Autism risk in small- and large-for-gestational-age infants




Objective


We sought to determine whether small-for-gestational age (SGA) and large-for-gestational age (LGA) birthweights increase autism risk.


Study Design


This was a retrospective cohort analysis comparing children with autism (n = 20,206) within a birth cohort (n = 5,979,605). Stratification by sex and birthweight percentile (SGA, <5th or 5-10th percentile; appropriate size for gestational age [GA], >10th to <90th percentile; LGA, either 90-95th or >95th percentile) preceded Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel analysis for GA effect, and multivariate analysis.


Results


Autism risk was increased in preterm SGA (<5th percentile) infants 23-31 weeks (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 1.60; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.09–2.35) and 32-33 weeks (aOR, 1.83; 95% CI, 1.16–2.87), and term LGA (>95th percentile) infants 39-41 weeks (aOR, 1.16; 95% CI, 1.08–1.26), but was decreased in preterm LGA infants 23-31 weeks (aOR, 0.45; 95% CI, 0.21–0.95).


Conclusion


SGA was associated with autism in preterm infants, while LGA demonstrated dichotomous risk by GA, with increased risk at term, and decreased risk in the premature infants. These findings likely reflect disparate pathophysiologies, and should influence prenatal counseling, pediatric autism screening, and further autism research.


Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder involving impaired communication skills, limited social interactions, restricted interests, and stereotypical behaviors. Autism is often associated with abnormalities in cognitive functioning, learning, attention, and sensory processing, and typically presents in early childhood. The autism spectrum disorders are considered to be a significant public health issue, affecting 0.9% of US children.


Despite increased public awareness and research efforts, the etiology of autism remains largely uncertain. Based on the myriad of genetic, environmental, perinatal, and immunologic associations to date, it is likely that either there is a multifactorial causal pathway (eg, an underlying genetic susceptibility triggered by an exogenous stressor) or that autism is the common end point of multiple causal pathways. Adverse perinatal conditions are common targets of inquiry, and several conditions, including prematurity and low birthweight (BW) have been associated with the later development of autism.


Prior analyses evaluated the role of abnormal BW percentiles, with conflicting results. A recent comprehensive metaanalysis of perinatal and neonatal risk factors for autism reported that small-for-gestational age (SGA) but not large-for-gestational age (LGA) BW were significantly associated with autism. Within a Swedish case-control study, LGA BW were associated with increased rates of autism (odds ratio [OR], 1.7; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.0–2.7). An analysis of autism risk by BW appropriateness stratified by gestational age (GA) at birth has not been published. It is conceivable that the combination of intrauterine and postnatal stressors associated with growth restriction and prematurity, or alternately fetal overgrowth met with placental senescence at term, may be more detrimental to neurodevelopment than anticipated. The goal of this analysis was to determine whether SGA or LGA infants are at increased risk for autism relative to appropriate-for-GA infants, and whether the association differs by GA at birth.


Materials and Methods


This was a population-based cohort study, approved by the California Protection of Human Subjects Committee; the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD); and the University of California, Davis Human Subjects Committee.


We utilized a database constructed by our group in 2007 to evaluate perinatal risk factors for developmental disabilities. An 11-year birth cohort (Jan. 1, 1991, through Dec. 31, 2001) was identified within a database provided by the California OSHPD, which had previously merged birth records from the Linked Vital Statistics Birth and Infant Death File published by the California Department of Health Services with maternal and infant hospital discharge records from the entire state. The analysis was limited to infants who survived to 1 year of age, without exclusion of children with comorbid congenital or neurodevelopmental abnormalities. This database provided perinatal data that was collected prospectively (at the time of hospital discharge, and filing of birth certificate data), such as maternal demographics and comorbidities, prenatal care, delivery type, and infant BW and GA at delivery. We then identified children with autism within the California Department of Disabilities database who were born in California from Jan. 1, 1991, through Dec. 31, 2001, and linked their information to the maternal and infant birth records within the OSHPD/Department of Health Services files using linkage analysis. The overall rate of successful linkage was 85%, with a range of 81% (in 1991) to 90% (in 2001).


In the current analysis, the predictive variable was defined as BW appropriateness for GA. All births in the cohort were separated by year of birth and sex, and were then assigned to a GA group based on completed weeks of gestation at the time of birth. Regarding determination of GA, the basis for dating criteria was not a variable included within the California OSHPD administrative birth files. For each year, we calculated the threshold values for male and female BW appropriateness by GA within the annual birth cohort (at the 5th, 10th, 90th, and 95th BW percentiles). Each birth according to sex and year was identified as SGA (either <5th or 5-10th percentile), appropriate for GA (>10th to <90th percentile), or LGA (either 90-95th or >95th percentile). Annualized BW percentile thresholds for each GA were tabulated and averaged for descriptive purposes ( Table 1 ). Trend tests demonstrated no significant time trend in percentile thresholds over the 1991 through 2001 time period.



TABLE 1

Birthweight percentiles by gestational age at birth

































































































































































































































































































Birthweight percentile
5th 10th 90th 95th
Sex Birthweight, g
Male
Gestational age
23 539 569 1147 1302
24 543 599 1138 1289
25 587 648 1236 1447
26 633 712 1431 1655
27 695 779 1622 1892
28 774 875 1886 2168
29 865 967 2262 2505
30 963 1105 2642 2828
31 1118 1278 2960 3107
32 1319 1502 3208 3346
33 1532 1735 3412 3557
34 1765 1964 3585 3747
35 1994 2188 3722 3931
36 2193 2380 3755 3977
37 2411 2602 3844 4055
38 2630 2797 3962 4157
39 2772 2934 4080 4267
40 2853 3021 4174 4360
41 2888 3060 4249 4438
42 2838 3016 4240 4433
43 2807 2984 4180 4376
Female
Gestational age
23 491 520 1130 1253
24 523 547 1110 1263
25 558 600 1181 1405
26 596 656 1325 1593
27 652 723 1600 1915
28 687 795 1908 2189
29 800 913 2322 2534
30 933 1063 2679 2849
31 1065 1221 2987 3124
32 1219 1411 3186 3339
33 1451 1643 3373 3526
34 1677 1873 3521 3697
35 1891 2089 3627 3837
36 2091 2287 3655 3871
37 2320 2500 3725 3928
38 2530 2700 3827 4017
39 2681 2829 3925 4111
40 2762 2913 4015 4194
41 2790 2951 4084 4267
42 2758 2918 4081 4269
43 2724 2883 4041 4233

For each year within the 1991-2001 birth cohort, annual birthweight percentiles were calculated and used to determine birthweight appropriateness for children born within that year. The analysis included children who survived to 1 year of age. Gestational age refers to completed gestational age at birth (23w1d = 23 weeks).

Moore. Autism risk by birthweight percentile. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2012.


The outcome of the current analysis was a diagnosis of autism. Within California, 75-80% of children with autism are followed up by the California Department of Developmental Services (DDS), which provides services for people with autism, epilepsy, cerebral palsy, and mental retardation, without regard for income. The Client Development Evaluation Report (CDER) database held by DDS was utilized to identify cases of autism by: (1) an autistic level of “one” (full syndrome autism) on any CDER report; or (2) an International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision ( ICD -9) code of 299.0 (autistic disorder), 299.8, or 299.9. As specific autism ICD -9 codes were not routinely included in the CDER during the time period queried, we do not have precise information regarding the number of cases of each autism spectrum disorder included without our cohort. We suspect that the majority of cases were autistic disorder, which is the only autism spectrum disorder eligible for services through DDS, in the absence of significant disability. While autism is typically diagnosed by age 3 years, the analysis included cases identified by DDS through Nov. 30, 2006, at which time the youngest member of our cohort was 4 years and 11 months old, leaving time for most of the children with a delayed diagnosis to be included in the analysis.


To estimate the strength of association between BW percentile and autism, OR was calculated with 95% CI. A multivariate logistic regression analysis was designed to account for perinatal risk factors previously associated with both BW percentiles extremes (SGA or LGA) and autism. We screened covariates for association with BW percentile (either SGA or LGA) using previously published studies, and confirmed an association with autism through the univariate analysis, using a 95% CI entirely >1.0 or <1.0 as a threshold for inclusion. We included chronic hypertension ( ICD-9, Clinical Modification [ ICD-9-CM ] 642.0-642.2, 642.7), preeclampsia ( ICD-9-CM 642.5), maternal diabetes ( ICD-9-CM 250, 648.0, 648.8), maternal age, twin gestation ( ICD-9-CM 651.0), birth order (derived from maternal parity), race, and interpregnancy interval (derived from a search for previous deliveries in mothers with a parity >0).


To determine whether GA at birth influenced the association between autism risk and BW appropriateness, the analysis was stratified by GA: very preterm 23-27 weeks 6 days and 28-31 weeks 6 days; midpreterm 32-33 weeks 6 days; late preterm 34-36 weeks 6 days; early term 37-38 weeks 6 days; term 39-41 weeks 6 days; and postdates >42 weeks. Effect modification was ascertained for GA strata using a Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test for difference of OR without a continuity correction.




Results


Within the cohort of 5,979,605 children born in California from 1991 through 2001, 21,717 children with autism were identified. The remainder of the birth cohort served as the control group (n = 5,957,888). Male sex, advanced maternal and paternal ages, Asian race, chronic hypertension, preeclampsia, any form of diabetes, high birth order (≥3), short interpregnancy interval, and twin gestations were significantly associated with autism ( Table 2 ).



TABLE 2

Demographic data of the 1991-2001 California birth cohort according to autism status









































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































No autism Autism Analysis
Variable Deliveries, n % Deliveries, n % OR 95% CI
Total 5,957,888 21,717
Sex of child
Male 3,040,131 51 18011 83 4.66 4.50–4.84
Female 2,917,757 49 3706 17 1.00 Reference
Age of mother
≤20 960,822 16 1753 8 0.77 0.68–0.86
21-25 1,499,201 25 4263 20 1.00 Reference
26-30 1,633,158 27 6081 28 1.28 1.21–1.36
30-35 1,242,483 21 5927 27 1.67 1.57–1.77
35-40 530,653 9 3107 14 2.02 1.89–2.16
≥41 90,664 2 583 3 2.15 1.91–2.43
Age of father
≤20 408,807 7 668 3 0.73 0.61–0.87
21-25 1,149,714 19 2838 13 1.00 Reference
26-30 1,480,484 25 4958 23 1.30 1.21–1.39
30-35 1,339,188 22 5741 26 1.63 1.52–1.74
35-40 757,722 13 3953 18 1.98 1.84–2.12
≥41 408,036 7 2449 11 2.29 2.12–2.48
Maternal race/ethnicity
Non-hispanic white 2,082,149 35 8789 40 1.00 Reference
African American 421,764 7 1764 8 1.02 0.95–1.10
Hispanic 2,759,541 46 7809 36 0.69 0.66–0.73
Asian 593,146 10 3049 14 1.33 1.25–1.41
Other race 75,398 1 206 1 0.69 0.57–0.84
Chronic hypertension
No 5,919,730 99 21516 99 1.00 Reference
Yes 38,158 1 201 1 1.45 1.26–1.67
Preeclampsia
No 5,700,487 96 20468 94 1.00 Reference
Yes 257,401 4 1249 6 1.42 1.29–1.57
Diabetes (any)
No 5,747,210 96 20624 95 1.00 Reference
Yes 210,678 4 1093 5 1.42 1.34–1.52
Parity
Unknown 8,336 <1 23 28 0.14 0.01–1.50
Nulliparous 2,314,526 39 9194 42 1.00 Reference
1 1,851,911 31 7810 36 0.29 0.04–2.04
2 1,003,761 17 2937 14 0.20 0.03–1.41
3 440,443 7 1087 5 0.15 0.02–1.08
4 181,708 3 370 2 0.13 0.02–0.93
≥5 157,203 3 296 1 0.13 0.02–0.91
Birth order
Unknown 772,322 13 3185 41 1.16 1.11–1.20
1 5,162,747 87 18,414 36 1.00 Reference
2 22,466 <1 114 5 1.4 1.18–1.71
≥3 353 <1 4 11 3.18 1.19–8.52
Multiple gestation
No 5,882,776 99 21234 98 1.00 Reference
Yes 75,112 1 483 2 1.81 1.65–1.98
Months since last live birth
Unknown 2,721,666 46 10992 51 1.5 1.39–1.61
0-1.5 y 367,914 6 1673 8 1.70 1.60–1.81
1.5-2.5 y 796,301 13 3310 15 1.53 1.45–1.62
2.5-4 y 850,760 14 2328 11 1.00 Reference
4-6 y 604,500 10 1383 6 0.82 0.76–0.88
≥6 y 616,747 10 2031 9 1.19 1.12–1.26
Birthweight percentile
Unknown 436,800 7 1516 7 0.97 0.92–1.02
<5% 260,587 4 1090 5 1.17 1.10–1.24
5-10% 280,316 5 1070 5 1.07 1.00–1.13
>10 to <90% 4,414,624 74 15828 73 1.00 Reference
90-95% 290,242 5 1083 5 1.04 0.98–1.11
>95% 275,319 5 1130 5 1.15 1.08–1.22

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

May 23, 2017 | Posted by in GYNECOLOGY | Comments Off on Autism risk in small- and large-for-gestational-age infants

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access