New Mothers with Disturbing Thoughts: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and of Psychosis in Postpartum


Formal definition of OCD [1]

Additional features specific to postpartum OCD

Obsessive thoughts and/or compulsive acts present most days for at least 2 successive weeks that are a source of distress or interfere with activities

Obsessive thoughts: repetitive ideas, images, or impulses. Often violent, obscene, or perceived to be senseless, the person cannot dismiss them

The patient recognizes them as her own thoughts or impulses. Compulsive acts: stereotyped behaviors that are repeated to reduce anxiety caused by obsessions. For instance, a sufferer who has obsessive thoughts of her baby dying of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) may engage in compulsively checking of baby’s breathing numerous times at night

Rapid onset [2]. Mean time of onset is 2 to 4 weeks after delivery but may be as early as the second postpartum day [35]

Non-postpartum OCD typically has a gradual onset

The presence of aggressive obsessions is more common in postpartum than in non-postpartum women [5]

Aggressive obsessions in the postpartum period are frequently linked to the theme of harming the newborn, i.e., dropping, suffocating, molesting, or becoming sexually aroused when caring for the baby [58]

Obsessions in non-postpartum OCD are highly heterogeneous in content


Data from Refs. [18]





4.4.1.2 How to Distinguish Normative Intrusive Thoughts in Postpartum from Clinically Significant Symptoms That Warrant Further Assessment?


More than half of women report mild and transient intrusive thoughts upon giving birth [9]. The content of these thoughts may be similar to those seen in postpartum OCD, such as fears of harming the infant or the infant dying of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), yet they are never that intense nor do they trigger dysfunction or behavioral modifications [9]. Most new mothers check on the newborn to ensure his or her well-being. This is normal behavior. In women with postpartum OCD, excessive checking eventually impairs the mother’s ability to take care of the newborn due to distressing symptoms. When symptoms negatively interfere with the person’s regular activities and functioning in the social, occupational, and family spheres, further assessment is necessary.


4.4.1.3 What Is the Incidence and Prevalence of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder?


In Table 4.2, incidence and prevalence of postpartum OCD is summarized [716].


Table 4.2
Incidence and prevalence of postpartum OCD















Incidence of new-onset OCD after childbirth

1.7–4.0 % [7, 8, 10, 11]

Prevalence of postpartum OCD

1–9 % [7, 8, 10, 1214] (prevalence not as well studied)

Prevalence of subclinical, transient obsessive thoughts in the postpartum

Majority of women [9, 15, 16]


Data from the United States and selected countries in Europe

Data from Refs. [716]

OCD obsessive-compulsive disorder


4.4.1.4 What Are the Most Common Themes of Postpartum Obsessions and Compulsions?


Women may experience one or several themes of obsessive thoughts at the same time. These are the most common types of obsessive symptoms:



  • Thoughts, images, or urges of intentional harm to the infant such as:



    • Dropping the baby from a high place


    • Putting the baby in a microwave


    • Choking or shaking the baby


    • Pressing the baby’s soft spot on the head (fontanel)


    • Drowning the baby while giving bath


    • Stabbing the baby


    • Molesting the baby


    • Experiencing sexual arousal when caring for the baby


  • Other thoughts:



    • Baby suffocating or dying of SIDS


    • Accidents


    • Losing the baby, images of the baby being dead


    • Baby contracting an infectious disease or getting poisoned by harmful substances (such as mercury, lead) via touch and contact with improperly washed foods, bottles, or other objects

The most common types of compulsions in postpartum OCD:



  • Overt:



    • Cleaning/washing and related rituals to prevent contamination of the baby


    • Checking behaviors to prevent harm to the baby


    • Avoidance of the baby or of objects associated with aggressive images or thoughts, i.e., avoidance of kitchen knives when obsessive thoughts center on stabbing the baby


  • Covert:



    • Mental rituals, i.e., praying, attempts to suppress the thought, and counting


4.4.1.5 What Are the Differences Between Postpartum OCD and Postpartum Depression (PPD)?


Postpartum OCD is highly correlated with postpartum depression [15, 16]. To avoid mistaking obsessive content for depressive symptoms, distinction between the two needs to be made (Table 4.3).


Table 4.3
Differences between obsessive and depressive thoughts













Obsessive

Depressive

Repetitive, specific, and fixed themes

Center on events that may be realistic but have low probability of occurring

Primarily induce fear and anxiety

Broad, nonspecific, and changing themes

Center on actual circumstances

Primarily induce sadness



4.4.2 Postpartum Psychosis



4.4.2.1 What Is the Definition of Postpartum Psychosis?


PP is the most severe type of postpartum mental illness that requires immediate treatment. Onset of PP most often takes place within the first week after delivery. Hospitalization is warranted. Some symptoms of PP are the same as in non-postpartum psychosis. These are:



  • False beliefs not based in reality (delusions) such as fear of being followed or watched, thoughts broadcasting, thoughts insertion, and conviction that thoughts and/or actions are controlled by outside forces


  • Hearing, seeing, or feeling unreal things (hallucinations)


  • Disorganized thinking patterns

Additional symptoms specific to PP include severe insomnia, agitation, bizarre, disorganized behavior, thoughts of harming the baby, incoherent and illogical speech, and rapid mood changes.


4.4.2.2 How to Distinguish Normal Cognitive Disturbances or Dysfunctions (Confusion, Memory Problems, Loss of Insight) in Postpartum from Clinically Significant Symptoms That Warrant Further Assessment?


Cognitive disturbances in the postpartum period could, in rare occasions, occur as a consequence of inflammatory, autoimmune, or metabolic causes. It is imperative to rule out any potential medical causes that could trigger cognitive distortions. The first steps are to obtain a comprehensive laboratory panel and, rarely, complete brain imaging. Several symptoms distinguish PP from other potential causes of cognitive distortion in postpartum; these are insomnia coupled with agitation, fluctuating mood symptoms, and rapid changes in the clinical presentation as well as insight into the illness. Other illnesses that may induce cognitive disturbances have a steady progression and lack mood fluctuations.


4.4.2.3 What Is the Incidence and Prevalence of Postpartum Psychosis?


See Table 4.4 for incidence and prevalence of PP [1722].


Table 4.4
Incidence and prevalence of postpartum psychosis (Data from the United States and selected countries in Europe)












Incidence and prevalence of postpartum psychosis

Incidence/prevalence

1–2 per 1000 childbirths [17, 18]

 Rate is up to 100 times higher for women with personal history of bipolar disorder [19, 20]

 Rate is seven times higher for women with personal history of postpartum psychosis [21, 22]


Data from Refs. [1722]

Note: Published literature on PP refers to 1–2 per 1000 childbirths interchangeably as incidence or prevalence. No additional data exist


4.4.2.4 What Are the Most Common Themes of Delusions in Postpartum Psychosis?


Delusional themes in PP are heterogeneous in nature. The following types of delusions have been identified:



  • Of altruistic homicide in which the woman is convinced that she needs to kill her baby to save it from a fate worse than death [23]


  • Of religious nature in which the woman believes she or her baby has a special relationship with God or the devil [24]


  • Of grandeur (often related to religion) in which the woman believes she has special powers or authority [25]


  • Of paranoia and/or persecution in which the woman believes that the baby is not hers or that someone wants to hurt her or the baby (among other things) [25]


  • Of influence/control in which the woman feels she is being controlled by an outside force [25]


4.4.2.5 What Are the Differences Between Postpartum Psychosis and Postpartum Depression?


In Table 4.5, the key differences between PPD and PP are summarized.


Table 4.5
Key differences between postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis




























Features

Postpartum depression

Postpartum psychosis

Onset

Gradual

Abrupt

Mood

Persistent sadness and/or loss of interest

Rapidly fluctuating depressive and manic symptoms

Reality testing

Intact

Disturbed

Psychotic symptoms

Occasionally present, mood congruent, and develop gradually

Always present, mood incongruent, and develop abruptly


4.4.2.6 What Are the Symptoms Distinguishing Non-postpartum Psychosis from Postpartum Psychosis?


In Table 4.6, the key differences between non-PP and PP are described [18, 20, 2530].


Table 4.6
Differences between symptoms of postpartum and non-postpartum psychosis




























Non-postpartum

Postpartum

Can occur in a variety of psychiatric diagnoses, such as schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, and mood disorders, and in many medical conditions

Most commonly seen as a manifestation of bipolar disorder precipitated by childbirth [18, 26, 27]

Hallucinations most often affect one sensory system at a time

Hallucinations affect all senses (tactile, visual, olfactory, and auditory) [25]

Affective symptoms of one type (depression and/or mania) may or may not be present

Interchangeable and fluctuating mood symptoms, both elation and depression [27]

Lack of obvious confusion

Disturbance of consciousness marked by confusion, bewilderment, or perplexity [20, 28]

Symptoms develop gradually

Symptoms develop abruptly after delivery (2 to 7 days) [27]

In the acute phase, symptoms progress in a mostly steady manner

Rapid changes in intensity and symptom presentation [29, 30]


Data from Refs. [18, 20, 2530]


4.4.2.7 What Is the Postpartum Psychosis Classification in Leading Mental Health Diagnostic Manuals?


As is depicted in Table 4.3, in practice there is a distinct clinical presentation and treatment of postpartum psychosis. However, neither the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision (ICD-10) [1], nor the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Edition (DSM-5) [31], recognizes it as a separate diagnosis. This has been subject to ongoing debate. Women with PP are formally diagnosed with mental behavioral disorders associated with the puerperium, not elsewhere classified per ICD-10, and with unspecified bipolar and related disorders with peripartum onset per DSM-5.


4.4.2.8 What Is the Differential Diagnosis of Postpartum Psychosis?


The differential diagnoses of PP are:



  • Acute confusion due to medical conditions


  • Alcohol withdrawal


  • Psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia, schizoaffective, and schizophreniform disorder


  • Major depressive disorder with psychotic features


4.4.2.9 What Are the Differences Between Postpartum Psychosis and Postpartum Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder?


It is imperative to distinguish obsessive thoughts from psychotic process due to different treatment approaches for each diagnostic entity [35, 16, 27, 32] (Table 4.7). Notably, in severe, persistent postpartum OCD, obsessions may take on a delusional quality.


Table 4.7
Key differences between postpartum psychosis and obsessive-compulsive disorder




























Features

Obsessive-compulsive disorder

Postpartum psychosis

Onset

2 to 4 weeks after childbirth [35]

Within 1 week after childbirth [27]

Risk of harm to the infant

Low to none [15, 16]

High [32]

Disturbance in sensory perception

None

Hallucinations affect all senses

Insight into symptoms

Present

Absent


Data from Refs. [35, 15, 16, 27, 32]


4.4.2.10 What Are the Potential Consequences of Untreated Postpartum Psychosis?


Potential consequences of untreated PP are:



  • Suicide (in up to 5 % of women with PP) [33]


  • Infanticide (in up to 4 % of women with PP) [32, 33]


  • Impaired mother-child bonding


  • Recurrent psychiatric illness


  • Infant abuse and neglect



4.5 Etiology and Pathogenesis



4.5.1 Postpartum Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder



4.5.1.1 What Are the Main Theories That Explain the Emergence of Obsessive-Compulsive Symptoms in Postpartum?


Many theories seek to explain the etiology and pathogenesis of postpartum OCD (Table 4.8) [5, 6, 15, 3437]. Consensus exists that the causes are multifactorial and include cognitive, psychosocial, and biological factors. Dysfunctional cognitive beliefs (conviction that normal, albeit unwelcome, thoughts about the infant are dangerous and significant and need to be suppressed or otherwise gotten rid of) give rise to OCD symptoms and impairment. Psychosocial stresses of new motherhood (such as sleep deprivation, changes in role, identity, priorities and routines, responsibility of caring for the infant, etc.) may create pressures that render the woman less able to cope with disturbing thoughts. Additionally, some women appear to be particularly vulnerable to change in levels of serotonin effected by abrupt post-childbirth drop in estrogen and progesterone.


Table 4.8
Main etiological theories of postpartum obsessive-compulsive disorder


















Cognitive behavioral theory

Symptoms triggered by (1) stressors associated with motherhood, (2) misinterpretation of normal thoughts and worries, and (3) ensuing emergence of maladaptive coping responses [34, 35]

Risk increased by cognitive tendencies, such as overestimation of threat/inflated responsibility; importance of, and need to control, intrusive thoughts; perfectionism and intolerance of uncertainty [35]

Biological theory

Role of neurotransmitters or hormones [36]

Abrupt drop in estrogen and progesterone levels following childbirth adversely affects serotonin functioning [6, 15, 37]

Higher concentration of oxytocin in the postpartum has been linked to OCD severity [37]

Possible genetic component that is not fully understood [5]

Evolutionary theory

Intrusive thoughts about the infant evolved to ensure sensitivity to infant safety. This adaptive pattern may trigger obsessive-compulsive symptoms in vulnerable women [15]

The theory lacks evidence but would explain why healthy postpartum women report subclinical obsessive thoughts

Sociobiological theory

Susceptibility to anxiety and stress [15]


Data from Refs. [5, 6, 15, 3437]


4.5.1.2 What Are the Risk Factors for Postpartum Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder?


Risk factors for postpartum OCD are:

Oct 17, 2017 | Posted by in GYNECOLOGY | Comments Off on New Mothers with Disturbing Thoughts: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and of Psychosis in Postpartum

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access