Fig. 5.1
This shows a flat low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL) (left) contiguous with a condyloma acuminatum (right) at low (a) and medium (b) power together with the accompanying p16 immunostain (c, d). The flat LSIL is block positive for p16, consistent with high-risk HPV infection, whereas the condyloma acuminatum is p16 negative, in keeping with low-risk HPV infection. Note the sharp demarcation between the two lesions
Condylomata acuminata associated with low-risk HPV infection are p16 negative (Fig. 5.1). In this context, negativity is defined as the absence of block-type positivity, which in turn is defined as “continuous strong nuclear or nuclear plus cytoplasmic staining of the basal cell layer with extension upwards involving at least 1/3 of the epithelial thickness. The latter height restriction is somewhat arbitrary but adds specificity” according to the Lower Anogenital Squamous Terminology (LAST) recommendations [6]. Figure 5.1 shows the contrast between block-positive and block-negative p16 staining.
Squamous Papilloma
By definition, a squamous papilloma has a papillary structure, with a fibrovascular core lined by non-atypical squamous epithelium, and is not associated with HPV infection. These morphological features can be seen in association with HPV infection but, when HPV infection is present, a diagnosis of LSIL with a papillomatous or condylomatous pattern is preferred. Immunostaining for p16 and Ki67 can be very useful in identifying those papillomatous lesions associated with HPV infection, as Ki67 expression in the upper squamous epithelium is typically seen in HPV-driven lesions, including those that are associated with low-risk HPV infection and hence p16 negative (Fig. 5.2). Other differential diagnostic considerations include immature squamous metaplasia with a papillary pattern, which in turn may be associated with HPV infection [7].
Fig. 5.2
“Squamous cell papilloma” (a) showing epithelial hyperplasia and single cell dyskeratosis but inconspicuous koilocytosis (b). Ki67 immunostaining shows both parabasal positivity and regional suprabasal positivity in keeping with activation in concert with HPV replication (c, d, arrows). This lesion was p16 negative, consistent with low-risk HPV infection. Given the features associated with HPV infection, this lesion is best categorized as a condyloma acuminatum (LSIL). This case is from the vulva but is included to illustrate the features of a more “papillomatous” condyloma acuminatum
Transitional Metaplasia
Transitional metaplasia is essentially a form of squamous metaplasia in which the lack of cytoplasmic maturation imparts a “transitional” appearance to the epithelium. This is reinforced by the presence of nuclear grooving. The low nucleus-cytoplasm ratio gives this lesion a hyperchromatic appearance at low power and, coupled with the lack of maturation of the epithelium, can lead to misdiagnosis as a high-grade SIL. Immunostaining for p16 is very helpful in resolving this differential diagnosis as transitional metaplasia is p16 negative; Ki67 positivity is also low, by contrast with high-grade SIL [8, 9].
Benign Glandular Lesions
Endocervical Polyp
Endocervical polyps comprise a fibrovascular core containing a variable number of endocervical glands, lined by benign endocervical epithelium. Squamous metaplasia, which is typically immature and may extend to involve endocervical glands, is common, as is microglandular hyperplasia, particularly in women taking hormone preparations (see below). These polyps may be identified incidentally, for example, when taking a cervical smear, but may also be associated with bleeding, particularly postcoitally, and/or discharge. Inflammation, with ulceration and reactive epithelial changes, is common, particularly at the tip of the polyp. Although common and generally benign, endocervical polyps should be examined carefully microscopically, as glandular neoplasia can occasionally involve the glands and SILs can involve the metaplastic squamous epithelium. Cervical sarcomas can also present as cervical polyps (see Chap. 10).
Müllerian Papilloma
This is a specific lesion found in children, most commonly between the ages of 2 and 5 years but with an age range of 1–9 years. This rare entity is considered to be of Müllerian origin, occurs in the upper vagina and cervix as a friable polypoid lesion up to 2 cm in diameter, and presents with vaginal bleeding or discharge [10]. By contrast with the more common endocervical polyp, Müllerian papilloma has branching fibrous papillae. The lining epithelium is benign and cuboidal to columnar but may show metaplastic changes. Local recurrence may occur if incompletely excised, but this lesion is considered to be benign. When considering a diagnosis of Müllerian papilloma, it is important to include Müllerian adenosarcoma and embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma in the differential diagnosis (see Chap. 10).
Nabothian Cysts
Nabothian cysts are distended but otherwise normal endocervical glands. The lining epithelium is often attenuated and may show reactive changes. Most are asymptomatic and come to clinical attention incidentally. Deep cysts may enlarge the cervix and produce a suspicious appearance (see the section below on “Endocervicosis”). Most lesions are asymptomatic, but they can be associated with chronic cervicitis and mucous discharge. In cases of deep wall Nabothian cysts, the cervix can become enlarged and clinically suspicious of a malignant process.
Tunnel Clusters
These common aggregates of benign endocervical glands, which generally form lobular structures, without (type A clusters) or with (type B clusters) cystic change, are typically identified incidentally on microscopic examination of the cervix [11]. When cystic, they can lead to a macroscopic abnormality.
Lobular Endocervical Glandular Hyperplasia (LEGH)
Diffuse Laminar Endocervical Hyperplasia
This is composed of benign but crowded endocervical glands that form a band-like structure beneath the endocervical surface. There is typically an inflammatory infiltrate beneath the glandular aggregates. This entity is discussed further and illustrated in Chap. 8.
Mesonephric Remnants and Hyperplasia
Remnants of the mesonephric (Wolffian) duct are a not uncommon incidental microscopic finding in cervical specimens, particular hysterectomies (Fig. 5.3). These remnants are typically found in the outer cervical wall in a location consistent with the embryological position of the mesonephric duct but can on occasion be present in the inner cervical wall and can communicate with the endocervical canal. A combination of small tubular structures containing PAS-positive eosinophilic material surrounding larger duct-like structures is often present. These structures are lined by predominantly cuboidal epithelial cells [12]. Mesonephric hyperplasia may be lobular or diffuse, the latter on occasion raising the possibility of invasive carcinoma [13]. However, there is minimal atypia and Ki67 labeling is low. Recent studies have identified nuclear GATA3 immunoreactivity to be typical of mesonephric lesions [14, 15], and this can be helpful in difficult cases. Mesonephric carcinoma is discussed in Chap. 11.
Fig. 5.3
Transverse (axial) section of the cervix from a hysterectomy showing a cluster of small glandular structures within the wall of the cervix (a). These are lined by cuboidal epithelial cells and contain eosinophilic material (b, c). The appearances are typical of mesonephric duct remnants
Arias-Stella Reaction
An Arias-Stella reaction may affect the endocervical glandular epithelium in the same way it affects endometrial glands [16]. This produces a potentially worrisome appearance, with enlargement of glandular epithelial cells with hyperchromatic nuclei (Fig. 5.4). The cytoplasm may be clear or show oxyphilic change. Its importance is in its distinction from clear cell or usual type adenocarcinoma of the cervix. An important clue to the diagnosis is a history of current pregnancy or hormone therapy, with which this change is associated. It is a benign hormone-related alteration with no malignant potential.
Fig. 5.4
Loop excision was performed during pregnancy following a biopsy diagnosis of superficially invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix. Focally, the endocervical glands showed marked nuclear pleomorphism (a), which raised concern for adenocarcinoma in situ (b, c). However, the morphological features, in the context of pregnancy and an adjacent prominent decidual reaction (d), led to a diagnosis of Arias-Stella reaction
Endocervicosis
Endocervicosis refers to the presence of endocervical glands in the outer half of the uterine wall [17]. This usually produces a mass, or cyst, involving the cervical wall, typically anteriorly. The epithelium lining the cystic spaces is benign. Mucin extravasation with an accompanying stromal reaction may be seen. There may be a history of antecedent Caesarian section.
Tuboendometrioid Metaplasia
Tuboendometrioid metaplasia of the endocervical glands, in which the lining epithelium resembles the tubal (ciliated) or endometrioid (non-ciliated) epithelium, is common, particularly where there is a history of cervical surgery. This may on occasion present diagnostic difficulty [18] as, when inflamed, it can mimic adenocarcinoma in situ. Immunohistochemistry for p16, Bcl2, and Ki67 can be helpful in resolving this differential diagnosis, with tuboendometrioid metaplasia and endometriosis typically showing patchy p16 positivity, Bcl2 positivity, and a relatively low Ki67 labeling index [19] (Fig. 5.5). Adenocarcinoma in situ is usually diffusely and strongly p16 positive and Bcl2 negative and has a high Ki67 labeling index (see Chap. 8).