A Woman Afraid to Deliver: How to Manage Childbirth Anxiety


Information patha
 
CBT patha

Module 1

Normal pregnancy: first trimester

CBT as treatment method. Psychoeducation concerning fear and anxiety in general and related to childbirth. How different physical conditions (e.g., sleep deprivation, hunger, etc.) can influence persons differently. Description of own expectations of the imminent labor and delivery

Module 2

Normal pregnancy: second trimester

Goal setting—what can be realistic to expect during labor and delivery. Participants set their own goals for the therapy. Exposure to other women’s stories about labor and delivery

Module 3

Normal pregnancy: third trimester

Instruction in and practice with tools to deal with the physical reactions to fear, e.g., breathing retraining, focusing techniques. Testing the tools in everyday situations

Module 4

Normal labor: preparations and start

Difference between thoughts and feelings and how they interact. Participants identify and challenge own fearful thoughts and then create alternative, more helpful thoughts about labor and delivery

Module 5

Normal labor: pain relief

Instructions for exposure in vivo (in the woman’s natural milieu)

Module 6

Normal labor: first and second stage

How to manage situations one cannot influence. What is control? How to control one’s own thoughts?

Module 7

Normal labor and delivery: acute situations

Advantages of different modes of delivery for one’s own situation. Summary of the program

Module 8

Normal labor and delivery: third stage

How to deal with setbacks. Participants work out an individual program for maintaining their progress. Description of own expectations of the imminent labor and delivery


Used with permission of Taylor and Francis from Nieminen et al. [27]

aEvery module has a section with information about pregnancy and delivery (the information path) and a section dealing more strictly with the management of the phobic anxiety (the CBT path)



At assessment Anne’s W-DEQ A sum score is 134.





1.6.3 When Does a Woman Have a Childbirth Phobia According to DSM-5?



1.6.3.1 Criteria for Phobic CA According to DSM-5 Criteria for Specific Phobia


If a woman fulfills DSM-5 criteria A-G (please see the DSM-5 manual), she has phobic CA according to the DSM-5 criteria for specific phobia [26]. However, if a woman does not fulfill all the diagnostic criteria required for the diagnosis of phobic CA, she can nonetheless suffer seriously from CA symptoms.


1.6.3.2 The DSM System


The DSM is a system to describe mental disorders in objective, explicit terms. It helps clinicians to operationalize and facilitate communication about patients’ mental problems, which makes it easier to decide about treatment possibilities. DSM neither offers an explanation of the origin of mental disorders nor an instruction for care management (see also Chap. 24).


1.6.4 Which Other Mental Problems Are Important to Differentiate from Severe/Phobic Childbirth Anxiety in a Differential Diagnosis for CA?



1.6.4.1 Differential Diagnosis of CA


Like all other anxiety problems, phobic and severe CA are highly comorbid with other anxiety disorders [26] and also with other mental problems [28]. In the context of a differential diagnosis for severe and phobic CA, some disorders need special attention because they easily can misguide the health-care workers who are the first to meet these patients. It is necessary and appropriate to evaluate other diagnoses, not only anxiety disorders but also mental problems in general, to find out which mental condition the woman is suffering from and which help (treatment) fits best for her actual situation. See Box 1.1 for a short overview of the most important problems [29, 30].


Box 1.1. Differential Diagnosis for Severe and Phobic Childbirth Anxiety

BloodInjectionInjury Phobia

Many with a specific phobia also have other types of phobias. In case a woman is severely suffering from a blood-injection-injury phobia, she should be treated for that first with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which is very effective [29]. Afterward the patient’s CA can be reviewed and treatment for CA added if needed.

Other Situational Phobias



  • Hospital Phobia

    A woman with augmented CA, planning to give birth at a hospital, could have a hospital phobia, whereas she is not afraid of giving birth. When this is assessed in time, therapy can be offered before she has to give birth.


  • Vaginismus and Dyspareunia

    The content of fear in these women most likely concerns fear of pain and penetrations in the genital area (see below). This type of treatment is special and different from that of women with CA. At intake in antenatal care, caregivers should routinely ask patients about special concerns regarding contact with obstetric care during the time to come.


  • Fear of the Pelvic Examination

    As the pregnancy and delivery include several pelvic examinations, these women may have great problems with obstetric care during pregnancy and the routine examinations during delivery. Since it is not the delivery in itself that is feared, these women need to be treated in another way than those suffering from CA.

Somatic Symptom Disorder and Illness Anxiety Disorder

A person with somatic symptom disorder has one or more somatic symptoms that cause disproportionate and persistent anxiety. Someone with illness anxiety disorder has excessive worries about her health and is easily alarmed by bodily signals about her health status. These disorders exist already before gestation, but can intensify in connection to the challenges of pregnancy and delivery.

Social Anxiety Disorder

Social anxiety disorder does not specifically concern pregnancy and delivery, but more the confrontation with unfamiliar people and the feeling of being inspected. The period of pregnancy and the delivery is an awkward situation for these women as it involves many confrontations with midwives and other members of the obstetric staff, which they may prefer to avoid as far as possible.

Panic Disorder

A woman with severe or phobic CA may be struck by a full or limited symptom panic attack when confronted with childbirth stimuli, such as objects, persons, places, words, thoughts, or images that have to do with delivery. Therefore severe/phobic CA and panic disorder can easily be mixed up and can also coexist. It is of great value to assess a panic disorder differentiated from severe/phobic CA since in the first case, a special treatment focused on panic disorder is required. If the woman has both panic disorder and severe/phobic CA, both problems need attention.

The delivery is usually accompanied by many physical and psychological symptoms. The extreme levels of physical stress may aggravate these symptoms during the course of delivery. Because physical panic symptoms can easily be mistaken by staff as normal, standard symptoms during the course of labor and delivery, panic attacks are hardly detected during childbirth, especially when the focus is on the woman’s belly and the child to be born. This means that after a delivery where a panic attack occurred, this anxiety disorder may pass undiagnosed, and the woman as well as the health-care staff may focus on a traumatic delivery experience without getting hold of the essence of it and thereby delaying proper diagnostics and treatment.

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder

Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a common disorder in the population. When a woman has PTSD and severe/phobic CA, her PTSD should be assessed and, if possible, treated before handling her phobia. Especially PTSD related to sexual abuse or a previous delivery needs urgent attention since after such events, trauma anxiety easily is provoked by pregnancy and delivery.

Depression

It is well known that depressive symptoms can be a consequence of suffering from serious anxiety problems over a long time. Therefore, it is important to also examine for anxiety problems when a woman shows up with depressive symptoms in connection to pregnancy and childbirth. On the other hand, depression is a risk factor for severe/phobic CA [30].

Other Problems that Can Cause Fear and Anxiety in Connection to Pregnancy and Delivery

Except for the differentiation between CA and the aforementioned disorders, the situation of pregnancy and the forthcoming delivery may include aspects that worry the woman to such an extent that she experiences fear that is not strictly related to the delivery to come. These are, e.g., incomplete mourning for a lost child, pathological shyness, and guilt for an earlier abortion or one considered during the actual pregnancy, relationship problems, and intimate partner violence or drug abuse by a partner.


Case History: Continued

Although Anne Jade has had a panic attack recently, she does not fulfill the diagnosis for panic disorder. She also has a great need for control and planning and “likes to do and have things in her way,” but not in clinical terms, i.e., not fulfilling DSM-5 criteria, for example for obsessive-compulsive disorder.



1.7 Clinical Features and Comments



1.7.1 Patients with Childbirth Anxiety



1.7.1.1 What Are the Clinical Features of Childbirth Anxiety During Pregnancy?


In almost all other phobic situations than childbirth phobia, the phobic person is able to avoid a great part of what she fears. However, the pregnant woman with severe CA is constantly “trapped” until the child is born [31]. In phobic situations, the idea of being trapped without the ability to flee is an indispensible trigger for intense anxiety. Moreover, the progressing pregnancy brings her closer to the feared, unavoidable situation. Women with childbirth phobia can experience their status as mental torture when they have to endure a seemingly endless time in constant horror for what will come [32]. On the other hand, this same phenomenon is favorable for the woman’s motivation to take part in treatment of her phobic CA, as she has minimal chances to postpone the final confrontation with the phobic situation.

During pregnancy, many women with severe CA can only imagine the approaching delivery as an upcoming disaster and have the same PTSD symptoms as those who already have experienced a trauma in reality [30]. In case of CA, one could speak of a “Pre-TSD” [33].

Unfortunately, we found that the delivery experience for most women will turn out as expected [3, 8, 34]. The pregnancy confronts the woman with massive bodily changes that influence her physical functioning. Simultaneously, such changes can be appraised as real symptoms of abnormal physical phenomena. Anxious persons have a tendency to be observant of their body functions, which makes the anxious pregnant woman more vulnerable to alarms from all physical changes. Thus, whereas most pregnant women see their physical changes as belonging to pregnancy, in women with severe CA, these changes instead easily add to their suspicion that their body functions are abnormal (a false alarm).

Pregnancy has been called “a healthy illness,” which in many countries is underpinned by societal service, such as regular obstetric controls to confirm that the woman and her fetus are all right. A woman with CA may interpret these controls as indications that pregnancy and delivery are combined with serious risks for complications. Extended consultations as means of alleviating anxiety rarely work [35], which is further exemplified in illness anxiety (Box 1.1).

In all other forms of phobias, the phobic person only needs to care for herself, while a pregnant woman, suffering from CA, is forced to think both of her own and the fetus’ well-being. This means that the potential origin of her anxiety is widened extensively.

In many societies the advent of a new child is socially highly appreciated, and an observed pregnancy is freely favored. Therefore, it is not easy for a woman with CA to get approval for her problems, and when expressed, she often feels minimized. She may also feel an enormous social pressure, as she has to fulfill one of the most appreciated societal tasks and on top of that “feel happy.”


1.7.1.2 What Are the Clinical Features of Childbirth Anxiety During Delivery?


During delivery the woman with severe CA is finally trapped in the situation she has feared for a long time, and all ways to flee are blocked. Then valuable matters are at stake. She has the task to contribute, maximizing the options of delivering a healthy child, even if this means physical and mental suffering for her personally. In the end, she is often locked up within some square meters, and while enduring pain, she has to yield to prerequisite performances while her efforts are closely observed. In extreme cases it is about life and death for both herself and her child.

Giving birth is for all women a strenuous effort, physically and psychologically. An important point is that during this process, most women experience moments with a more or less altered state of awareness. The woman has to endure extreme levels of physical stress and pain, which she probably otherwise never experiences in her life, that influence her awareness. Moreover, many women breathe quickly when they have contractions, thus hyperventilate, which also affects their state of consciousness.

Therefore, during labor and delivery there are several elements that stimulate a temporary change in awareness; some women can even welcome this as a way to cope with extreme pain.

Such states are normal in daily life, like during daydreaming, when extremely tired, when fasting, having slept too little or too long, or when influenced by fever or a medicine or another external agent, which by no means is pathologic in a psychiatric sense. The decisive factor for how she experiences this phenomenon emotionally is her cognitive labeling of what happens. Therefore, helping the woman to interpret the process correctly is meaningful. However, during this process, and especially in critical moments when the child’s or her own health is in danger, much of the staff’s attention is concentrated on the woman’s and the child’s physical conditions, even if that is at the expense of their attentiveness toward the mother’s mental state. In any case, even when she receives correct information, in connection with labor and delivery, the stress can become so intense that she dissociates in a pestiferous sense, e.g., when it is part of extreme anxiety like during a panic attack. See DSM-5 for the description of the symptoms of a panic attack [26].

Dissociation can be summarized in simple words as when the woman experiences either or both:



  • A feeling of being outside her body and its feelings (depersonalization)


  • A feeling that everything is unreal—like in a dream (derealization)

Although dissociation is seen as a way to escape from extreme stress and anxiety, reality testing is intact, and thus dissociation can at the same time in itself be very frightening, as absolutely any control is lost, and the woman can think that she has become crazy. Postpartum, such an experience can become a part of a childbirth-linked posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Therefore, it is recommended to notice dissociation during delivery as possibly harmful when it goes together with severe anxiety, and/or postpartum is seen by the woman as (part of) a traumatic experience.

Severe CA does not automatically disappear after the delivery and becomes most alive when a woman considers a new pregnancy. Nor does a psychologically perfect accomplished delivery, following a traumatic delivery that gave postpartum phobic CA, “treat” the phobic CA. The intensity of a phobic anxiety, also of severe CA, varies with the distance to the phobic stimulus. Thus, an untreated phobic CA re-intensifies when a woman considers a new pregnancy or is pregnant again.


1.7.1.3 What Are the Risk Factors for Childbirth Anxiety?



Risk Factors and Consequences: Vicious Cycles Everywhere

We found that women with the highest levels of CA during gestation, as measured by the W-DEQ, also had the highest CA during and after delivery [3, 36], which was unrelated to obstetric complications [8]. A vicious cycle phenomenon also seems to be the pattern for mental health problems connected to pregnancy and delivery at large. Many women with severe CA have already had mental problems in their lives [3740], and consequently even during pregnancy, several also have other anxiety disorders [11]. In general, mental disorders such as anxiety and depression are most noticeable during the reproductive age for women [4042]. This means that during this life period, negative affect is widespread among women, making them extra vulnerable for developing severe CA when pregnant. Consequently, previous mental problems such as anxiety and depression are risk factors for severe CA during pregnancy.


1.7.1.4 How Much Does Childbirth Anxiety Influence the Process of Labor?


Some studies show that severe CA is associated with obstetric complications such as prolonged labor, instrumental vaginal deliveries, and cesarean sections [10, 43, 44], although this is not found in all studies [4, 6].

As we have argued [45], very little is known about possible links between the level of fear women experience and the physiological functioning during the process of labor and delivery. As the endocrine system is essential for the well functioning of the different steps in the delivery process, we measured CA and stress hormones hourly during the process of labor and delivery, but could not find a systematic correlation between the two variables [34].

However, women’s CA may influence deliveries in another way, i.e., by the reaction to her fear by obstetric health providers. Already in the 1980s [46] and three decades later [34], we found that during delivery, a staff’s standard response to CA is offering pain relief, which may conceal the problem of fear. Throughout the last decade, CA is regarded as the main reason for the increasing number of cesarean sections (CS) on maternal request [4749].

In Western countries, severe CA has caused a significant increase of CS without medical reasons [50, 51]. This trend is not without concern, since CS implies higher short- and long-term risks for both mother and infant as compared to vaginal delivery [5256].

In many delicate situations, where obstetric caregivers are confronted with a pregnant woman panicking when only thinking of a vaginal delivery, an elective CS seems to be an easy way out. As it implies the greatest possible reinforcement for these women’s urges to escape delivery, most also will wish to end a following pregnancy by means of a CS [5, 49].

Sometimes, in acute situations, CS may be an emergency solution also for psychological reasons, but for handling a woman’s severe anxiety, this is an insufficient treatment. Moreover, pregnant women with severe CA, who get a CS on maternal request but do not have a treatment for their CA, run a risk to have a negative experience of their delivery anyway [46]. Therefore, such actions have to be completed with proper care for the woman’s CA, which will be discussed later.

After delivery, severe CA more often is found in women having had complications such as an instrumental vaginal delivery, emergency CS, or fetal compromise [6, 7, 10, 33, 57].

CA during labor and delivery is a risk factor for postpartum PTSD [30, 33, 58, 59]: Extreme fear (panic) can be so overwhelming that women experience the delivery as a trauma. Then, anxiety-vulnerable women may develop postpartum PTSD [60].

For many women, pregnancy, labor, and delivery are a challenge, and for some women the endeavors carry a price by affecting their mental condition with a risk for postpartum psychiatric problems [37] and difficulties in a healthy mother-child bonding [46]. It has been found that for a notable number of women with panic disorder, their panic started during pregnancy or soon after delivery [61].

Although it earlier has been hard to show how anxiety during gestation is related to delivery outcome and the condition of the child, the study results of Andersson et al. [62] revealed no differences in neonatal outcome between women with antenatal depressive disorders and/or anxiety disorders and healthy subjects. The authors conclude that neonatal outcome did not deteriorate despite the women’s impaired mental health during pregnancy.

It is unclear if and how CA directly influences the biologic process of labor and delivery. According to recent reviews, it becomes increasingly evident that at least there might be a relation between anxiety during pregnancy and preterm birth [63, 64].


1.7.2 Caregivers’ Communication and Collaboration with Women with Childbirth Anxiety


Most likely, obstetric caregivers have generally spoken have difficulties in handling severe CA, which in Western countries probably has been the reason for an increasing number of elective CS [50].


1.7.2.1 What Can Be Expected from Obstetrical Health-Care Providers in Diagnostic and Assessment Procedures of Severe Childbirth Anxiety?



Diagnostic and Assessment Procedures: For Whom to Carry Through?

In the preceding sections, we have shown in depth the details of anxiety and anxiety disorders and the place of severe and phobic CA among them. Severe CA is a serious mental problem and phobic CA a psychiatric disorder, even though the situation regards pregnancy and delivery—the field of obstetrics.

Severe CA is often strongly related to other mental difficulties that are easily overlooked when the caregiver does not have the right clinical psychological or psychiatric competence, although by now it is well known that such problems greatly affect the patient’s mental condition during pregnancy and, if not properly treated, implies at least for the patient herself a great risk for serious mental problems for a long time after delivery. Therefore, it is advised that the obstetric staff routinely screen for CA and that those women who are screened positive are further diagnosed by caregivers with appropriate competence. This means that obstetricians and midwives need to collaborate with clinical psychologists and psychiatrists. In addition, measurements such as the W-DEQ are useful tools in finding women with CA, but they cannot replace proper diagnostics.


1.7.2.2 What Are the Problems in Disclosure of Severe CA?


We have classified CA in its extreme form as a specific phobia. Among the mental problems, specific phobia is probably the most widespread with a lifetime prevalence of 11 % [65] and of all anxiety disorders, probably the best understood [66] and best treatable [29, 67, 68]. In general, persons with phobias hardly seek help for their problems, possibly because they can find ways to avoid the object they fear. It is also probable that phobia, and even more so subclinical fear, is so common that sufferers get used to its existence and find strategies to live with it and confine themselves to living with their phobia. Nevertheless specific phobia can have serious consequences, especially in its severe form and when the phobic stimulus cannot be avoided.

These general aspects also count for women with childbirth phobia who turn up in obstetric care when pregnant. However, here the phobic patient often expresses her anxiety by means of worries about her physical condition and all the bodily dangers and suffering that might occur during labor and delivery. These, in interaction with the caregivers’ reactions, develop a kind of obstetrification of CA, where the patient seems to demand from caregivers measures to ensure her and her fetus’ health, and caregivers try to answer the woman’s anxiety with (inappropriate/insufficient) obstetric measures.

In addition, this interaction comes with the woman’s way of expressing her need for help by rephrasing her anxiety as fear of pain [36, 46]. It is well known that help-seeking patients try to formulate their questions in such a way that they think the care system will understand and for which the system is able to offer remedies [35]. Concentration on pain can be a manner for an anxious woman to win approval for her apprehension and helplessness, as pain is a topic that is often discussed before and during labor. For both the woman with CA and her caregiver, pain is a rewarding topic. The woman can formulate a clear question about a topic that fits the frame of reference of the caregiver, not the least being that obstetrics in Western countries nowadays can offer advanced pain relief, and thus the staff can feel reassured that the woman’s request has been adequately met. Interestingly, severe pain almost always reflexively generates an acute panic-like reaction that can be sedated by means of pain relief. Thus, during the delivery, psychologically and pain-generated panic easily can be mixed up. Accordingly, in various studies we have found that during childbirth women with severe CA get significantly more pain relief than others [34, 46].

In obstetric care, practically all service is concentrated on the physical condition of the mother and the fetus. Even childbirth-preparing classes focus on these aspects. Generally spoken, this is logical and adequate. Midwives and obstetricians are educated to attend to the care of the pregnant woman and her fetus, with responsibility for the gestational aspects of the well-being of the woman and her child. As the physical condition of the woman is the main goal for obstetrics, CA may easily be marginalized. When midwives and obstetricians are preoccupied with the woman’s physical condition, her CA is easily overlooked, as “a certain amount of CA is normal and should be tolerated,” thereby minimizing the communication about fear when a woman signals CA.

But also the reverse can be the case. For a pregnant woman, statistically speaking, there are risks for real dangers for her own and the child’s well-being, and therefore she may think that her fears are appropriate, and she will focus on medical assistance. A caregiver’s rewording of such worries into a discussion about the woman’s anxiety can easily be experienced as a playdown of her concerns. There is a real risk for a conflict between the patient expressing her beliefs and the caregivers’ more accurate estimation of these threats. In that case it will be difficult to motivate the patient for psychological treatment. Moreover, to center upon her mental state would also mean a confrontation with the discomfort she wants to reduce and preferably manages by means of avoidance.

Consequently, proper discussions of the patient’s CA easily go astray in concord between staff and patient. When a patient expresses her worry, caregivers use to literally concentrate on the content of the patient’s questions, answering with comforting reassurance, which often may be helpful for subclinical fear, but is no effective remedy for clinical anxiety. There is plenty of experience with patients who somatisize, that frequent medical consultations met with reassurances or even physical tests can make the patient even more eager to come back for new consultations, as these actions only give temporary relief [35].

At least in Western countries, women trust obstetric staff and expect to get all the service they need in connection with their pregnancy and delivery. Staff, doing their best to reassure the woman, promotes this impression. And therefore this idea is nurtured in harmony. This is particularly suitable for those women who want to avoid getting in touch with their CA until the last minute, telling themselves that “it’s going to work out.” An additional aspect is the belief that childbirth anxiety only exists during pregnancy and automatically vanishes after delivery, only she endures until she has given birth. At the end of gestation, these women can find themselves in a situation where their CA finally erupts in full swing, while time for psychological treatment has run out. The risk for a traumatic delivery is then impending, with negative consequences for the woman’s postpartum mental health.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 17, 2017 | Posted by in GYNECOLOGY | Comments Off on A Woman Afraid to Deliver: How to Manage Childbirth Anxiety

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access