Trauma-Related Problems and Disorders

Chapter 19
Trauma-Related Problems and Disorders


Brian Fisak


BRIEF OVERVIEW OF DISORDER/PROBLEM


Potentially traumatic events (PTEs) include a range of experiences, such as physical or sexual abuse, exposure to domestic or school violence, traumatic death of a loved one, injuries and accidents, exposure to community violence, and severe illnesses (American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry [AACAP], 2010). Unfortunately, exposure to PTEs in childhood and adolescence is common. In particular, based on conservative estimates, approximately 25% of children and adolescents experience a PTE (Costello, Erkanli, Fairbank, & Angold, 2002), with some epidemiological studies reporting rates exceeding 60% (Turner, Finkelhor, & Ormrod, 2010). Further, specific groups may be at elevated risk. Briggs-Gowan, Ford, Fraleigh, McCarthy, and Carter (2010) found that poverty, single parenting, and parent depression symptoms were associated with increased likelihood of exposure to PTEs. Exposure to PTEs also appears to be common in clinical outpatient settings, with estimates ranging from 60% to 90% of children and adolescents (Ford et al., 1999).


Although many children and adolescents who are exposed to PTEs recover naturally and without the need for intervention, long-term disruption in multiple areas of functioning is not uncommon. In particular, children and adolescents are at risk for developing posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), along with a number of other behavioral and emotional problems, including depression symptoms, emotional dysregulation, and oppositional behaviors and aggression (Cohen, Mannarino, & Deblinger, 2006). Further, sexualized behaviors and shame are common in youth who have been sexually abused. Rate of PTSD among children and adolescents exposed to a PTE varies considerably and is influenced by a number of factors, including the nature of the trauma, pretrauma psychopathology, and duration of time following the occurrence of the traumatic event (Cox, Kenardy, & Hendrikz, 2008; Smith, Perrin, Yule, & Clark, 2010).


Overall, it is likely that practitioners will encounter children and adolescent clients who have been exposed to trauma and who experience trauma-related disruptions in functioning. This chapter provides an overview of evidence-based approaches and standards of practice for clinicians working with traumatized children and adolescents.


EVIDENCE-BASED APPROACHES


A number of comprehensive reviews have been conducted to identify the best evidence-based interventions for children and adolescents who have experienced trauma. One comprehensive review was prepared by the National Crime Victims Research and Treatment Center and the Center for Sexual Assault and Traumatic Stress (Saunders, Berliner, & Hanson, 2004). This review identified and categorized the common psychosocial treatments for trauma in youth, and treatments were rated on several dimensions, including level of empirical support, acceptance/use in clinical practice, potential for harm, and theoretical basis. Each treatment was rated on a Likert scale ranging from 1 (well-supported efficacious treatment) to 6 (concerning treatment). Trauma-Focused Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT) was the only treatment to receive a top rating. An additional 12 treatments received a rating of 3, meaning that they were considered to be generally supported and acceptable.


Another reviewed conducted by the Kauffman Best Practices Project (Chadwick Center on Children and Families, 2004) identified three specific interventions as “best practices” for children and adolescents who experience trauma-related symptoms following abuse. Again, TF-CBT was listed as a best practice. In addition, Abuse Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (AF-CBT) and Parent–Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT) were also listed as best practices. Of these three treatments, TF-CBT was the only treatment specifically designed to address trauma symptoms in youth and their nonoffending parents.


A number of other factors strengthen the argument for TF-CBT as a standard of practice for traumatized children and adolescents. In particular, the efficacy of TF-CBT has been supported by several controlled clinical trials (see Cary & McMillen, 2012). Further, TF-CBT was found to be effective in a multisite, randomized clinical trial, with significant reductions in PTSD symptoms, depression symptoms, behavior problems, shame, and negative abuse-related attributions in children and adolescents who had been sexually abused (Cohen, Deblinger, Mannarino, & Steer, 2004). Treatment gains were maintained at 12-month follow-up (Deblinger, Mannarino, Cohen, & Steer, 2006).


Another reason that TF-CBT has become a standard of practice is due to the widespread and successful dissemination of this model (Cohen & Mannarino, 2008). In particular, readily accessible resources have been provided for dissemination, including a published treatment manual (Cohen et al., 2006) and web-based training, referred to as TF-CBTWeb, which is accessible at www.musc.edu/tfcbt (Allen & Johnson, 2012; Cohen & Mannarino, 2008). Although other models show promise for the treatment of traumatized children and adolescents, TF-CBT appears to have reached the strongest evidence-based standards for the treatment of traumatized children and adolescents and their parents. Consequently, the remainder of this section focuses on TF-CBT.


Trauma-Focused Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy


Overview of TF-CBT


TF-CBT is a manualized treatment designed to help children and adolescents who are experiencing PTSD and other trauma-related symptoms, including depression, anxiety, externalizing behavior problems, sexualized behaviors, and trauma-related shame (e.g., Cohen et al., 2004, 2006; TF-CBTWeb, www.musc.edu/tfcbt). The program also has benefits for parents, including reduction in emotional distress related to the child’s trauma, improved ability to support the child, improved general parenting practices, and reductions in depression and PTSD symptoms. It is noteworthy that most of the research on TF-CBT focuses on children with a history of sexual abuse; however, the model can be applied to other forms of trauma, including children with a history of physical abuse and children who have witnessed violence.


TF-CBT Treatment Components


TF-CBT includes nine modules, which are based on common cognitive behavioral interventions for children who experience dysfunction in response to trauma (Cohen et al., 2006). The duration of treatment is typically 12 to 16 sessions but can be extended if necessary. Further, the treatment was designed to include individual sessions with the child and parent, along with conjoint parent–child sessions. The nine basic modules (skill sets) can be remembered with the acronym PRACTICE:



  1. Psychoeducation
  2. Parenting
  3. Relaxation
  4. Affective expression
  5. Cognitive coping
  6. Trauma narrative development and processing
  7. In vivo exposure
  8. Conjoint parent–child sessions
  9. Enhancing safety and future development

The modules are designed to be implemented in a flexible manner. A summary of each of the modules, based on the treatment manual published by Cohen at al. (2006) and the TF-CBTWeb program (www.musc.edu/tfcbt), is provided next.


Psychoeducation

Psychoeducation usually is implemented near the beginning of treatment but often continues throughout the course of treatment. Psychoeducation typically consists of normalization of the child and parent experiences in response to the trauma, including discussion of common responses to trauma. Information about the nature of the particular trauma often is provided, including the frequency and causes of trauma. Clinicians also address common myths and misconceptions about abuse. Psychoeducational handouts are available for distribution (see Cohen et al., 2006; TF-CBTWeb, www.musc.edu/tfcbt).


In relation to sexual abuse, psychoeducation typically includes three basic components:



  1. Information about the traumatic event. This typically includes defining sexual abuse, discussions about the reasons that perpetrators commit sexual abuse, typical responses to abuse, and the reasons that children do not immediately tell others about the abuse.
  2. Sex education. Children and adolescents are provided with factual information, and misinformation about sexual abuse is clarified. Further, body awareness and the child or adolescent’s feelings about sexuality are discussed, and health-related issues, such as sexually transmitted diseases, often are discussed.
  3. Risk reduction. Children and adolescents learn how to identify high-risk situations and how to develop a safety plan if they were to end up in a high-risk situation in the future. The difference between appropriate touch and inappropriate touch also is discussed, and a child’s right to say no is reinforced. Further, role-plays can be used to practice effective limit setting.

Parenting Skills

The clinician discusses the use of basic parenting skills, such as praise, selective attention, time-out, and contingency reinforcement. These skills may serve to improve the parent–child relationship and reduce disruptive behaviors. Further, a discussion of parenting skills may be particularly helpful for parents who experience less effective parenting in response to the trauma or who exhibited ineffective parenting skills before the occurrence of the trauma. Although a discussion of basic parenting skills may be particularly beneficial for the parents of children and adolescents who exhibit externalizing symptoms, these skills also are likely to be beneficial for parents of children who are not exhibiting behavioral difficulties. More specifically, these skills may enhance the effectiveness of other components of TF-CBT. For example, parent praise is an important skill for parents to use when children and adolescents begin to engage in exposure later in treatment (see the sections titled “Trauma Narrative Development and Processing” and “In Vivo Exposure”).


Relaxation/Stress Management

Relaxation strategies can be particularly beneficial to manage physiological arousal due to trauma-related memories and triggers. In this module, children and adolescents typically learn a variety of skills. One skill that is introduced is controlled breathing (diaphragmatic breathing), and for older children and adolescents, meditation also can be taught. Muscle relaxation (progressive muscle relaxation) typically is included as well. In addition, thought stopping often is introduced as a strategy to manage intrusive thoughts that occur at inopportune times.


In general, all these skills should be introduced and practiced in session. Clinicians also should make an effort to adjust technique descriptions to the developmental level of the child or adolescent. Further, parents typically are taught the relaxation strategies in session, often by the child or adolescent. As a result, parents develop strategies to manage their own stress and can assist the child and adolescent with between-session practice. Especially detailed descriptions of these relaxation strategies, including scripts, are provided in the TF-CBTWeb training program (www.musc.edu/tfcbt).


Affective Expression and Modulation Training

The purpose of this module is to help children and adolescents develop the ability to identify and label emotions so that they can appropriately express and manage emotions. First, the clinician works with the child or adolescent to identify and rate the intensity of emotions. Next, strategies to address appropriate management of emotions are discussed. For example, children or adolescents are taught effective communication skills, including the use of I statements, active listening, and the benefit of sharing feelings in the appropriate context. Further, children and adolescents are encouraged to use the previously discussed relaxation skills as a strategy when negative emotions are experienced. Finally, role-plays often are conducted in session.


Cognitive Coping

In this module, children and adolescents discuss how to identify and challenge inaccurate and unhelpful thoughts. In particular, clinicians often begin with the connection among thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, which usually is presented in the form of a cognitive triangle. The clinician typically discusses how some thoughts can be inaccurate and/or unhelpful and how these thoughts may lead to negative emotions and behaviors, including avoidance. Further, the clinician and the child or adolescent work together to identify and challenge unhelpful thoughts and to generate helpful/accurate thoughts. Finally, generalization of this skill is discussed. It is noteworthy that skills from this module can be helpful in the cognitive processing of the trauma narrative (see next module).


Trauma Narrative Development and Processing

The goal of trauma narrative development and processing is to break the connection between thoughts and memories of the traumatic event and both negative emotions and physiological arousal. Through gradual exposure and repetition, habituation occurs, and the end result is that trauma-related thoughts no longer lead to excessive distress.


The trauma narrative is developed in a gradual, progressive manner. In particular, the child or adolescent is asked to provide an account of the trauma over time, with increased detail. One option is for the child or adolescent to develop the narrative in sections, starting with sections of the narrative that create the lowest level of distress and eventually progressing to the most distressful components of the narrative. During the development of the narrative, the clinician also asks the child or adolescent to describe feelings and cognitions about the trauma, which can assist in the integration and processing of the traumatic event. Older children and adolescents typically are asked to provide a written narrative; however, therapists often dictate the narrative for younger children. The narrative also can be made into a book, and younger children can include drawings.


Cognitive and emotional processing typically occurs following the completion of the narrative. The purpose of this processing is to elicit and modify distorted thoughts about the trauma, and this process allows thoughts and feelings to be consolidated into an understandable experience. Through this experience, the child or adolescent can recognize that the trauma is part of his or her self-concept rather than central to his or her self-concept.


As part of the trauma narrative process, the child or adolescent typically is asked to read the narrative out loud to the therapist, and, typically, the narrative eventually is shared with the parent. The parent is often exposed to the narrative in a stepwise manner. First the therapist may read the narrative to the parent, and eventually the child is asked to read the narrative in the presence of the parent. This task provides the parent an opportunity to model positive coping behavior and also serves to improve support and communication between the parent and child in relation to the trauma.


In Vivo Exposure

The trauma narrative likely will decrease reactivity to thoughts and images that remind the child or adolescent of traumatic event; however, children and adolescents still may experience continued fear and avoidance of external cues that serve as reminders of the traumatic event. For example, a child may continue to experience a fear of the dark, even when safe in his or her own bedroom. As a result, in vivo exposure can be used to overcome the fear and avoidance of these external cues. As with the narrative, in vivo exposure should be gradual. It is noteworthy that in vivo exposure is not recommended for situations that may signify an actual threat to the child or adolescent’s safety.


Conjoint Parent–Child Sessions

Parent involvement is considered an important component of TF-CBT, and sessions with both the parent and child typically occur throughout treatment. Conjoint sessions may be particularly important when discussing components of the psychoeducational module. Further, as discussed earlier, conjoint sessions are an important component of review of the trauma narrative. In particular, once the child and parent are adequately prepared, the child typically is asked to read the narrative to the parent and therapist. The parent and child are then provided an opportunity to ask each other questions about the trauma. In addition to desensitization, these conjoint sessions provide parents and children an opportunity to learn how to communicate about the trauma in a more open manner.


Enhancing Safety and Future Development

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Sep 11, 2016 | Posted by in PEDIATRICS | Comments Off on Trauma-Related Problems and Disorders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access