Comorbid Psychiatric Disorders in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: The Spectrum Concept



Fig. 2.1
OCD and related disorders



The following paragraph describes the OCD spectrum disorders according to DSM-5.



2.3.2 Trichotillomania


Trichotillomania (repeatedly pulling one’s hair) is a condition formerly found in the “impulse control disorder not elsewhere classified” section. The diagnostics in DSM-5 involve visible hair loss, a feeling of tension immediately prior to pulling, and a sense of relief or pleasure when pulling out hair. According to DSM-5, individuals have to repeatedly attempt to stop hair pulling. This requirement was not part of the diagnostic criteria in DSM-IV and brings the hair-pulling disorder more in line with the repetitive and ritualized behavior and urges in OCD (Ameringen et al. 2014).

Recent results confirm evidence for the genetic transmission of hair pulling and suggest a familial subtype of hair pulling with comorbid OCD. However, there was no evidence for an etiologic relationship between hair pulling and skin picking (Keuthen et al. 2014).

Rogers et al. (2014) propose a stepped care model with a Web-based self-help program as step 1 followed by the opportunity to engage in an in-person habit reversal training for 8 weeks (step 2). The model was tested in 60 patients and proved to be highly accepted. On top of that, participants showed significant reduction of symptoms and increased quality of life.


2.3.3 Excoriation Disorder (Skin Picking)


As for trichotillomania, excoriation disorder was previously classified under impulse control disorders. Even with a lifetime prevalence estimate of between 2 and 4 % (Grohol 2013), excoriation disorder is new to DSM-5. Patients with this disorder have to suffer from a recurrent urge to pick at one’s own skin resulting in skin lesions. The disorder is further characterized by repeated attempts to decrease or stop the skin picking. Excoriation disorder can be very time consuming as individuals sometimes spend up to 8 h per day picking their skin.

Unlike OCD, skin picking is not preceded by obsessions but a high level of tension and an urge to scratch, pick, or squeeze otherwise healthy skin. Several studies suggest that symptom severity tends to fluctuate with stress levels but typically has a chronic course associated with substantial emotional distress and functional impairments (e.g., Odlaug et al. 2010).

Recent data support the conceptualization of excoriation disorders as a valid diagnostic entity (Snorrason et al. 2013). First, skin picking is characterized by a distinct constellation of symptoms, phenomenology, and course. Second, recent data suggest an underlying dysfunction and familiarity that cannot be completely explained by comorbid disorders. Third, skin picking is associated with certain characteristic environmental and temperamental factors such as stress and emotional reactivity.

SSRIs seem to be less effective in the treatment of skin picking, in contrast to OCD, whereas the opioid agonist naltrexone, for example, has demonstrated efficacy in this disorder. Similarly, exposure treatment, the method of first choice in OCD, seems to be ineffective, whereas patients with skin picking, like patients with trichotillomania, benefit from habit reversal training (Grant et al. 2012). Here, patients are instructed to develop awareness of the picking behavior and, in a next step, to replace it with a harmless habit that makes it impossible.


2.3.4 Hoarding Disorder


Hoarding disorder is a chronic and very debilitating condition characterized by a difficulty in discarding and/or excessive acquiring of things, gathering of clutter, and subsequent distress and impairment due to the hoarding behavior. Often, functional impairment also extends to relatives who live with the patient, so involving family members in the treatment is crucially important.

There is mounting evidence that hoarding pathology is associated with worse treatment outcome compared to other OC symptoms (e.g., Knopp et al. 2013). A large body of research suggests that hoarding disorder is clinically and neurobiologically distinct from OCD and necessitates a somewhat different kind of treatment. In line with this, hoarders seem to have a different pattern of cerebral glucose metabolism than non-hoarding patients with OCD (Saxena et al. 2004).

Though OCD symptoms and hoarding symptoms occasionally co-occur, many patients with hoarding disorder do not suffer from OCD. Recent results, however, suggest that individuals with only hoarding disorder show similar deficits on measures of executive functions as patients with both OCD and severe hoarding. This points toward a similar underlying neuropsychological dysfunction. The authors interpret their results as an argument for the inclusion of hoarding disorder within the new Obsessive–Compulsive and Related Disorders chapter (Morein-Zamir et al. 2014).


2.3.5 Body Dysmorphic Disorder


DSM-5 moved body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) from the somatoform disorders to the obsessive–compulsive spectrum disorders. Recent research on BDD yields a prevalence rate of about 1.8 % (Buhlmann et al. 2010).

Patients with BDD are constantly haunted by feelings of ugliness or an imagined defect in their looks despite a normal appearance or only a slight and trivial abnormality in appearance. Physical features that commonly raise concerns about perceived imperfections or flaws involve the skin, nose, ears, mouth, genitals, or hair. Some subjects, for example, focus their concern on perceived excessive facial hair or a disfigured shape of the nose. The preoccupation must cause clinically significant distress or impaired social or occupational functioning, clearly differentiating the disorder from normal concerns about one’s appearance. Many subjects tend to constantly ask for reassurance from others, are engaged in ritualistic checking behaviors, and make time-consuming attempts to improve the perceived imperfection. Others show avoidance behavior, for example, social withdrawal and avoiding mirrors; alternating between excessive checking and avoidance is also not unusual.

Insight in BDD is generally poorer than in OCD. Phillips et al. (2006), for example, investigated the two variants of BDD, namely, delusional and non-delusional. Their study found that about one third (36 %) of BDD subjects were delusional. The proportion of delusional BDD was higher in adolescents than in adults. A recent comparison of insight in BDD and OCD revealed that in both disorders insight can range from excellent to absent. Most OCD patients, however, showed excellent or good insight on the Brown Assessment of Beliefs Scale (BABS), and only 2 % of OCD patients had delusional beliefs. In contrast, the majority of BDD patients scored within the range of poor or absent insight (Phillips et al. 2012), and 32 % showed delusional beliefs.

Buhlmann and Winter (2011) point to several similarities between OCD and BDD. These include checking rituals, similar age of onset and course of illness as well as tendencies to hide the disorder from others due to excessive shame or embarrassment, and a high comorbidity. Major depression and anxiety disorders, however, are also very often comorbid with BDD, and the disorder is frequently associated with suicidal ideation (31 %) and suicide attempts (22 %) (Buhlmann et al. 2010).

So far, serotonin reuptake inhibitors and cognitive behavioral treatment are considered the treatment of choice. A recently evaluated manualized modular cognitive behavioral therapy for BDD over 24 weeks was well received by patients and proved very effective in reducing BDD symptoms (Wilhelm et al. 2014).


2.3.6 Other OCRD Conditions


Substance-/medication-induced OCRD must occur immediately after or during substance intoxication or withdrawal or develop as a consequence of a specific medication. For example, obsessions or compulsive rituals can be caused by certain stimulating drugs containing amphetamines or by corticosteroid therapy (Bhangle et al. 2013).

As OCD can also be caused by certain medical conditions, a medical evaluation is always required to rule out that a medical factor is causing obsessions or compulsions. Pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infections (PANDAS), for example, can lead to a sudden onset of severe OCD symptoms in children. There is evidence that patients with this type of OCD may benefit from antibiotics in addition to CBT or medication with antidepressants (Murphy et al. 2012). Another example is certain neurodegenerative diseases of the basal ganglia such as Huntington’s or Wilson’s disease, which can be associated with OC symptoms. New onset of OCD has also been reported secondary to other neurological disorders such as brain tumors, stroke lesions, postencephalopathic disorders, or traumatic brain injury.

Finally, there are other specified and unspecified obsessivecompulsive and related disorders for individuals who fulfill some but not all the diagnostic criteria for one of the disorders described above. One example is body dysmorphic-like disorder with actual flaws, which command excessive preoccupation. Another example is obsessional jealousy, which is characterized by non-delusional preoccupation with a partner’s perceived infidelity and repetitive behaviors or mental acts concerning the perceived infidelity. Also Jikoshu-kyofu or olfactory reference syndrome – a strong fear of having bad body odor – falls into this category.



2.4 Common Comorbidities



2.4.1 Comorbidity in OCD


A recent study on 955 patients with obsessive–compulsive disorder revealed that only 7.7 % showed no lifetime prevalence of any comorbid DSM-IV Axis I disorder (Torres et al. 2013). In line with this, Murphy et al. (2013) report that comorbidities with psychiatric disorders are two- to eightfold higher in individuals with OCD than the rates of neuropsychiatric disorders in the general US population. The most common psychiatric comorbidities in OCD as determined by several studies are presented in Fig. 2.2 (for a review, see Zaudig 2011). It shows depression as the most frequent comorbid disorder followed by personality disorders and anxiety disorders. Table 2.1 provides a more detailed overview by listing results from studies on comorbidities with large samples of OCD patients (n > 300). In the following section, the most frequent psychiatric comorbidities of OCD are described.

A317840_1_En_2_Fig2_HTML.gif


Fig. 2.2
Comorbidities of obsessive–compulsive disorders (%). According to various studies, lower and upper numbers in studies



Table 2.1
Lifetime comorbidity rates of patients with obsessive–compulsive disorder in large studies (n > 300)


































































































































Comorbid disorder

LaSalle et al. (2004)a

N = 334a

Hasler et al. (2007)a

N = 418

Miguel et al. (2008)a

N = 630

Ruscio et al. (2010)b

N = 2073

Gomes de Alvarenga et al. (2012)a

N = 813

Torres et al. (2014)a

N = 1,001

Affective disorders
       
70.7

60.8

Major depression

66

69

69.7

40.7
 
56.4

Dysthymia

24

14.1

10.6

13.1
 
11.9

Bipolar disorder

13

7.0

10.0

23.4
 
8.2

Social phobia

23

42.6

36.8

43.5

35.2

34.6

Specific phobia

12

38.9

32.4

42.7

33

31.4

Panic disorder with or without agoraphobia

23

21.0

6.2

20.0

5.7

15.3

Agoraphobia without history of panic disorder

18

16.3

5.7

7.8

5

4.9

Generalized anxiety disorder

18

45.8

35.4

8.3

33.8

34.3

Bulimia nervosa

10

5.0

2.9
 
11.3
 

Anorexia nervosa

9

6.2

2.7
   

Somatization disorder
   
3.5
 
Somatoform disorder

2.8

2.3

Hypochondriasis
 
7.7
   
3.4

Alcohol abuse/dependence

23
 
7.5

38.6
 
7.9


aThe Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV/Clinical Version (SCID-I/CV) was used to diagnose the Axis I disorders

bThe Composite International Diagnostic Interview was used to diagnose the Axis I disorder


2.4.2 Affective Disorders


Depression is the most frequent comorbidity in OCD. A large body of research suggests that about two thirds of patients with OCD fulfill criteria for major depression during their lifetime and one third of OCD patients experience a depressive episode at the time of evaluation (Tükel et al. 2002; Timpano et al. 2012).

Depression mostly occurs after the onset of OCD (Bartz and Hollander 2006). This may indicate that patients with OCD develop depressive symptoms mainly due to the functional impairment or the loss of positive reinforcement and of self-esteem that OC symptoms cause. In many cases, this leads to a vicious circle that involves depressive mood, growing inactivity, lowered self-esteem, an increase in OC symptoms, and, consequently, worsening of depressive symptoms. There is evidence that OCD patients with comorbid depression benefit less from cognitive behavioral or pharmacological treatment (Overbeek et al. 2002). Moreover, depressive symptoms seem to occur more frequently in response to excessive obsessions than compulsions.

A recently published review on comorbid bipolar disorder and OCD (Amerio et al 2014) stated that 11–21 % of patients suffering from bipolar disorder experience obsessive–compulsive disorder in their lifetime, whereas the lifetime prevalence rate of bipolar disorder is about 6–10 % in patients with current OCD. Interestingly, in patients who fulfill both diagnoses, OC symptomatology takes a more episodic course. As might be expected, patients typically show improvement of symptoms during manic or hypomanic episodes and exacerbation of symptoms during depressive episode.

Whereas cognitive behavioral therapy has been established as highly efficacious in OCD, patients with comorbid depression seem to be slightly less responsive to behavioral-based treatment alone (Hohagen et al. 1998). Therefore, in the case of comorbid depression, CBT should be combined with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.


2.4.3 Anxiety Disorders


As mentioned above, OCD was formally classified as anxiety disorder in DSM-IV. While individuals with anxiety disorders often try to help themselves by avoiding feared situations or stimuli such as closed places or spiders in certain specific phobias, individuals with OCD predominantly engage in rigid rituals or repetitive behavior to achieve temporary relief from their distressing thoughts. In contrast to general anxiety disorder, obsessions mostly go beyond daily worries and focus on one or only a few underlying themes (e.g., “I could have killed someone unintentionally,” “there may be germs that make me sick”). As already mentioned, OCD is often accompanied by anxiety, but some patients experience other emotional qualities such as disgust, for example.

A large cross-sectional study with 1,001 OCD patients by Torres et al. (2014) revealed that about 20 % had a lifetime diagnosis of panic disorder and/or agoraphobia. Patients in this subgroup were also more likely to have other Axis I diagnoses, especially other anxiety disorders, hypochondriasis, or mood disorders.

Sometimes patients with severe OCD experience social anxiety resulting from low self-esteem and deficits in social skills due to their longtime social isolation. Moreover, OC symptoms frequently also serve to keep distance from others or to shun social demands (Külz et al. 2010). As noticed by Jakubovski et al. (2013), avoidance tendencies in patients with comorbid anxiety disorder can compromise adherence to exposure treatment. On the other hand, experiencing the mechanisms of stimulus confrontation and habituation can effect relief regarding both OC symptoms and comorbid anxiety disorder.


2.4.4 Substance Use Disorder and Alcohol Dependency


Some individuals with OCD suffer from secondary alcohol dependency or drug addiction. In the study of Mancebo et al. (2008), 27 % of OCD patients had a lifetime diagnosis of substance use disorder. The majority of individuals reported that OCD preceded substance use disorder by at least 1 year; the median was 8 years.

In the study by Gentil et al. (2009), 7.5 % of OCD patients showed alcohol-use disorder comorbidity. These patients were more likely to be men and had a higher rate of suicidal thoughts and suicide attempts. Other comorbidities such as generalized anxiety and somatization disorders were also more common in this group of OCD patients. It is remarkable, however, that the rates of alcohol-use disorder in OCD patients do not seem to differ strongly from community prevalence rates (Wakefield and Schmitz 2014).

Clinical experience generated the hypothesis that some individuals turn to overconsumption of alcohol or to drug use in order to cope with OCD symptoms. For some patients, the intake of alcoholic beverages can easily become a fixed element of the daily routine when social relationships and positive activities fall by the wayside because rituals and absorbing thoughts are highly time-consuming. Unfortunately, this makes it even more difficult to resist the obsessive impulses in the medium term. It seems essential to treat alcoholism or drug addiction first before exposure therapy can be administered effectively.


2.4.5 Personality Disorders


There is a constant interest in possible relations between OCD and obsessive–compulsive personality disorder (OCPD). In a recent study by Starcevic et al. (2013), almost half of the OCD patients (47.3 %) fulfilled the criteria of an obsessive–compulsive personality disorder (OCPD). However, individuals diagnosed with both OCD and OCPD did not differ from other OCD patients regarding demographic variables, mean age of onset of OC symptoms, clinician-rated severity of OCD, or levels of disability. Other authors, however, found an association between comorbid obsessive–compulsive personality disorder and early onset of OC symptoms (e.g., Maina et al. 2008).

In contrast to OCD, OCPD is characterized by an enduring pattern of preoccupation with perfectionism, doubt, excessive consciousness, orderliness, and interpersonal control in all or almost all aspects of daily life. Rigid adherence to rules and an excessive devotion to work, which impairs family activities and social relationships, are frequent. While patients with OCD feel tortured by their unwanted thoughts and impulses and consider them unreasonable, patients with OCPD usually believe that their rigid system of rules makes sense. Subjective suffering often results from interpersonal conflicts, for example, when family members do not comply with the patients’ high standards or feel neglected when work and achievement take up too much time.

Interestingly, OCPD seems to be as frequent in anxiety disorders (Pena-Garijo et al. 2013), which argues against a continuum between OCPD and OCD.

Apart from OCPD, cluster C personality disorders in general are common in OCD (Pena-Garijo et al. 2013). Nevertheless, it is important to bear in mind that patients with OCD can present various different personality traits. In some patients, for example, OC symptoms can have a compensatory function, for example, to deal with impulsivity, feeling fragmented, or lacking identity.

Concerning comorbidity with schizotypal personality disorder, there is some evidence for higher rates of OC symptoms on symmetry, ordering/arranging, and checking in patients with a high level of schizotypy (Brakoulias et al. 2014). Besides, comorbidity with major depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, substance abuse, and general psychopathology seems to be more common than in patients with a low level of schizotypy.

With regard to treatment response, cluster A personality disorders, especially schizotypal personality disorder, narcissistic personality disorder, and the presence of two or more comorbid personality disorders, were found to be associated with poorer treatment outcomes. For other clusters, the results are inconsistent (Thiel et al. 2013).

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Sep 23, 2016 | Posted by in OBSTETRICS | Comments Off on Comorbid Psychiatric Disorders in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: The Spectrum Concept

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access