positions are required for 24-hour coverage of each position for these services. A transport team with 2 nurses and a respiratory therapist, for example, would require at least 12 nurses and 6 therapists to provide full-time, in-house coverage.

Next, the strategic planning team also will need to assess the impact of the new or renovated NICU on other hospital departments, especially obstetric, maintenance, and supply services. When these issues are clear, the team will proceed to interview and engage an architect. The timing of this step is important—the architectural firm should be involved before any design decisions are made, but after the strategic planning team has articulated a clear set of goals for the process. Several architectural firms can be asked to make formal presentations of their general concepts for the project, as well as present examples of other projects that they have designed. The architectural firm chosen should have complete engineering and interior design specialists on staff, as well as an equipment representative and a neonatal nurse planner. The entire architectural team should be familiar with the latest trends in NICU design and the scientific principles behind the design process. Once chosen, the architectural group and the strategic planning team can then develop a timetable for planning and construction of the new facility.


The Financial Planning Team

This group is composed of the hospital’s chief financial and operational officers, nursing management, and any other individuals representing areas of the hospital whose budgets will be significantly affected by the new construction. Consultants, such as those helpful in the equipment selection process (see Equipment Selection section), also may be asked to join the team. The one-time costs for the project will include architectural fees, the physical plant, and new equipment. Ongoing costs may include increased staffing for direct patient care, housekeeping, and maintenance functions. These costs should be clearly identified early in the planning sequence, with the assistance of the care practices team (see The Care Practices Team section). This team should continue to meet intermittently throughout the planning process, because some unanticipated expenses often surface as the design takes shape.


The Care Practices Team

This is the largest group, and it represents caregivers in the NICU. At a minimum, the following disciplines should participate: neonatology, nursing management and staff, respiratory therapy, social work, pharmacy, laboratory, radiology, infection control, nutrition, housekeeping, and parents. Depending on local care practices, surgery, obstetrics, and clinical research may be appropriate additions to this list. As each individual provides information on his or her own specialty to enhance care for babies, families, and staff, the team should be encouraged to look beyond existing practices and view the new construction as an opportunity to change the way things are done. In particular, most NICUs will need to reevaluate their care practices with respect to parental access and developmentally supportive care, which may have been severely restricted under their previous NICU design. They should consider environmental design features that will provide the most optimal living conditions for babies, working conditions for staff, and integration of families, and they should begin to address some of the conflicts inherent in these ideals. As a team, this group can then identify general
space, equipment, staffing, and maintenance and cleaning requirements, which can be reported to the financial and design teams for determination of feasibility.


The Design Team

When the strategic planning, financial planning, and care practice teams have agreed on the general scope of the project, including goals, approximate size and cost, major changes in care practices, and an architectural firm, the design team can begin its work. Members of this team should include the architectural group, the hospital’s project manager, neonatology, nursing, respiratory therapy, parents, and the equipment consultant. After creating a functional plan that addresses all the needs identified by the care practices team, this group should visit new or updated NICUs to get additional ideas, learn how to avoid pitfalls, and solicit suggestions on their functional plan. This team then will meet regularly over several months as blueprints are developed to reconcile all these concepts into a working unit. Detailed minutes should be kept and reviewed at the beginning of each meeting.


SITE VISITS

Touring other NICUs can be a valuable investment for many reasons, whether planning for a renovation or new construction. Visits provide a firsthand look at design features that are and are not working for others. The benefits can include a better plan, fewer change orders, and a smoother transition because the planning team gained new ideas and a clearer understanding of the pros and cons of the proposed changes.

Careful planning will assure that site visits are productive. Start by identifying the objectives of the tours, areas of greatest interest, potential units to visit, and the best timing. The typical purpose of a site visit during the early stages of planning is to trigger ideas. Many NICU teams find it useful to tour other units during the stage when they have identified their vision, defined their care practices, and prepared a preliminary functional program. Others stagger their tours and see different units during various stages of planning. Waiting until the preparation of construction documents is underway is not usually the best timing for initial site visits, unless the objective is to clarify operational issues related to the selected design approach.

Two other essential components to be addressed are selecting the members of the tour group and funding the travel. Selecting tour team members should tie back to the objectives. Most units request a budget for site visits as part of the project funding. Some fortunate units have donors who help with the travel budget, and even include interested donors on the tour team, when appropriate. If a travel budget is not feasible, the next best strategy is virtual tours. In many cases, the NICUs or their architects have photos in hard copy, on Web sites, videos or other material that could be viewed, and several of these are also available on a single Web site (6). A phone interview or written survey would be helpful to provide descriptive information for a virtual tour.


Tips for Planning a Site Visit

Performing the tasks below will enable the planning team to get maximum benefit from a site visit:



  • Interview key people by telephone or in person before touring their unit.


  • Obtain permission to photograph, videotape, or receive audiovisuals already available from public relations, architects, and other sources. If assigning photography to a team member, assure that he or she has the proper equipment and competence.


  • Design a questionnaire that will be used consistently as a guide for all visits.


  • Assign a person or people to key topics to assure all pertinent questions are answered before, during, or after the tour. Categorize questions by area of interest, and create the expectation that the responsible person will report on the findings.


  • Determine how the information from the tour will be used and by whom.


  • After the visit and in a timely manner, discuss and record general impressions of people who toured the facility.


Sample Questionnaire

A questionnaire should be developed to ensure that all needed information in relation to a site visit is captured and recorded. Segments of the questionnaire could be contact information, general statistics, and specific questions.


Contact Information

The contact information should include:



  • Date of Visit


  • Organization Name/Location


  • Contact Names/Titles


  • Phone Numbers/E-mail Addresses/Web Site


  • Who attended from your organization


General Statistics

General statistics should include:



  • Annual NICU volume (and birth volume, if relevant)


  • Number of beds by level of care or other category


  • Annual number of infant transports in and out


  • Average length of stay (by level, if appropriate)


  • Economic and cultural characteristics of population served


  • Acuity of patients served (and information on how acuity is defined)


  • Payer mix


  • Date opened or renovated



Examples of Questions

The questions to ask at the site being visited should include, but not be limited to:



  • Describe the changes that resulted in the current services and facilities and the reasons driving the changes.


  • Were the objectives met? (How is success measured?)


  • What types of NICU health professionals practice at this hospital (number of neonatal nurse practitioners (NNPs), neonatologists, residents, etc.)?


  • What are the key staffing issues that were or need to be resolved?


  • What type of staffing education programss, orientation, budget, and amount of time were required to make changes to the current model?


  • How is each type of patient care room or area used?


  • Where and how are most procedures handled?


  • Describe communication systems among staff, between staff and families and others.


  • Describe special features of unit.


  • What was the biggest challenge related to this project?


  • What would be done differently based on the wisdom learned from the experience?


  • What were the benchmarks or other resources that were most helpful during the planning process?


Other Potential Topics for Questionnaire

Other topics that may be included on the site visit questionnaire are:



  • Family input


  • Visitation practices


  • Family space


  • Care practices


  • Admission process


  • Maintenance


  • Monitoring systems


  • Lighting


  • Sound control


  • Interior design


  • Storage


  • Communication Systems Security


  • Flow paths


  • Cleaning


  • Head walls


  • Staffing


  • Fundraising


  • Total project costs


  • Acceptance by staff/administration


  • Response by community/competitors


  • Ceiling/floor/wall/cabinet finishes patterns


  • Coordination with labor and delivery

One of the final planning steps is to determine how the information gained from the site visit will be shared with the stakeholders who could not participate directly in the tour. Good documentation of the visits and effective presentation of the information will provide maximum benefit from the activities.


SPECIFIC DESIGN ISSUES


Floor Space Requirements

NICUs have historically been undersized, with insufficient room for storage, parental access, and offices, even when accurate estimates are made for the number of babies to be cared for. Change has been incremental, as administrators, architects, and NICU staff gradually expand their horizons to accommodate new practices, particularly increased parental access.

Given this historical perspective and extrapolating from floor space requirements in adult and pediatric intensive care units (ICUs), it is likely that an NICU design should allow 600 gross square feet per bed to meet the needs of the babies, staff, and families. This figure includes office, storage, and support space as well as the patient care areas; gross square footage estimates also include space required for hallways, ductwork, restrooms, and the like. This figure is an average; teaching hospitals with active clinical research programs, for example, might require more than 600 gross square feet per bed, whereas a community NICU might require somewhat less. Any design that provides less than 500 gross square feet per bed will inevitably demand compromises and limit flexibility for the future, when parental access desires and lengths of stay (because of increasing survival of extremely low-birth-weight infants) may be even greater than they are today.

Previous estimates of floor space requirements often recommended square footage per bed position (e.g., 120 to 150 square feet per intensive care bed position), and most state codes still use this convention. If this method is used, an additional 30 square feet of storage space must be planned outside of the patient care area, as well as 24 cubic feet of cabinet storage at each bedside, at a minimum.


Location Within the Hospital

The NICU should be immediately adjacent to the high-risk delivery rooms whenever possible. There are few, if any, NICUs that are more than a few hundred feet from a high-risk delivery service that do not consider their location as the source of certain risks to optimal care. In some circumstances, especially very large hospital complexes or freestanding children’s hospitals, this ideal may be impossible to achieve. In the former situation, a resuscitation area within the delivery room complex or in each delivery suite, always valuable, becomes crucial; in the latter case, all infants are accepted as transfers, and proximity to the ambulance entrance and heliport becomes particularly significant. When the NICU is on a different floor from the delivery suites, as often occurs in larger hospitals, controlled elevator access between these two areas is essential.

Many NICUs, particularly in small or medium-sized hospitals, share staff and responsibilities with the well baby nursery or pediatric ICU. When these areas are
contiguous, much of the support space (e.g., family lounge, staff lockers, equipment storage) can be shared, and the opportunities for staff to assist one another are enhanced.

Traffic patterns for infants who leave the NICU for procedures should be identified and private hallways created wherever possible, so that ill infants and their attendants do not need to use public areas.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 1, 2016 | Posted by in OBSTETRICS | Comments Off on Newborn Intensive Care Unit Design: Scientific and Practical Considerations

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access