Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Youth



Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Youth


Ellen C. Perrin

Nicola J. Smith





  • I. Recognition of sexual orientation and gender identification. Before adolescents are able to self-identify with any form of sexual orientation, they often question what their feelings, fantasies, and behaviors mean, and if they are transient or an intrinsic part of themselves. Rather than relying upon a stringent categorization of individuals as heterosexual, homosexual, or bisexual, sexual orientation should be viewed as a continuum ranging from absolute heterosexuality to absolute homosexuality. Adolescents have come to recognize and acknowledge their sexual orientation at younger ages recently, presumably due to the increased visibility and social acceptance of the diversity of sexual orientation and sexual expression. Given appropriate information and support, individuals generally will resolve uncertainty about sexual orientation by late adolescence through self-exploration of feelings, fantasies, and experiences. Children may also be coming to recognize discomfort with their anatomic sex and explore the implications of a transgender identity at younger ages than was previously believed.


  • II. Definitions of terms.



    • Sexual orientation. A persistent pattern of physical and emotional attraction to members of the same and/or opposite sex. Components include sexual fantasies, emotional and romantic attractions, sexual behavior, and self-identification.


    • Homosexuality. A persistent pattern of same-sex arousal accompanied by weak or absent arousal to members of the opposite sex.

      Lesbian: Popular term for homosexual female.

      Gay: Popular term for homosexual male.


    • Bisexuality. A pattern of arousal toward people of either sex.


    • Transgenderism (transsexuality). A strong and persistent cross-gender identification, not merely a desire for sociocultural advantages of being the other sex. Individuals describe feeling “trapped” in the body of the opposite sex and may seek to alter their physical appearance accordingly. May be heterosexual or homosexual.


    • Transvestism. Dressing in the clothing usually characteristic of the opposite sex; this is not an indication of sexual orientation.


    • Homonegativity is a discomfort, dislike, or critical judgment about people who are not heterosexual.


    • Homophobia is an irrational fear or hatred of homosexual individuals.


    • Heterosexism is the belief that only a heterosexual orientation is “natural” and normal.


  • III. Epidemiology. Evidence suggests that homosexuality has existed in all societies and cultures, but the stigma associated with it is so powerful that it has remained largely unmentionable and secret. Most of the published information is based on reports from middleclass, well-educated, Caucasian populations, as the stigma of homosexuality is even greater among people of color, certain religions, and developing nations.



    • The percentage of teenagers reporting predominantly homosexual attractions steadily increases with age, with a peak of 6%-10% among 18-year-old students. Up to 35% of students report sexual experiences with a partner of the same sex.


  • IV. Factors contributing to sexual orientation.



    • A. Environmental/social process theory. There is no scientific evidence that certain parenting practices and/or other environmental factors lead to homosexual orientation. The early theory of “dominant mother-passive uninvolved father” is no longer accepted. Sexual orientation is considered innate.


    • B. Organic/hormonal theory. The biological theory of sexual orientation suggests that sexual orientation is a consequence of the early biological environment and/or events. Neuroanatomically, investigations of brain activity by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), functional MRI, and positron emission tomography scans demonstrate differences in functioning in sexually dimorphic areas depending on sexual orientation, most showing that brain functioning of homosexual males is more similar to that of heterosexual females than of heterosexual males, or are intermediate. Fewer studies have been
      performed on homosexual females. Some studies suggest that prenatal hormone levels that are sex atypical may be responsible for various structural and behavioral differences, although studies of hormonal differences in heterosexual and homosexual adults have not yielded consistent differences.


    • C. Genetic etiologies. There have been few studies on the heritability of homosexuality and bisexuality. Most genetic studies are awaiting replication or have failed to be replicated. Twin studies and pedigree investigations have shown that there is a higher concordance in sexual orientation between monozygotic twins than dizygotic, higher concordance in dizygotic twins than nontwin siblings, and that there may be a higher incidence of homosexuality among family members of homosexual individuals than among family members of heterosexual individuals. Although genetic studies focusing on identifying causal genes are slowly increasing in number, no single gene or set of genes has been reliably indicated, and evidence suggests that the development of sexual orientation is a complicated and most likely multifactorial process.


    • D. Can sexuality be changed? Despite numerous assertions that psychosocial interventions could “cure” homosexuality, there is little empirical evidence. While sexual practices, behavior, and identity may have been changed in some investigations, there is no evidence of change in sexual orientation. In addition, there is evidence that the interventions sometimes result in psychological harm. Since 1993, medical associations such as the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), American Medical Association (AMA), and American Psychological Association (APA), have been increasingly vocal against such attempts to change sexual orientation, stating that therapeutic attempts to change sexual orientation are contraindicated and ethically inappropriate.


  • V. Stages in the formation of a homosexual identity. A typical progression in stages of understanding and acceptance of sexual orientation was developed by Richard Troiden in relation to homosexual males, and may differ for females.

    Stage I: sensitization. The prepubertal stage is not within the realm of sexuality, but rather refers to generalized feelings of being different from same-sex peers. This is recognized largely by gender-neutral or gender-atypical interests and behaviors.

    Stage II: identity confusion. The realization in early adolescence that his/her feelings and/or behaviors may be identified as homosexual/bisexual often surprises the youth and clashes with previously held self-images. This results in confusion and uncertainty about sexual identity. Youths may respond to identity confusion in one of several ways:


    Denial: ignoring the feelings/behaviors.

    Repair: attempting to eradicate the feelings/behaviors.

    Avoidance: actively avoiding learning about homosexuality out of fear that the information will confirm their suspicions.

    Redefining: viewing the feelings/behaviors as temporary or evidence of bisexuality.

    Acceptance: resolution of confusion as the youth acknowledges that the feelings, behaviors, and fantasies may be homosexual, and the seeking out of information.

    Stage III: identity assumption. Begins with self-definition as homosexual and may include regular association with other homosexual teens, sexual experimentation, and embarking on the lengthy and complex process of sharing his or her identity with others (“coming out”). Adolescents usually confide in a sibling, friend, or teacher before informing their parents or professionals.

    Stage IV: commitment. Usually marked by self-acceptance, emotional intimacy, and a clear recognition of sexual orientation. Commitment occurs when the youth’s homosexual identity is internalized and integrated. This stage is generally reached during adulthood.


  • VI. Psychosocial and medical risks. Although homosexual youth have many of the same medical concerns and needs as heterosexual teenagers, some are also at increased risk for a variety of psychosocial and medical problems, based on sexual activity and the experience of growing up in a society without widespread acceptance of sexual minorities. The increased risk is not inherent to sexual orientation, as some gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender (GLBT) youth navigate this transition without apparent difficulty. However, social ostracism, stigma, stress, and lack of social support and acceptance may result in mental illness, risky behaviors, and increased healthcare needs. The challenge for pediatric clinicians is to direct youth and their parents to appropriate information and social supports and to be alert to special needs expressed by those GLBT youth who are at increased risk for negative outcomes.

    Heightened risks exist for sexually active GLBT youth for both medical and psychosocial problems (see Table 46-1).

Jun 22, 2016 | Posted by in PEDIATRICS | Comments Off on Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Youth

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access