There has been an expansion of the autoinflammatory syndromes due to the discovery of new diseases related to mutations in genes regulating the innate immune system and the knowledge gained from these diseases as applied to more common nongenetic inflammatory conditions. Autoinflammatory syndromes are characterized by unprovoked (or triggered by minor events) recurrent episodes of systemic inflammation involving various body systems, which are often accompanied by fever. Inflammation is mediated by polymorphonuclear and macrophage cells through cytokines, particularly interleukin-1. This article reviews the clinical approach to patients with suspected autoinflammatory syndromes, several of the main and new (mostly genetics) syndromes, advances in treatment, and prognosis.
Autoinflammatory syndromes are defined as recurrent attacks of systemic inflammation that are often unprovoked (or triggered by a minor event) related to a lack of adequate regulation of the innate immune system. Unlike autoimmune diseases, there is a relative lack of autoantibodies or autoreactive T cells. In recent years there has been a substantial increase in the diseases classified (at least partially) as autoinflammatory because of better understanding of pathways of immune activation and regulation of the innate immune system ( Box 1 ). Much of this understanding was obtained from knowledge gained from rare autoinflammatory diseases with a genetic etiology ( Table 1 ). Periodic fever syndromes, the former term for this group of diseases, is not adequate because most syndromes are not truly periodic, and fever is not a necessary feature. This article includes those autoinflammatory syndromes (especially genetic) that do not fall into other diagnostic categories (eg, systemic juvenile idiopathic arthritis, vasculitis, and crystal disease).
Autosomal-recessive
Familial Mediterranean fever (FMF)
Mevalonate kinase deficiency: hyperimmunoglobulinemia D syndrome (HIDS)
Deficiency of the interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (DIRA)
Deficiency of the interleukin-36 receptor antagonist (DITRA): generalized familial pustular psoriasis
Majeed syndrome
Recurrent hydatidiform mole (NLRP7)
Autosomal-dominant
TNF-receptor–associated periodic syndrome (TRAPS)
Cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes (CAPS, NLRP3)
Familial cold-autoinflammatory syndrome (FCAS)
Muckle-Wells syndrome (MWS)
Neonatal-onset multisystem inflammatory disease (NOMID)
Pyogenic arthritis, pyoderma gangrenosum, acne syndrome (PAPA)
Familial cold-autoinflammatory syndrome 2 (FCAS2-NLRP12)
Cherubism (SH3BP2)
Granulomatous
Blau syndrome (autosomal-dominant)
Early onset sarcoidosis (autosomal-dominant)
Crohn disease (partially genetic)
Other, nongenetic
Periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis, adenitis syndrome (PFAPA)
Systemic juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Behçet syndrome
Recurrent pericarditis
Chronic recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis (CRMO)
Schnitzler syndrome
Gout
Other, nongenetic, at least partially autoinflammatory
Spondyloarthropathies
Type II diabetes
Age-related macular degeneration
Fibrosing disorders
Hemolytic uremic syndrome
Atherosclerosis
Post–myocardial infarction muscle damage
Abbreviation: NLRP, nucleotide oligomerization domain–like receptor family, pyrin domain.
Disease | Inheritance | Chromosome | Gene Defect | Protein Product | Common Mutations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
FMF | Recessive | 16p13 | MEFV | Pyrin | M694V, M694I, M680I, V726A, E148Q a |
HIDS | Recessive | 12q24 | MVK | Mevalonate Kinase | V377I, I268T |
DIRA | Recessive | 2q14 | IL1RN | IL-1 receptor antagonist | 175-kb deletion, 156_157delCA |
DITRA | Recessive | 2q13–14 | IL36RN | IL-36 receptor antagonist | L27P, S113I |
TRAPS | Dominant | 12p13 | TNFRSF1A | 55-kDa TNF receptor | T50M, C52Y, R92Q, a P46L a |
FCAS | Dominant | 1q44 | NLRP3 | Cryopyrin | V198M, a R260W |
MWS | Dominant | 1q44 | NLRP3 | Cryopyrin | V198M, a L264 V, E311K, T348M, A439V |
NOMID | Dominant/sporadic | 1q44 | NLRP3 | Cryopyrin | L264F,H; D303H; V351M,L |
PAPA | Dominant | 15q | PSTPIP1 | CD2 antigen-binding | A230T, E250Q,K |
NLRP12 | Dominant | 19q13 | NLRP12 | NLR family, pyrin domain, containing 12 | C850T |
a Polymorphism, partial penetrance or mild phenotype mutation.
These syndromes should be suspected in patients, mainly young children, with recurrent fever unexplained by infections and/or with episodic symptoms in various systems, especially the skin, gastrointestinal tract, chest, eyes, musculoskeletal, and central nervous system. These syndromes should also be suspected in patients with unexplained increased laboratory indices of inflammation even if the patient is asymptomatic. A family history of these syndromes is often but not always obtained, including a history of unexplained deafness, renal failure, or amyloidosis.
Most autoinflammatory syndromes have common clinical features including recurrent fevers, serositis, rashes, musculoskeletal manifestations, and increased laboratory markers of inflammation. However, a complete history and physical examination is crucial and often the correct diagnosis can be attained before more genetic or sophisticated tests are used. Syndromes can be differentiated by age of onset, ethnicity, attack triggers, duration of attacks, disease-free intervals between attacks, clinical manifestations, and the response to therapy ( Tables 2–4 ). It is very useful to examine patients during an attack, or alternately to ask parents to record attacks carefully and take photos of relevant physical findings. It is also useful to obtain laboratory markers of inflammation during and between attacks, because in some syndromes attacks are only the “tip of the inflammatory iceberg” and patients consistently have increased inflammatory indices. These patients are at higher risk of developing Amyloid A (AA) amyloidosis, the major adverse outcome of the autoinflammatory syndromes.
Age of onset | |
At birth | NOMID, DIRA, FCAS |
Infancy and first year of life | HIDS, FCAS, NLRP12 |
Toddler | PFAPA |
Late childhood | PAPA |
Most common of autoinflammatory syndromes to have onset in adulthood | TRAPS, DITRA |
Variable (mostly in childhood) | All others |
Ethnicity and geography | |
Armenians, Turks, Italian, Sephardic Jews | FMF |
Arabs | FMF, DITRA (Arab Tunisian) |
Dutch, French, German, Western Europe | HIDS, MWS, NLRP12 |
United States | FCAS |
Can occur in blacks (West Africa origin) | TRAPS |
Eastern Canada, Puerto Rico | DIRA |
Worldwide | All others |
Triggers | |
Vaccines | HIDS |
Cold exposure | FCAS, NLRP12 |
Stress, menses | FMF, TRAPS, MWS, PAPA, DITRA |
Minor trauma | PAPA, MWS, TRAPS, HIDS |
Exercise | FMF, TRAPS |
Pregnancy | DITRA |
Infections | All, especially DITRA |
Attack duration | |
<24 h | FCAS, FMF |
1–3 d | FMF, MWS, DITRA (fever) |
3–7 d | HIDS, PFAPA |
>7 d | TRAPS, PAPA |
Almost always “in attack” | NOMID, DIRA |
Interval between attacks | |
3–6 wk | PFAPA, HIDS |
>6 wk | TRAPS |
Mostly unpredictable | All others |
Truly periodic | PFAPA, cyclic neutropenia |
Useful laboratory tests | |
Acute-phase reactants must be normal between attacks | PFAPA |
Urine mevalonic acid in attack | HIDS |
IgD >100 mg/dL | HIDS |
Proteinuria (amyloidosis) | FMF, TRAPS, MWS, NOMID |
Response to therapy | |
Corticosteroid dramatic | PFAPA |
Corticosteroid partial | TRAPS, FCAS, MWS, NOMID, PAPA a |
Colchicine | FMF, PFAPA (30% effective) |
Cimetidine | PFAPA (30% effective) |
Etanercept | TRAPS, FMF arthritis |
Anti–IL-1 dramatic | DIRA (anakinra), FCAS, MWS, NOMID, PFAPA |
Anti–IL-1 mostly | TRAPS, FMF |
Anti–IL-1 partial | HIDS, PAPA |
Disease | Serositis | Skin | Musculoskeletal | Eyes | Mucous Membranes | Reticuloendothelial | Neurologic |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FMF | Peritonitis, pleuritis pericarditis, scrotum | Erysipelas-like, vasculitis | Acute monoarthritis, 5%–10% chronic arthritis, exercise-related myalgia, prolonged febrile myalgia | No | Rare aphthous | Splenomegaly, adenopathy | Headaches |
HIDS | Abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea | Maculo papular, mobiliform rash | Arthralgia, arthritis | No | Aphthous, vaginal sores | Cervical adenopathy | No |
DIRA | None | Pustulosis | Bonyytic lesions, osteitis | No | No | No | No |
DITRA | None | Pustular psoriasis, nail dystrophy | Arthralgia, arthritis | No | Tongue lesions (geographic) | No | No |
TRAPS | Peritonitis, pleuritis pericarditis | Painful, migratory erythema, vasculitis | Myalgia, fasciitis, arthralgia, arthritis | Periorbital edema, conjunctival injection | Aphthous | Splenomegaly, adenopathy | Focal neuropathy |
FCAS FCAS2/NLRP12 | No | Urticaria-like | Arthralgia | Conjunctivitis | No | No | Headaches |
MWS | No | Urticaria-like | Arthralgia | Conjunctivitis, episcleritis, uveitis | No | No | Hearing loss, headaches |
NOMID | No | Urticaria-like | Epiphyseal overgrowth with deformities, cartilage defect, arthritis | Conjunctivitis, uveitis, papillitis | No | Adenopathy | Chronic meningitis, mental retardation, headaches |
PAPA | No | Pyoderma gangrenosum, acne | Destructive ‘pyogenic’ large joint arthritis | No | No | No | No |
PFAPA | No | No | Arthralgia | No | Aphthous, pharyngitis | Cervical lymphadenopathy | No |
Disease | Colchicine | Corticosteroids | TNF Inhibitors | IL-1 Inhibitors | Other |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
FMF | a Multiple controlled studies | Effective only in prolonged febrile myalgia, vasculitis | Effective for arthropathy, case reports/series | Controlled study (two-thirds of patients), case series | |
HIDS | No | No | Case reports | About 40%, case series | Simvastatin shortens attacks |
DIRA | No | No | Unknown | a Anakinra, case series | |
DITRA | No | No | Case reports | Case reports | Oral retinoids cyclosporin |
TRAPS | No | Yes, but loses effect over time | Case reports, b etanercept only, not in all cases, often loss of effect over time | Case series | Anti–IL-6, case report |
FCAS | No | No | Unknown | a Two controlled studies | |
MWS | No | No | Unknown | a Two controlled studies | |
NOMID | No | No | Unknown, case reports | a Open study | |
FCAS2/NLRP12 | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | No (case reports) | |
PAPA | No | No | Case reports (partial) | Case reports | |
PFAPA | 30%–40%, case series | a Yes, may shorten intervals between attacks | Unknown | Case series | a Tonsillectomy, controlled studies; cimetidine (30%–40%), case series |
The innate immune system as it relates to the pathogenesis of autoinflammatory syndromes
The initial response to pathogens and damaged cells is mediated by the innate immune system ( Fig. 1 ). The cells of the innate immune system, primarily epithelial, dendritic, polymorphonuclear, and macrophage cells, act not only as an immediate barrier, but also as effectors in the evolution of the inflammatory response. The innate immune system recognizes pathogen-associated molecular patterns and damage-associated molecular patterns by several complex mechanisms, involving cell-associated pattern recognition receptors and soluble recognition molecules. These receptors, such as toll-like receptors, are present on the surface of the cell. Nucleotide oligomerization domain–like receptors (NLRs) within the cell and other receptors further mediate intracellular innate immune system processes and development of the inflammatory response. NLRPs (NLRs with pyrin-domain–containing proteins) are a subfamily of the NLRs. NLRP3 assembles other proteins to form the inflammasome complex in response to cytoplasmatic pathogen-associated molecular patterns and damage-associated molecular patterns, which also triggers the expression of proinflammatory genes by transcription factors (eg, nuclear factor-κB). The inflammasome complex involving NLRP3 recruits and activates caspase 1, a protease that cleaves prointerleukin (IL)-1β and IL-18 to their active forms. The common pathogenic pathway of the autoinflammatory syndromes involves the excessive production and activity of these proinflammatory cytokines and molecules, not as a result of external stimuli but as a result of mutations in different proteins that regulate these pathways.
Familial Mediterranean fever
Familial Mediterranean fever (FMF), described in 1945, is the most common inherited autoinflammatory syndrome. Inherited in an autosomal-recessive manner, it results in recurrent attacks of fever, serositis, arthritis, and rash. Late complications of untreated FMF include the development of primarily renal AA amyloidosis leading to the nephrotic syndrome and renal failure.
The highest prevalence of FMF is in Sephardic Jews, Armenians, Arabs, and Turks. Because of the availability of genetic diagnosis FMF is now recognized more frequently among Ashkenazi Jews, Greeks, and Italians and even among Japanese, although the disease is usually milder in these groups. It is estimated that there are between 100,000 and 120,000 FMF patients worldwide. The carrier rate is as high as 1:3 to 1:5 among Armenians and North African Jews.
Etiology
The FMF gene ( MEFV ) is located on the short arm of chromosome 16. The product of this gene is a 781–amino acid protein termed “pyrin” (marenostrin in Europe). There may be a phenotype–genotype correlation with more severe disease and amyloidosis occurring in patients with the M694V, M694I, and M680I mutations. In most series, at least 30% of patients diagnosed with definite FMF by clinical criteria lack one or even two mutations, especially patients from Western Europe or the United States; autosomal-dominant transmission has been demonstrated in some families. Mutations or polymorphisms in genes other than MEFV gene may impact on the development of FMF or the severity of the disease, including the development of amyloidosis.
Pathogenesis
The pyrin protein consists of three main domains: (1) the N-terminal 92–amino acid pyrin domain, (2) the B-box, and (3) the C-terminal B30.2 domain. Most disease-causing mutations occur in exon 10 of the MEFV gene encoding the B30.2 domain. Pyrin directly interacts and binds to caspase 1, inhibiting its ability to cleave pro–IL-1β to IL-1β. Mutations in the B30.2 region of pyrin, particularly those mutations considered more severe (positions 680 and 694) interfere in this binding process, thus contributing to increased levels of IL-1β and inflammation with and without exogenous stimulation.
Clinical Manifestations
Clinical signs of FMF develop by age 10 years in 80% of the patients and by age 20 years in 90%. Attacks typically last 12 to 72 hours and are characterized by fever, serositis, monoarthritis of the knee or ankle, often accompanied by an erysipelas-like rash over the involved joint ( Fig. 2 ). Severe abdominal pain (caused by peritonitis), often mimicking appendicitis, accompanies fever in nearly 90% of patients. Pleuritis occurs in 30% to 45% of patients, and patients occasionally develop pericarditis and scrotal swelling. Acute arthritis is seen in 50% to 75% of patients and is characterized by substantial effusions with polymorphonuclear predominance and usually lasts up to 1 week. Chronic arthritis develops in 5% to 10%, especially in the hip and sacroiliac joint. Headaches related to aseptic meningitis may occur.