Neglect



Neglect


Howard Dubowitz





  • I. Description of the problem. Child neglect is usually defined as parental omissions in care, resulting in actual or potential harm to a child. Child Protective Services (CPS) typically requires evidence of harm, unless the risks are serious (such as when very young children are left home alone). Some states exclude situations attributed to poverty.

    An alternative and broader view of neglect is from a child’s perspective, defining neglect as occurring when a child’s basic needs are not adequately met. Basic needs include adequate healthcare, food, clothing, shelter, supervision/protection, emotional support, education, and nurturance. However, it is often difficult to establish at what point any of these needs are “adequately” met and thresholds may be rather arbitrary. Usually, the “neglect” label is applied to clearly worrisome circumstances. Less serious circumstances may still require intervention, perhaps without labeling them as “neglect.”

    There are several advantages to this child-focused definition. It fits with the broad goal of ensuring children’s health and safety. It is less blaming and more constructive. It draws attention to other contributors to the problem (discussed later) aside from parents, and encourages a broader range of interventions. Clearly, many neglect situations may require intervention (e.g., a child with failure to thrive due to an inadequate diet) but may not warrant or meet criteria for CPS involvement. Practitioners, however, need to be aware of the laws and regulations in their area and factor these into their practice.



    • A. Epidemiology. Neglect is the most common form of child maltreatment, accounting for almost two-thirds of all cases reported annually to CPS. It was a factor in approximately 70% of the estimated 1760 deaths due to child maltreatment in 2007. Because of ambiguity in diagnostic criteria and underreporting, accurate prevalence data are impossible to determine. One study in 2010 identified 30.6 cases of neglect per 1000 (or 2,251,600) children in the population, but it is likely that these are very conservative estimates, as neglect is a problem that frequently occurs “behind closed doors.”


    • B. Manifestations of possible neglect. Aside from direct observation, the possibility of “neglect” should be considered in the following circumstances:



      • Noncompliance (nonadherence) with healthcare recommendations


      • Delay or failure in obtaining medical, mental health, or dental care


      • Hunger, failure to thrive, and unmanaged morbid obesity


      • Drug-exposed newborns and older children


      • Exposure to hazards in the home: ingestions, recurrent injuries, exposure of children with pulmonary disease to second-hand smoke, access to guns, and exposure to intimate partner violence


      • Exposure to hazards outside the home, failure to use car seat/belt, and not wearing bike helmet


      • Emotional concerns (e.g., excessive quietness or apathy in a toddler), behavior issues (e.g., repetitive movements), learning problems (especially if not being addressed), and extreme risk-taking behavior (may reflect inadequate nurturance, affection, or supervision)


      • Inadequate hygiene, contributing to medical problems


      • Inadequate clothing, contributing to medical problems


      • Educational needs not being met


      • Abandoned children


      • Homelessness


    • C. Etiology. There are often multiple and interacting contributors to child neglect, including the following:

Jun 22, 2016 | Posted by in PEDIATRICS | Comments Off on Neglect

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access